SAP loses bid to overturn $345M patent judgment
Long-running dispute with Verstat Software centers on SAP's alleged infringement on pricing software patent
IDG News Service - An appeals court has rejected SAP's attempt to overturn a $345 million judgment awarded to Versata Software, which had brought a patent-infringement case against the software maker.
"Sufficient evidence supports the jury's verdict," Chief Judge Randall Rader wrote in the decision, which was released Wednesday.
In the 1990s, Versata developed and sold software that companies use to determine the prices of their offerings based on customer size, geographic location and other factors, the decision states. Called Pricer, the software was used by SAP customers as a "bolt-on" to their core ERP system.
SAP subsequently released its own pricing software and bundled it into "its full enterprise software to discourage the use of bolt-on products like Pricer," the decision states. Pricer sales took a tumble "as SAP's bundled software took hold," it adds.
Versata sued SAP in 2007, alleging its pricing software infringed a number of its patents.
Initially, Versata won a $139 million verdict in August 2009, but a judge later set that award aside and ordered a new trial to determine damages.
Before the second trial, SAP applied a software patch to its pricing software that was meant to eliminate "any basis for future infringement" on Versata's patents, according to the appeals court's decision.
But the second trial's jury concluded SAP's software still infringed Versata's intellectual property, even with the patch, and it awarded Versata $345 million in May 2011.
A permanent judgment was also applied to SAP, barring it from continuing to sell the pricing functionality.
In its appeal, SAP argued that the injunction was too broad because it also prohibited SAP from selling additional seats and maintenance services to existing customers.
The appeals court agreed with SAP on this point and asked the trial court to modify the wording of the injunction. "SAP should be able to provide maintenance or additional seats for prior customers of its infringing products, so long as the maintenance or the additional seat does not involve, or allow access to, the enjoined capability," the decision states.
"SAP's attorneys are currently reviewing the court's ruling," SAP spokesman Andy Kendzie said via email. "We are pleased the court found the injunction was overbroad and remanded it to the lower court for modification. Until we have had a chance to review this ruling in detail, we will not comment further."
Chris Kanaracus covers enterprise software and general technology breaking news for The IDG News Service. Chris' email address is Chris_Kanaracus@idg.com
- Aberdeen Group: Marketing Analytics for Manufacturing: Forging Customer Insights There are no recalls for poor marketing. Manufacturers need to get their customer intelligence and messaging right the first time. Learn how.
- The Brave New World of Customer-Centric Manufacturing The Unique Opportunity for Manufacturers to Better Understand their Consumers
- See the Possibilities Utilizing Data Visualization Do you simply want to collect data, or do you want to derive business insights from it? What if you could quickly and...
Changing the Way Government Works: Four Technology Trends that Drive Down Costs and Increase Productivity
This paper discusses four technology-based approaches to improving processes and increasing
productivity while driving down department and agency costs.
- Cloud Knowledge Vault Learn how your organization can benefit from the scalability, flexibility, and performance that the cloud offers through the short videos and other resources...
- LIVE EVENT: 5/7, The End of Data Protection As We Know It. Introducing a Next Generation Data Protection Architecture. Traditional backup is going away, but where does this leave end-users? All IT Industry White Papers | Webcasts