Firefox UI revamp sparks complaints, searches for alternatives
New 'Australis' look prompts some users to abandon browser or ask how they can restore the old UI
Computerworld - Some Firefox users, cranky about the overhaul of the browser's user interface, have scrambled to find ways to make the latest version look more like older editions.
Two weeks ago, Mozilla launched Firefox 29, the first production-grade version that sported the new "Australis" UI. The visual redesign, the most dramatic for Firefox since March 2011, was Mozilla's attempt to both streamline the browser's look and feel and standardize it across all platforms, from desktop to mobile.
Many of Australis' visual changes were subtle, such as more rounded tabs, inactive tabs that faded deeper into the background and a revamped customization panel. Australis also dumped the orange-colored Firefox menu in Windows, an element that first popped up in Firefox 4.
Some people balked at the changes.
"After updating to [Firefox] 29.0.1 I could barely use Firefox," complained a user identified as pdrummond on May 9, writing on MozillaZine, a third-party discussion board. "It's taken me an hour to get the UI back to a usable state and I'm more than a little annoyed."
"This is useless, please do not copy the Google Chrome," someone identified as imdawe said yesterday, also on MozillaZine. "WE DO NOT WANT GOOGLE CHROME UI. If we want that then we would use Google Chrome."
The this-looks-a-lot-like-Chrome complaint against Firefox's Australis has been widespread, and predated its appearance in Firefox 29.
Others cited more specific gripes, all tied to changes in Firefox's UI and a desire to restore older visual and navigational elements, like the page-reload button, the tab bar's position -- now above the address and search fields, not below them as before -- and the from-one-side-to-the-other relocation of the Firefox menu.
Some were quite explicit in their criticism. "Please add function to restore UI prior to 29.0 ... new UI is horse****," said bokstav on MozillaZine on May 9. A few compared Mozilla's redesign, which they felt was forced on them, to Microsoft's radical renovation of Windows with 2012's Windows 8. Those were not compliments.
Many commenters on MozillaZine, and on Mozilla's official support discussion forum, suggested installing Classic Theme Restorer, a Firefox add-on that spins back the clock by reverting many of the Australis changes.
Others recommended grabbing SeaMonkey, an open-source, volunteer-created suite of programs, including a browser; or Pale Moon, a Firefox-based browser for Windows and Linux. Both look much more like earlier versions of Firefox.
Some users weren't hearing any of that, and said they are moving on. "Control Panel, Uninstall, gone," said Ray-in-Kingwood of yanking Firefox from Windows. "Used Firefox for many years and loved it. The new update was a total cluster****. So ... I am on Chrome now. At least it works."
Firefox 29 defenders weren't absent from the discussions. They alternately chided others for being Luddites and pointed to resources that explained how to customize the new UI -- Mozilla trumpeted those features when it shipped the browser April 29 -- to restore an older feel.
One of those resources, a message on MozillaZine titled "Australis Guide for Normal People," was recommended by several users who said they're sticking with Firefox.
It's not unusual for users to howl at UI changes to long-familiar software -- as Microsoft knows better than most after Windows 8 -- but Mozilla can little afford to lose large numbers of users because of Australis. Firefox, which once had a solid lock on the No. 2 spot in Web metrics company Net Applications' measurements of browser user share, slipped behind Google's Chrome in March. At the end of April, Firefox accounted for 17% of all desktop browsers in use, while Chrome had a user share of 17.9%.
Firefox has lost 3.3 percentage points of user share in the past 12 months, representing a decline of 16% from its April 2013 standing.
Gregg Keizer covers Microsoft, security issues, Apple, Web browsers and general technology breaking news for Computerworld. Follow Gregg on Twitter, at @gkeizer, and on Google+, or subscribe to Gregg's RSS feed . His email address is email@example.com.
- Workarounds to purge search bar from Firefox's new tab page are available
- Mozilla ships Firefox 31, adds search to new tab page
- Microsoft's IE steps back from the brink of irrelevance
- Firefox falters, falls to record low in overall browser share
- Firefox risks user backlash by adding search box to new tab page
- Google unseats Microsoft as the U.S. browser powerhouse
- Safari, Chrome push to mask URLs
- Chrome on Windows champs at the 64-bit
- Google pulls trigger, cripples some Chrome add-ons
- Microsoft shoots to shorten Internet Explorer's long tail
Read more about Internet in Computerworld's Internet Topic Center.
- 3G/4G Digital Signage Guide Today, the widespread availability of 3G and 4G cellular or wireless broadband networks enables digital signage to be deployed virtually anywhere.
- Enterprises in Motion: In-Vehicle Networks In a world where traditional tethers to the central office have all but vanished, enterprises that operate vehicle fleets require constant and dependable...
- Uninterrupted Internet: Maximizing Revenue and Minimizing Business Risk with 3G/4G Failover Whether your businesses are connected to the Internet via T1/T3, or Cable, incorporating a mobile broadband backup solution adds uptime whenever there is...
- Trends in Pop-up Retail: Innovative Merchandising Driven by Flexible, Dependable Mobile Connectivity This paper outlines the challenges and obstacles to successful implementation, and discusses existing, rapid-deployment solutions for connecting pop-up locations with mission-critical retail applications...
- Business-driven data protection Setting up data protection infrastructures with your organizations' core mission or business in mind is key. In this webinar, the ARCserve team will...
- On-Demand Webinar: Mind the Gap! Watch the webinar featuring Bob Janssen, CTO and Co-Founder of RES Software, to start building a solid foundation for business and IT to... All Internet White Papers | Webcasts
Our new bimonthly Internet of Things newsletter helps you keep pace with the rapidly evolving technologies, trends and developments related to the IoT. Subscribe now and stay up to date!