Target: Deceive first, answer questions later
Issuing deceptive statements is no way to win back customers' trust. That's a lesson for anyone who might find itself in Target's position someday.
Computerworld - For Target to get beyond its data breach disaster, it needs to regain the trust of its shoppers. Mystifyingly, it has opted to issue statements that are, at best, misleading. Some tiptoe beyond misleading, since the chain had to know they were untrue when it issued them.
The latest example came Friday, when Target confirmed that encrypted PIN data was stolen. Then came the whopper: "The most important thing for our guests to know is that their debit card accounts have not been compromised due to the encrypted PIN numbers being taken."
Of course those debit card accounts have been compromised. Webster's dictionary defines compromise as exposing something "to risk or danger." When personal identification numbers that give full access to someone's bank account are in the hands of experienced and sophisticated cyberthieves, I think it's safe to say that those bank accounts are indeed exposed to risk or danger. How could anyone argue otherwise?
Target's statement emphasized that the cards were triple DES encrypted and that the encryption key was not stored in Target's systems. It added that the data "can only be decrypted when it is received by our external, independent payment processor."
First off, Target's people know well that any encryption can be broken, if the attacker spends enough time and has enough compute power. It may not be easy, but it can certainly be done. Triple DES is an excellent encryption option, but nothing is unbreakable. Therefore, saying that the data "can only be decrypted" by its payment processor is untrue.
Target should be applauded for not storing that encryption key anywhere on its system. Having it stored solely at its payment processor is also a good move, but processors' systems can be broken into as well. Indeed, given that they have data from a huge number of retailers, it's an especially attractive target.
So, in theory, how could the attacker get access to the PINs? First, a brute-force cracking effort on the encrypted data might work. Second, the key might be grabbed by an attack on the processor's systems, as has happened in the past. Third, there might be a Target insider -- or a processor insider -- who could give up the key for money. Or who might be tricked into giving it up, via social engineering, which cyberthieves love.
Had Target simply said that the stolen PINs were fully encrypted so there's an excellent chance that they won't be accessible, that would be fine. It could have also truthfully added, "We currently have not seen proof that the bad guys have in fact deciphered these PINs. We've also not seen any evidence that they haven't."
More by Evan Schuman
- Evan Schuman: With Heartbleed, IT leaders are missing the point
- Evan Schuman: Social media endangers corporate secrets
- Evan Schuman: Resurrection of Full Disclosure mailing list is great news, if you're not a cyberthief
- Evan Schuman: Wal-Mart is latest big company with mobile-app security problems
- Evan Schuman: Can Starbucks get people to use its app to pay for dry cleaning?
- Evan Schuman: Is MasterCard's fraud program just another data grab?
- Evan Schuman: Mobile IT Roach Motel: Data checks in, but it won't check out
- Evan Schuman: Transparency about data retention requires knowing what you have
- Evan Schuman: Your data exposed -- Delta, Facebook, others latest to fall into mobile app trap
- Evan Schuman: Get ready, IT; here comes the Internet of Things
- Radicati: Cloud Business Email - Market Quadrant 2013 Google was named the top cloud business email provider in a recent report by research firm Radicati. Out of 14 key players, Google...
- Tablets in the Enterprise: A Checklist for Successful Deployment How can you enterprise manage and secure tablets in order to protect corporate data while providing access to the information and applications employees...
- Enterprise Mobility: A Checklist for Secure Containerization The advantages and disadvantages of the multiple approaches to containerization. Learn More>>
- Enterprise File Sync & Share Checklist File sync and share has changed the way people work and collaborate in today's tech-savvy world. Gone are the email roadblocks, clunky FTP...
- Live Webcast LIVE EVENT: 5/7, The End of Data Protection As We Know It. Introducing a Next Generation Data Protection Architecture. Traditional backup is going away, but where does this leave end-users?
- On-demand webinar: "Mobility Mayhem: Balancing BYOD with Enterprise Security" Check out this on-demand webinar to hear Sophos senior security expert John Shier deep dive into how BYOD impacts your enterprise security strategy... All Security White Papers | Webcasts