Review: My Book Mirror Edition RAIDs your data

Western Digital's new desktop storage system offers a 1TB dual-disk enclosure with RAID for under $600.

There's no such thing as too much protection for your valuable files. Although external hard drives can provide backup copies of files on your hard drive, what if you use external drives for primary storage? Sure, you can use yet another external backup drive, but a better solution might be a RAID array with two drives. Western Digital offers such a system with its new My Book Mirror Edition ($549.99).

Packed inside a 6.5-by-6.1-by-3.9-in. black enclosure are two hard drives that connect to your system via a single USB 2.0 port. The My Book is preconfigured as a single Windows NTFS partition using RAID 1 (mirrored) mode for a total capacity of 1TB. Files saved to this "primary" partition are automatically copied to the "secondary" drive, which is hidden from view. In fact, files on the second drive can't be directly viewed by, say, a file manager, and cannot be accessed from applications). An additional note: Mac users must reformat the NTFS drive to HFS+ (Journaled) or FAT32 formats.

If you're not interested in RAID mirroring and prefer a single 2TB drive, you can use the included WD RAID Manager software (there are separate versions for Windows and Mac systems) to switch to RAID 0 (striped) mode. You gain the full storage capacity of both drives combined into what appears to your system to be a single drive, but there's no mirroring of your data.

Installation is a simple matter of plugging in the power and USB cables. When you insert the accompanying utility disk into a CD drive to begin installation of the RAID management software, the installer automatically (and silently) installs the WD Drive Manager software. After that, if you mouse over the WD Drive Manager icon placed in your System Tray, you can see basic facts about the drive: Percentage used, RAID configuration (0 or 1) and status of the drive (healthy, RAID 1 degraded and so on).

Right-click on the WD Drive Manager icon and you can launch the WD RAID Manager to see specific property information, including the serial numbers of each drive, each drive's status (for example, whether the installed drive isn't RAID compatible or is missing) and each drive's RAID status (for example, whether it's degraded or there's a RAID rebuild in progress). WD RAID Manager is also the tool you'll use to switch between RAID modes 0 and 1 (doing so erases all data on both drives, however).

The utility disk also offers automatic backup software that continuously monitors your system. When you save a file (for example, to your system's C: drive), it automatically backs up the file to the My Book's "primary" drive. If you have RAID 1 enabled, then the system makes a third copy of the file on the second drive on the My Book that's only accessible if the primary drive fails. If a file becomes corrupted or deleted on your PC's C: drive, the recovery process is not automatic; you have to restore the file back to the C: drive yourself by using the backup software's "Restore Files" option.

Packed inside a 6.5-by-6.1-by-3.9-in. black enclosure are two hard drives that connect to your system via a single USB 2.0 port. The My Book is preconfigured as a single Windows NTFS partition using RAID 1 (mirrored) mode for a total capacity of 1TB.
My Book Mirror Edition

A vertical-lighted blue strip (divided into four segments or bars) on the front of the drive enclosure serves several purposes. When constantly lit, the drive is powered on. If it flashes every four seconds, that indicates the drive is in standby mode. If the top and bottom bars flash, then one of the drives is having problems and you need to take action (such as replacing the drive). The four segments also light up when the drive initially powers up; one is lit for every one-fourth of total of capacity used.

In addition to the software CD (which includes the user guide in PDF), the drive comes with a USB cable and AC adapter. The drive automatically powers up and down in sync with your system.

When I checked the drive's capacity, Windows XP SP3 found 931.51GB (technically that's just over 1 trillion bytes). I tested the drive with HD Tach 3.0 from Simpli Software. Using its thorough "Long Bench" test (using 32KB blocks for reads and writes across the entire drive), the benchmark registered 31.9MB/sec. burst speed, an average read speed of 28.6MB/sec. and CPU utilization of 16%. That compares favorably with the Buffalo DriveStation Combo 4 that I recently reviewed (see "Review: The DriveStation Combo 4 is very well connected ").

Using Version 2.55 of the HD Tune benchmark test, I saw an average transfer rate of 27.0MB/sec., 16.3 ms average access time and a burst rate of 23.0MB/sec. using 15.5% of the CPU, which is average for a drive of this size.

Copying a 1GB MPEG file on my hard drive to the My Book (when configured as RAID 1 took 53 seconds.

According to Western Digital, the My Book uses a convection cooling architecture that keeps the drives cool without fans and uses one third less power than competing drives. I can attest to its cool and quiet operation.

You can open the top of the enclosure and replace either drive (though you're limited to using "WD Caviar GP hard drive assemblies," according to the user manual). The My Book starts the rebuild process automatically; rebuilds usually take between five and seven hours, according to Western Digital, but can take up to 12 hours.

The drive includes a three-year warranty. The company also sells a 500GB model (1TB as RAID 0) for $289.99.

Sometimes you just can't protect valuable files enough. Whether you use the "primary" drive of the My Book (and rely on RAID 1 to make a second copy on the "hidden" secondary drive) or use the included backup software to make an additional copy of files on your system's built-in hard drive (using RAID 0) or two copies (with RAID 1 enabled), the quiet, fast and easy-to-set-up My Book gives you the best and simplest data protection in a user-friendly drive I've seen.

Rich Ericson is a northwest-based technology writer and is the reviews editor of The Office Letter, a site devoted to tips for Microsoft Office.

Copyright © 2008 IDG Communications, Inc.

7 inconvenient truths about the hybrid work trend
Shop Tech Products at Amazon