Tech workers anti-poaching suit fails to get class action status -- for now
The employees can, however, amend their motion, judge says
IDG News Service - A court in California declined to certify as class action a lawsuit by workers alleging an illegal cartel formed by seven technology companies including Apple, Google and Intel.
The judge, however, raised the possibility that she may review her decision, after giving the software engineers leave to amend their petition in the light of new information.
The five engineers alleged in their lawsuit, individually and on behalf of a class of all those similarly situated, that Adobe Systems, Apple, Google, Intel, Intuit, Lucasfilm and Pixar, all high-tech companies with principal place of business in the San Francisco-Silicon Valley area of California, engaged in an "overarching conspiracy" to fix and suppress employee compensation and to restrict employee mobility.
The companies are said to have set up "Do Not Call" lists, putting each firm's employees off-limits to the other companies, with instructions to recruiters not to "cold call" these employees.
The employees alleged the anti-solicitation agreements centered around three of the most important figures in Silicon Valley including former Apple CEO Steve Jobs, Eric Schmidt who was then Google CEO and is now its executive chairman, and Intuit Chairman Bill Campbell, all of whom served on Apple's board of directors throughout the alleged conspiracy, according to court records.
"The Court is most concerned about whether the evidence will be able to show that Defendants maintained such rigid compensation structures that a suppression of wages to some employees would have affected all or nearly all Class members," Judge Lucy H. Koh of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose division, wrote in her ruling last week.
"The Court is also concerned that Plaintiffs' proposed classes may be defined so broadly as to include large numbers of people who were not necessarily harmed by Defendants' allegedly unlawful conduct," she added, while agreeing with the employees that a class action would be a more effective way than alternate adjudication from a number of aspects including manageability.
The software engineers had proposed two classes, the first consisting of all employees, except for retail employees, corporate officers, members of the boards of directors and senior executives, that were employed at the seven companies in the U.S. on salaries during the periods under consideration. Alternately, it was proposed to have a "technical class" consisting of "persons who work in the technical, creative, and/or research and development fields" in the seven companies during the same periods. The first class would likely have over 100,000 members, while the second class was expected to have over 50,000 members.
The lawsuit has served to highlight ways in which top executives allegedly tried to make deals and impose their will on other top executives, including allegedly with threats. Jobs is said to have threatened Palm with a patent lawsuit in 2007 if it did not enter into an agreement in which the companies pledged not to hire employees from each other, according to a written affidavit made public in the court.
- Pivotal Melds Big Data and Platform-as-a-service The value of Information has increased, so has the business's thirst for more information. Access to data and collaboration are at the heart...
- Operationalizing the Buzz: Big Data 2013 The 2013 EMA/9sight Big Data research surveyed 259 business and technology stakeholders around the world.
- The Pivotal Big Data Suite- Reducing the Risks of Big Data The explosion of big data and the rapid evolution of big data tools and technologies is challenging IT to meet the demands of...
- The Principles of the Business Data Lake The Business Data Lake is a new approach to information management, analytics and reporting that better matches the culture of business and better...
- Keep Servers Up and Running and Attackers in the Dark An SSL/TLS handshake requires at least 10 times more processing power on a server than on the client. SSL renegotiation attacks can readily...
- On Demand: Mastering the Art of Mobile Content Management Mobile device usage in the enterprise has skyrocketed, and it continues to escalate. IT must answer to users who demand access to their... All Legal White Papers | Webcasts