Skip the navigation

Oracle puts IBM, Microsoft execs on witness list

IBM's software chief, Steve Mills, is among those called to testify

By Stacy Cowley
May 19, 2004 12:00 PM ET

IDG News Service - Oracle Corp. plans to enlist IBM's software chief, Steve Mills, as a witness when the U.S. Department of Justice's case against Oracle's PeopleSoft Inc. takeover plan moves to trial in June
The witness list Oracle submitted to Judge Vaughn Walker yesterday is a roster of high-profile software executives, including Oracle's own CEO, Larry Ellison, and PeopleSoft CEO Craig Conway. Oracle's lawyers estimate that they will spend six hours grilling Conway on topics including the sustainability of PeopleSoft's business and the industry's competitive dynamics, according to the filing.
Along with academic experts and industry analysts, Oracle intends to boost its case with testimony from Siebel Systems Inc. product strategy leader David Schmaier; Microsoft Corp.'s U.S. small business general manager, Cindy Bates; and SAP AG executive Richard Knowles.
The DOJ also plans to tap officials from PeopleSoft, IBM and Microsoft to back its position, including Microsoft's business applications leader, Doug Burgum.
The DOJ is suing to block Oracle's tender offer to PeopleSoft's shareholders for control of the company (see story), an acquisition the DOJ says would unacceptably limit the buying options of large customers and hurt industry competitiveness.
While Oracle's witness list leans heavily on experts and representatives from other application vendors, the DOJ's list focuses on customers. The department intends to call representatives of more than a dozen companies to speak about their human resources and financial management system needs and about the likely impact on their organizations of an Oracle/PeopleSoft combination.
The trial for the DOJ lawsuit against Oracle is scheduled to commence June 7 in U.S. District Court in San Francisco.
Even if Oracle successfully counters the DOJ's opposition, it faces long odds on completing the PeopleSoft takeover it began pursuing almost a year ago. PeopleSoft's management remains bitterly opposed to the deal, and the company's shareholders aren't responding to Oracle's cash tender offer.
Last week, Oracle cut its per-share offer from $26 to $21 (see story), reducing to $7.7 billion the value of a bid that at one point had climbed to $9.4 billion. It said at the time that 7.9 million PeopleSoft shares had been validly tendered, representing about 2% of PeopleSoft's outstanding shares.
PeopleSoft and Oracle are also embroiled in a number of other legal cases related to Oracle's takeover attempt. A judge is set to hear in November PeopleSoft's lawsuit charging Oracle with libel and unfair competition.

Reprinted with permission from Story copyright 2014 International Data Group. All rights reserved.
Our Commenting Policies