Who's the Smartest of Them All?
Social software uncovers the true experts.
Computerworld - Before building a walkway through a garden, college campus or office park, an experienced landscaper carefully studies where people walk naturally to discover the best routes between popular destinations.
Hewlett-Packard Co. researcher Bernardo Huberman and his team at the Systems Research Center at HP Labs are using a similar strategy to study how e-mail flows through organizations. The idea is to uncover natural "communities of interest" that can be tapped to make smarter decisions and more accurate business predictions.
Using an algorithm that measures "betweeness centrality" -- a measure of the prominence of individuals in a social network -- Huberman and his team classified hundreds of thousands of e-mail messages by how they traveled within certain HP divisions. They discovered that day-to-day work was often accomplished by self-selected teams of people who don't show up as a group on a formal organization chart. They theorized that members of the groups actually made up de facto teams of experts whose business decisions would outperform those of the formal experts.
To prove the theory, Huberman and his collaborators had 15 HP managers distributed around the globe place bets on projected monthly revenue and profit figures for an HP division. The research team developed an algorithm to account for variations in the managers' attitudes toward risk. As an incentive, Huberman also provided the managers with a small amount of cash that would increase or decrease, depending on the accuracy of their predictions.
Accurate Predictions
In the end, the group of managers consistently predicted the financial outcomes more accurately than an expert financial software tool the division had been using to forecast the figures.
Huberman says the test could also be conducted by pitting the informal group against a formal group of decision-makers, and the results would be the same. The reason is that the information used to predict a business outcome is aggregated from the best possible sources, even though their high level of knowledge may not be reflected in their job titles.
He also notes that only nominal incentives are needed to persuade undeclared experts to do their best. "Just putting up a little bit of money -- less than $100 -- makes people behave differently," Huberman says. Moreover, money isn't necessarily a requirement. "People in companies are concerned about their status. If they predict well, call them 'dukes' or 'barons.' There are ways to enhance people's status other than giving them financial compensation," he says.
Brian Whitworth, a researcher and assistant professor of information systems at the New Jersey Institute of


- Excel 2010 Cheat Sheet
- Register for this Computerworld Insider Cheat Sheet and gain access to hundreds of premium content articles, guides, product reviews and more.
- Switching Schedulers - Not As Complicated As You Think
- Changing or consolidating job schedulers may seem daunting. However, the benefits of switching to enterprise workload automation outweigh the risks. Read how BMC...
- Capture-Enabled Business Process Management
- Organizations today must deal with a vast amount of incoming information from many different sources. Efficient, automated business processes are critical to managing...
- Using Case Management to Empower Employees and transform Customer Service
- This Kofax paper shows how successful customer service organizations have transformed customer service by empowering their employees. We will see how Dynamic Case...
- Case Study: Audi-Volkswagen Improves Procurement Control
- Audi-Volkswagen required a user-friendly, easy-to-use Business Process Management system that did not require programming skills or high levels of technical expertise in-house. This...
- AIIM Market Intelligence: The paper-free office, dream or reality?
- In this Aiim Market Intelligence report, produced in association with Kofax, we look at the success of paper-elimination projects, where and why paper...
- Live Webcast
How to Reduce Complexity and Automate Your Partners for Efficient E-Business: - Date: Tuesday, June 5, 2012, 2:00 PM EDT
Whether your B2B complexity is caused by multiple technologies due to M&A, business or application specific... - Live Webcast
Data Privacy and Protection in Production Environments: New Research from Ponemon Institute - Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012, 1:00 PM EDT / 10:00 AM PDT
In a recent study conducted by Ponemon Institute, fifty-five percent of respondents... - Live Webcast
A Geek's Guide to Presenting to Business People - Live Webcast: Wednesday, June 20th at 1:00 PM EDT
Join this live webinar with Paul Glen, author of Leading Geeks, to learn how to... - BMC Control-M - Single Point of Control Demo
- With BMC Control-M, you schedule and manage everything - down to the very last platform and application - from one simple interface. It's...
- BMC Control-M - Single Point of Control Demo
- With BMC Control-M, you schedule and manage everything - down to the very last platform and application - from one simple interface. It's...
- Sun Chemical Customer Success Story
- Sun Chemical, the world's largest producer of printing inks and pigments, quadrupled its complex batch environment with zero extra headcount using BMC Control-M's...
- Service-Enabling CICS Applications: Best Practices
- This informative webcast provides an informed, thorough look into CICS service-enablement options and how they can affect your environment. You'll learn how to...
- Teaching Legacy Application Elephants How to Dance
- This four-minute video podcast shows how you can create services to continuously reuse enterprise applications, however and whenever needed, while leaving legacy logic...