Net neutrality: Reclassifying broadband would mean a long fight
Expect court challenges and a possible blacklash in Congress, if the agency regulates broadband as a utility
IDG News Service - Advocates of strong net neutrality rules are calling for the U.S. Federal Communications Commission to reclassify broadband as a regulated utility, but such a move would trigger a lengthy court fight between the agency and broadband providers, some telecom law experts say.
With net neutrality back on the FCC's agenda in recent weeks, many net neutrality advocates -- including digital rights groups Free Press and Public Knowledge -- have resurrected their long-time push for the FCC to reregulate broadband as a traditional telecom service as an alternative to FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler's proposed set of regulations, released in late April, that they view as too weak.
Despite a large public outcry -- the FCC has received more than 45,000 public comments in the past month, with many calling for reregulation -- some telecom law experts question whether the agency will take that step.
"People at the FCC refer to broadband reclassification as the nuclear option," said Jonathan Jacob Nadler, a telecom regulation lawyer with the Squire Sanders law firm in Washington, D.C. "It's just not going to happen."
The FCC, in a public notice of proposed rules released earlier this month, asked for comment on Wheeler's proposal, which would allow broadband carriers to engage in "commercially reasonable" traffic management, and also on whether the FCC should reclassify broadband as a common-carrier telecom service subject to utility-type regulations under Title II of the Telecommunications Act.
But Nadler and some other telecom regulation experts expect a huge legal backlash if the FCC moves toward Title II regulation. "If the FCC were to reclassify broadband as a telecom service, lawyers for the major telcos and cable systems would immediately start lining up in front of the court of appeals and would file petitions for review within minutes after the order was published," Nadler said.
Broadband providers would argue that reclassification is a "trillion-dollar bait-and-switch," said Scott Cleland, chairman of the NetCompetition advocacy group supported by broadband providers. Providers would argue that a change in classification would be arbitrary and capricious, the classic language of a challenge to agency regulations.
"Promising an industry light regulation to encourage $1.2 trillion in private risk capital investment, and then after it's built, breaking that promise, would be the [ultimate] arbitrary and capricious FCC action," Cleland added. "Expect a tsunami of legal challenges against any FCC reclassification decision in multiple courts pursuing multiple different legal challenges and theories in order to stay and overturn the FCC decision."
Harold Feld, senior vice president at Public Knowledge, downplayed potential arguments by broadband providers. In a handful of recent Supreme Court cases, justices have suggested the FCC has the authority to change its mind, he noted.
Net neutrality battle
- Net neutrality becomes a key battleground in encryption fight
- FCC swamped with last-minute comments on net neutrality
- Dems' plan would force FCC to ban Internet fast lanes
- How Tom Wheeler's FCC plan will wreck your Internet
- Inside the FCC's net neutrality notice
- FCC moves ahead with controversial net neutrality plan
- Net neutrality backers decide to 'occupy' the FCC
- Net neutrality advocates flood FCC Twitter chat
- Trade group, lawmaker question drive to classify broadband as a utility
- FCC chairman may revise his controversial plan on net neutrality
- Agility & Scalability for Oracle EBS R12 and RAC on VMware vSphere 5 This white paper outlines extensive performance and scalability testing of Oracle EBS applications on a Vblock™ Systems with vSphere 5.
- Oracle and VCE: The Next Step in Integrated Computing Platforms In this ESG Lab review you will learn how a VCE system driven by Oracle, delivers the perfect blend of high performance and...
- Migrate Oracle Apps from RISC/UNIX to Virtualized x86 Ready to move Oracle to a virtualized environment? This brief explains how true converged infrastructure can help you migrate from a RISC/UNIX environment...
- Step Out of the Bull's-Eye Learn about the evolution of targeted attacks, the latest in security intelligence, and strategic steps to keep your business safe.
- Keep Servers Up and Running and Attackers in the Dark An SSL/TLS handshake requires at least 10 times more processing power on a server than on the client. SSL renegotiation attacks can readily...
- On Demand: Mastering the Art of Mobile Content Management Mobile device usage in the enterprise has skyrocketed, and it continues to escalate. IT must answer to users who demand access to their... All Broadband White Papers | Webcasts