SAP: Oracle-PeopleSoft merger would boost competition
An SAP official said the merger would make Oracle No. 1 in the enterprise apps market
IDG News Service - An Oracle-PeopleSoft merger would boost competition in the market for enterprise applications, an SAP America Inc. executive testified today in the U.S. government's case to block the proposed merger.
"We anticipate a greater amount of competitiveness," said Richard Knowles, vice president of SAP America, a subsidiary of Germany's SAP AG. Knowles was called in federal court in San Francisco by Oracle Corp., which is challenging the U.S. government's attempt to block its $7.7 billion hostile bid for rival PeopleSoft Inc.
During questioning by an Oracle attorney, Knowles also said all SAP buyers have high functional needs and that SAP competes against numerous vendors, not just PeopleSoft and Oracle. The testimony undermines the U.S. Department of Justice's argument that only Oracle, PeopleSoft and SAP can meet the human resources and financial management software needs of large, complex organizations.
In the U.S., SAP currently holds 34% of the enterprise application market, Knowles testified. If the acquisition of PeopleSoft by Oracle goes through, Oracle would have 38% of the market, leaping SAP, he said.
"Oracle would become the No. 1 provider in the U.S. and would do anything to keep that position. We, from an SAP position, think that would be highly competitive for us," Knowles testified. "We're going to see more salespeople being marshaled into a position competing against us."
Still, asked if SAP has a position on the merger, he said the enterprise applications giant is "neutral."
The answer appeared to surprise Judge Vaughn Walker, who oversees the case. The direct question of whether SAP would mind if one large competitor was eliminated because it was folded into another wasn't asked.
The DOJ doesn't see Knowles' testimony hurting its case, said Thomas Barnett, deputy assistant attorney general, speaking during a break in Knowles' testimony.
"The notion that two competitors are going to be better than three competitors does not follow," Barnett said. "Customers have consistently testified that they would prefer three options, rather than two. I put more weight on the customers."
The DOJ's argument is that Oracle, PeopleSoft and SAP dominate the market for human resources and financial management applications and that an Oracle-PeopleSoft merger would create a duopoly, hurting competition and resulting in escalating prices. Oracle's argument is that there are several other viable vendors in the segment such as Lawson Software Inc., American Management Systems Inc. and Microsoft Corp.
The DOJ has yet to cross-examine Knowles. The head of Microsoft's Business Solutions group, Doug Burgum, was scheduled to take the stand later today. Burgum was expected to testifythat Microsoft doesn't target the high end of the enterprise applications market and focuses instead on small and midsize businesses.



- Excel 2010 Cheat Sheet
- Register for this Computerworld Insider Cheat Sheet and gain access to hundreds of premium content articles, guides, product reviews and more.
- Forrester Total Economic Impact (TEI) Case Study - Oracle
- In this paper, Forrester Consulting examines the total economic impact and potential return on investment (ROI) realized by three Enterprise organizations as they...
- The Hidden Truth About Virtualizing Business-Critical Applications
- This IDG whitepaper highlights key findings based on the Quickpoll Survey conducted with more than 300 Enterprise and Commercial IT decision makers worldwide...
- Top 10 Myths About Virtualizing Business-Critical Applications
- Even though virtualization has brought positive change to enterprise IT over the last decade, some skepticism remains about how valuable virtualization can be...
- Enterprise Java Applications on VMware: Unix to Linux Migration Guide
- This guide focuses on key considerations for IT Architects who are in the process of migrating Java applications from UNIX to Linux as...
- Virtualizing Tier 1 Applications: A Critical Step on the Journey Toward the Private Cloud
- This IDC white paper explains how much of the Enterprise IT community is at a crossroads in extending their journey to the private... All Applications White Papers
- Live Webcast
Banish Poor Application Performance: Eliminate Business Disruptions, Increase End User Productivity - End User Experience, 30-Min Webinar
Wed. Feb. 22nd ~ 11 AM ET
Are you ready to gain the proactive ability to rapidly respond... - Apps QuickStart Series Part 2: Designing and Deploying SQL Server on VMware vSphere
- Download this webcast to learn about the design considerations for virtualizing SQL workloads, performance and scalability information and high-availability options, as well as...
- Apps QuickStart Series Part 1: Designing and Deploying Exchange 2010 on VMware vSphere
- Download this webcast to learn the virtual hardware design considerations for Exchange 2010, deployment using the building block approach, options for high-availability and...
- Virtualize Business-Critical Applications with Confidence
- Virtualizing business-critical applications has become a key focus for organizations as they move along their virtualization journey. With the launch of VMware vSphere®...
- Discover the Benefits of Virtualization for Federal Applications
- Want to say goodbye to missed SLAs? VMware can help you virtualize mission-critical applications such as Oracle, MS Exchange and SharePoint to achieve...
- Reduce Application Lifecycle Management Costs with VMware ThinApp
- Traditional desktop application deployment and management is a time-consuming and costly endeavor for IT. From development to deployment, including help desk support, the... All Applications Webcasts