Skip the navigation

University researchers challenge Bush win in Florida

'Something went awry with electronic voting in Florida,' says the lead researcher

By Dan Verton
November 18, 2004 12:00 PM ET

Computerworld - Researchers at the University of California, Berkeley, said today that they have uncovered statistical irregularities associated with electronic voting machines in three Florida counties that may have given President George W. Bush 130,000 or more excess votes. The researchers are now calling on state and federal authorities to look into the problems.
The study, "The Effect of Electronic Voting Machines on Change in Support for Bush in the 2004 Florida Elections," was conducted by doctoral students and faculty from the university's sociology department and led by sociology professor Michael Hout.
Hout is an expert on statistical methods at the Berkeley Survey Research Center and a member of the National Academy of Sciences.
According to the study, counties with electronic voting machines were significantly more likely to show increases in support for Bush between 2000 and 2004 compared to counties with paper ballots or optical scan equipment. This change cannot be explained by differences between counties in income, number of voters, change in voter turnout, or size of the Hispanic/Latino population, said Hout.
In Broward County, for example, Bush appears to have received approximately 72,000 excess votes, Hout said, adding that the research team is 99.9% sure that these effects are not attributable to chance. The other two counties that experienced unexplained statistical discrepancies in the vote are Miami-Dade and Palm Beach. The three counties revealed the most significant irregularities and were the most heavily Democratic counties in the state. Smaller counties that showed strong support for Bush didn't produce any statistical anomalies, Hout said.
"For the sake of all future elections involving e-voting systems, someone must investigate and explain the statistical anomaly we found in Florida," Hout said at a news conference today.

The researchers said they used a widely accepted method of study known as Multiple-Regression Analysis. It is a statistical technique widely used in the social and physical sciences to distinguish the individual effects of many variables, which in this case included number of voters, median income, Hispanic population, change in voter turnout between 2000 and 2004, support for President Bush in the 2000 election and support for Republican candidate Bob Dole in 1996.
"No matter how many factors and variables we took into consideration, the significant correlation in the votes for President Bush and electronic voting cannot be explained," said Hout. "The study shows that a county's use of electronic voting resulted in a disproportionate increase in votes for President Bush. There is just a trivial probability of evidence like this appearing in a population where the



Legislation/Regulation

Additional Resources
Advancing Knowledge Sharing with Google: The LSNC Story
WEBCAST
In the modern work environment, knowledge sharing has become paramount to organizational success, given the geographic dispersion, mobility, and information overload. During this session, Legal Services of Northern California (LSNC) will discuss their recent knowledge sharing transformation. With employees across 14 offices, servicing one-third of California, and having to access information across a million documents, the challenge was daunting. To address this, LSNC tapped Google's expertise on enterprise search and cloud computing, and deployed a knowledge-content system.
Cost-Effective Virtualization Security
WHITE PAPER
Trend Micro(tm) Virtualization Security solutions deliver advanced security software to protect operating systems, applications and data on virtual and cloud servers to help ensure compliance, while allowing higher server consolidation rates, and maximizing performance and operational flexibility. With Trend Micro software deployed on your physical servers and virtual machines, your IT infrastructure receives comprehensive and integrated protection.
The Laptop Dilemma: How to Maximize Productivity and Lower the Burden on IT
WHITE PAPER
New era of mobile computing creates opportunities for remote productivity while next-generation, industry-standard technologies address management and data security. Read more in this white paper.
Gov't Legislation/Regulation White Papers
SMART Steps Toward Consolidated Workload Automation
Consolidating job scheduling into a single, comprehensive workload automation solution is a critical first step to effective workload automation (WLA). But without tight...
Workload Automation: Helping Cloud Computing Take Flight
With the right workload automation solutions, business can take much greater advantage of cloud computing, achieving faster time-to-market, reduced costs, and more flexible...
The Evolving Role of Disk and Tape
Disk-based solutions for data protection have opened up new storage options for organizations. The question should not be whether to choose disk or...
Securing Sensitive Information
Encryption of tape data can safeguard information. Implementing LTO-4 tape drive encryption is a relatively simple process and ensures that sensitive data is...
Clipper Notes: Disk and Tape Square Off Again
This Clipper Group report examines a 5 year cost of ownership study for tape and disk for long term storage. It compares and...
All Gov't Legislation/Regulation White Papers
Gov't Legislation/Regulation Webcasts
Live Webcast
Breaking Down the Top Five Barriers to Maximizing Virtualization Efficiency
Virtualization has the potential to deliver exceptional benefits in agility, cost, and quality. However, robust management is the critical discipline needed in order...
Live Webcast
Red Hat Enterprise Linux on HP ProLiant and BladeSystem Servers
In this session, HP and Red Hat speakers will explain how to prepare for and execute an effective migration from SPARC/Solaris OS-based systems...
Guiding Principles for Healthcare in Transformation
EMC Consulting has developed guiding principles for information technology in healthcare provider institutions. These aren't technical points. They're the kinds of guidelines that...
Desktop virtualization keys innovation drive
View now.
Guiding iPhone into the business world
Watch now.
Radical virtualization brings new benefits to...
Watch now.
Virtualization @ the speed of business
Watch now.
All Gov't Legislation/Regulation Webcasts
IT Jobs