Skip the navigation

Who blinks first? EU's threat to charge Google over antitrust issues is mostly bluff

December 26, 2013 11:58 AM ET

However, Petit didn't think Microsoft's lobbying had played a big part in Almunia's decision to reject Google's second suggested deal. "I don't believe those interest groups have much traction in this debate," Petit said, when asked about FairSearch's and ICOMP's influence. "There are too many other complainants in addition to Microsoft-related ones."

Although Almunia denied that sanctions are inevitable, he said the hourglass is running out. "At this moment, there is little time left, but the ball is still in Google's court," Almunia said last week.

If Google is formally charged, a lengthy process will begin that could result in fines as large as $5 billion.

That's unlikely. Almunia has staked his reputation on reaching settlements with corporations accused of anti-competitive practices, arguing that faster resolutions, not drawn-out legal battles, better serve European consumers, especially in quick-changing technology markets.

Almunia's stance has been very different from his predecessor, Neelie Kroes, who was much more confrontational. Kroes led a years-long action against Microsoft that ended in the American company paying billions in fines for past behavior.

It's time, said Petit, for Almunia to prove that his strategy is viable.

"Almunia has been bragging everywhere about the virtues of settlements, and more generally of fast antitrust enforcement in high-tech markets," said Petit. "He is now bound to make something out of this case before the end of his term."

To do so, however, means he will have to take the Statement of Objections option off the table.

"He won't [file official charges]," said Petit. "If nothing has come in June it will be too late."

covers Microsoft, security issues, Apple, Web browsers and general technology breaking news for Computerworld. Follow Gregg on Twitter at Twitter @gkeizer, on Google+ or subscribe to Gregg's RSS feed Keizer RSS. His email address is

See more by Gregg Keizer on

Read more about Internet Search in Computerworld's Internet Search Topic Center.

Our Commenting Policies