Skip the navigation

HTC One (M8) deep-dive review: Smartphone sophistication made better

April 2, 2014 06:30 AM ET

The software

The M8 runs custom HTC software based on Google's Android 4.4.2 KitKat operating system. With this latest effort, known as Sense 6, HTC's take on Android has really come into its own and grown into a polished and cohesive setup.

HTC One Dot View -- who knew a case could be so cool?

HTC has created an innovative and unusual case for its new One (M8) phone -- and it's as interesting for its function as it is for its appearance.

See our hands-on report for a detailed look at how it works.

The user interface still has a distinctly HTC flavor to it, but that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Many of the weird and annoying UI quirks that have held HTC's software back in the past -- things like overly complicated procedures for adding apps onto your home screen or changing your phone's wallpaper -- are now corrected and the system is actually quite user-friendly. At this point, it almost feels like a custom Android launcher with much of the familiar Android environment still intact at its core.

The leftmost home-screen panel of the new One is taken up by BlinkFeed, a news-reading service built into the phone. BlinkFeed lets you scan through articles and social media tidbits right from your home screen. It's gotten a visual refresh in this latest Sense incarnation that's helped it mature into a useful and inviting tool -- and if you don't want it, it's now easier to turn it off.

Beyond that, you've got the usual mix of app shortcuts and widgets, all of which are now refreshingly easy to customize and arrange (unlike on HTC's previous software efforts). Some of HTC's changes to Android are still mildly annoying -- the Recent Apps tool is visually overwhelming, for instance, and the expanded Quick Settings panel is mysteriously missing the basic option to display your phone's battery level. But all in all, the company has finally started to get out of its own way and mold its software into something that's pretty pleasant to use.

(One major exception: bloatware. My Verizon review unit came larded up with loads of random garbage that can't easily be uninstalled. Sadly, that's par for the course with carrier-connected handsets these days.)

HTC is also guaranteeing the M8 will get major OS upgrades for at least two years from its launch date -- a significant promise that sets it apart from other Android devices.

Bottom line

Last year's One was the start of a fresh beginning for HTC. With the new One, the company has built upon that foundation and created an exceptionally good device that's in no danger of becoming Just Another Android Phone.

At a Glance

HTC One (M8)
Price: $200 (with a new two-year contract from the major U.S. carriers )
Pros: Premium all-aluminum body; exceptional display with free one-time replacement; outstanding front-facing stereo speakers; great performance; good battery life; expandable storage; dual camera setup provides interesting image effects; polished and cohesive user interface; contemporary on-screen buttons; useful motion gestures; includes two-year OS upgrade guarantee
Cons: Tall body makes phone awkward to carry and use; power button in hard-to-reach place; inconsistent camera performance; no optical image stabilization; low camera resolution limits photo cropping possibilities

The new One has a huge list of impressive qualities: The phone is beautifully constructed, with an all-metal body that gives it a distinctly premium look and feel. It has a gorgeous display and outstanding speakers. The device provides great performance, commendable battery life and a polished and cohesive software experience. Its unique dual-camera setup opens the door to some interesting photo-editing opportunities, too, and HTC's "UltraPixel" technology shines when it comes to capturing photos in low-light conditions.

But hold the phone: It isn't all good news. The M8 is awkwardly tall, its power button is in a hard-to-reach place, and its camera -- while impressive in some ways -- produces inconsistent image quality and comes with a resolution that is potentially limiting.

Ultimately, the question is if the positives outweigh those negatives for you. One thing I can assure you: HTC has created something special. If you can live with the size and aren't bothered by the camera limitations, the M8 will give you an experience like no other -- one in a class all its own.

JR Raphael is a Computerworld contributing editor and the author of the Android Power blog. For more Android tips and insights, follow him on Google+, Twitter, or Facebook.

This article, HTC One (M8) deep-dive review: Smartphone sophistication made better, was originally published at

Read more about Smartphones in Computerworld's Smartphones Topic Center.

Our Commenting Policies
Consumerization of IT: Be in the know
consumer tech

Our new weekly Consumerization of IT newsletter covers a wide range of trends including BYOD, smartphones, tablets, MDM, cloud, social and what it all means for IT. Subscribe now and stay up to date!