Ballmer forced out after $900M Surface RT debacle
Major miscalculation and ensuing financial blow precipitated board's decision to push out the Microsoft CEO, argues analyst
Computerworld - Steve Ballmer was forced out of his CEO chair by Microsoft's board of directors, who hit the roof when the company took a $900 million write-off to account for an oversupply of the firm's struggling Surface RT tablet, an analyst argued today.
"He was definitely pushed out by the board," said Patrick Moorhead, principal analyst with Moor Insights & Strategy, in an interview Friday. "They either drove him out, or put him in a situation where he felt he had to leave to save face."
The biggest clue that Ballmer was pushed and didn't leave of his own free will was the 12-month timetable Microsoft said it would use to find a CEO successor. "Typically, a board will be working behind the scenes for a replacement, but they've given themselves 12 months," said Moorhead. "I think this went down very quickly."
Microsoft announced Ballmer's retirement earlier Friday.
Ballmer, who has been CEO since 2000 and at Microsoft since 1980, will remain CEO until his successor is selected. In a statement, the board indicated that could take as long as 12 months. It has drafted a committee to oversee the selection process; co-founder, former CEO and current chairman Bill Gates will serve on the committee.
In his email to Microsoft workers, Ballmer seemed to hint that the retirement was not his idea, but that he was falling on his sword. "This is an emotional and difficult thing for me to do. I take this step in the best interests of the company I love," he wrote.
Later Friday morning, Ballmer told Mary Jo Foley of ZDNet that he had been thinking of retirement for some time -- true, as he'd informally named 2018 as the likely date five years ago -- but that his thinking had "intensified really over the last couple, two, two and a half months."
Moorhead had a different timeline.
"What could have precipitated the quick move?" Moorhead asked, then answered his own question. "It was the $900 million write-down. That caught the attention of the board, and based on Ballmer's over-enthusiastic public commentary on Windows RT and Surface RT, they lost a lot of credibility. So did Ballmer. How can you be that far off what consumers want? Was it that you're not listening to your team? Was it because the team was afraid to give him advice? Was it because the team saw a different reality? Or was it that the team lacked the skill set to anticipate the failure?"
Whatever the reason, it ultimately led to Ballmer being blamed. "The buck stopped with Ballmer," said Moorhead.
- Microsoft plans to patch critical under-attack IE bug next week
- Ballmer regrets not aping Apple sooner
- OS upgrades: Cheap is better than pricey, free is better than cheap
- Update: More top-tier Microsoft execs head for the door
- Microsoft ships Office 2013 SP1 the old-fashioned way
- Microsoft's 'go-low' play puts Windows revenue on the line
- Microsoft: Android Nokia not our call to make
- Gates sells another 20M shares; lead over Ballmer shrinks to nearly nothing
- Hey Microsoft, where's the next Mac Office?
- Microsoft dubs 'confusing' Office Web Apps as Office Online
- 15 Non-Certified IT Skills Growing in Demand
- How 19 Tech Titans Target Healthcare
- Twitter Suffering From Growing Pains (and Facebook Comparisons)
- Agile Comes to Data Integration
- Slideshow: 7 security mistakes people make with their mobile device
- iOS vs. Android: Which is more secure?
- 11 sure signs you've been hacked
- eBook: An Executives' Guide: The Machine of the Future This eBook has been developed to help executives understand the value of M2M and IoT to enterprises. We will include a framework CEOs...
- Quantifying the Return on Investment: The Business Case for Machine-to-Machine Initiatives This paper uses real-world customer results and a set of key metrics to help executives and managers understand the return they should expect...
- Is There Still a Case for PMO? PMOs haven't always worked for all companies all of the time. Smart companies should review their PMO needs and activities through a PMO...
- Consequences of Poorly Performing Software Systems While performance issues are not always avoidable, their effects can be mitigated and often avoided by developing a keen understanding their causes and...
- How to Select the Right IoT Platform We are rapidly entering a world where almost everything will be connected to the cloud and managing these connected things and leveraging the...
- Integrated Infrastructure: Simplify Operations, Speed Deployments and Reduce Costs George Weiss, Gartner Vice President and Analyst, and Praveen Akkiraju, CEO of VCE, provide practical information regarding the various aspects of Integrated Infrastructures... All IT Leadership White Papers | Webcasts