Computerworld - Some things are patently ridiculous. One is the U.S. patent system, an institution in desperate need of reform.
The reason for patents is to encourage innovation. We give inventors exclusive rights to their creations for a limited period, after which the inventions enter the public domain.
In the real world, patents are also about politics, mismanagement and slippery behavior. The results may be damaging to our economic and cultural health. Patents are supposed to be issued for actual inventions -- for new methods and machines that are, crucially, not obvious. Too many patents are being awarded for "inventions" that aren't new or are blatantly obvious.
The technology business is rife with bad patents. A couple of years ago, BT Group claimed to own a patent on hyperlinking, a concept that long predated the company's application. This bizarre notion was, thankfully, shot down in a U.S. courtroom, but not before SBC Communications spent a lot of money defending its right to use the technology.
Microsoft lost a trial in which a small Illinois company, Eolas Technologies, claimed to own fundamental technology for browser plug-ins. The U.S. Patent & Trademark Office (PTO) is re-examining that case, which many in the Web community believe is an example of a patent that should never have been issued in the first place.
Then there are the "business method" patents -- essentially, online translations of analog activities. The most infamous is Amazon.com's "one-click" shopping patent, but there are lots of other egregious examples.
There's plenty of blame to go around on this. But the chief culprits are the PTO, which by nearly every credible account doesn't sufficiently analyze the applications it gets, and Congress, which allows this to persist.
To be fair to the PTO, it is laboring under handicaps. For example, Congress doesn't let the agency use all the money it generates in fees to improve the patent process. But the PTO's attitude has been compared, accurately, to that of a polluter. The agency, which considers patent applicants -- not the public -- to be its main constituency, hands out patents willy-nilly and lets the courts sort out the mess that results.
IT has a serious stake in this. The intellectual property dust-up over Linux seems likely to be the tip of a nasty iceberg, with patent holders (especially Microsoft, I suspect) potentially using threats about alleged infringement to scare people away from open-source software. And companies developing their products are increasingly filing for patents on everything that moves, mostly for defensive reasons. Wouldn't you


- Excel 2010 Cheat Sheet
- Register for this Computerworld Insider Cheat Sheet and gain access to hundreds of premium content articles, guides, product reviews and more.
- Practice Management: Double Billing Rate and Improve Patient Services
- Would you like to double your billing rate and achieve faster payment for services?
Download this customer success story to see how One Health... - Mission Critical Data Explosion and Customer Case Study
- Would you like to double your tier 1 storage capacity while simultaneously reducing your storage footprint?
Download this customer success story to see how... - Protecting Against Database Attacks and Insider Threats: Top 5 Scenarios
- Read this new eBook to learn the top five scenarios and essential best practices for preventing database attacks and insider threats.
- Database Activity Monitoring Is Evolving
- Read the analyst report and learn how you can leverage the core capabilities of a DAP solution for better database security.
- Establishing a Strategy for Database Security is No Longer Optional
- The options for securing increasingly valuable databases are very broad and deep, and can be confusing. This research provides an overview of three...
- Live Webcast
Data Privacy and Protection in Production Environments: New Research from Ponemon Institute - Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012, 1:00 PM EDT / 10:00 AM PDT
In a recent study conducted by Ponemon Institute, fifty-five percent of respondents... - Live Webcast
A Geek's Guide to Presenting to Business People - Live Webcast: Wednesday, June 20th at 1:00 PM EDT
Join this live webinar with Paul Glen, author of Leading Geeks, to learn how to... - Live Webcast
Today's NAS: A Solution Beyond Old Limits - Date: Tuesday, July 17, 2012 2:00 PM EDT
Traditional NAS systems don't scale beyond fixed limits. Proliferation of NAS systems leads to management... - Distributed Database Security with Real-time Monitoring
- View this demo and learn how IBM InfoSphere Guardium database activity monitoring can help protect your sensitive data in distributed DBMS environments with...
- InfoSphere Warehouse Packs Demo
- These flash modules make warehousing more tangible and relevant to business users through detailed explanations of the InfoSphere Warehouse Packs.
- Delivery Management -- Extending Lifecycle Management
- Date: Wednesday, June 20, 2012, 1:00 PM EDT
Siloed organizations continue doing the wrong things and doing things wrong, leading to increased costs,... - Leverage automation today to reduce IT complexity
- Date: Tuesday, June 5, 2012, 2:00 PM EDT
Whether your B2B complexity is caused by multiple technologies due to M&A, business or application specific... - Redefine Expectations in the Data Center
- Need to do more with less? Watch this video to learn how HP ProLiant Gen8 servers can help your business deploy servers three...