Ads by TechWords

See your link here
Receive the latest technology news and information.
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
Cloud Computing
View all newsletters




Privacy Policy
 

A Patent Strain on Innovation

October 4, 2004 12:00 PM ET

Computerworld - Some things are patently ridiculous. One is the U.S. patent system, an institution in desperate need of reform.
The reason for patents is to encourage innovation. We give inventors exclusive rights to their creations for a limited period, after which the inventions enter the public domain.
In the real world, patents are also about politics, mismanagement and slippery behavior. The results may be damaging to our economic and cultural health. Patents are supposed to be issued for actual inventions -- for new methods and machines that are, crucially, not obvious. Too many patents are being awarded for "inventions" that aren't new or are blatantly obvious.
The technology business is rife with bad patents. A couple of years ago, BT Group claimed to own a patent on hyperlinking, a concept that long predated the company's application. This bizarre notion was, thankfully, shot down in a U.S. courtroom, but not before SBC Communications spent a lot of money defending its right to use the technology.
Microsoft lost a trial in which a small Illinois company, Eolas Technologies, claimed to own fundamental technology for browser plug-ins. The U.S. Patent & Trademark Office (PTO) is re-examining that case, which many in the Web community believe is an example of a patent that should never have been issued in the first place.
Then there are the "business method" patents -- essentially, online translations of analog activities. The most infamous is Amazon.com's "one-click" shopping patent, but there are lots of other egregious examples.
There's plenty of blame to go around on this. But the chief culprits are the PTO, which by nearly every credible account doesn't sufficiently analyze the applications it gets, and Congress, which allows this to persist.
To be fair to the PTO, it is laboring under handicaps. For example, Congress doesn't let the agency use all the money it generates in fees to improve the patent process. But the PTO's attitude has been compared, accurately, to that of a polluter. The agency, which considers patent applicants -- not the public -- to be its main constituency, hands out patents willy-nilly and lets the courts sort out the mess that results.
IT has a serious stake in this. The intellectual property dust-up over Linux seems likely to be the tip of a nasty iceberg, with patent holders (especially Microsoft, I suspect) potentially using threats about alleged infringement to scare people away from open-source software. And companies developing their products are increasingly filing for patents on everything that moves, mostly for defensive reasons. Wouldn't you



Jump to comments

Legislation/Regulation

Additional Resources

EFD vs. HDD - What You Need to Know
WHITE PAPER
Enterprise flash drives provide a new Tier 0 storage layer capable of delivering high I/O performance at a very low latency. Proper use of EFDs in an Oracle environment can deliver increased performance compared to fibre channel drives. Read the recommendations for identification of the best DB components for EFDs.
Gartner Research Report: Magic Quadrant for Application Delivery Controllers, 2009
WHITE PAPER
The market for products to improve the delivery of application software over networks remains dynamic and innovative. Vendors focused on solving enterprises' most-pressing application problems have become the top players.
Eight Criteria for Server Load Balancing
WHITE PAPER
Server load balancers are a simple yet highly effective means to scale an application environment while ensuring its availability. Today's solutions should also address application performance and security. Read about the top eight criteria you should consider when choosing a server load balancer and how Citrix NetScaler meets those requirements.

White Papers & Webcasts

The Workday User Experience Video
Watch Workday's Creative Director, Scott Lietzke, discuss the business-centered design philosophy at Workday.

Business Process Framework Demo
Learn about Configurable Business Processes and Calculated Fields. Watch Now!

Manager Experience Demo
Go beyond self-service solutions to perform more effectively. Watch Now.


IT Jobs