Microsoft's Xbox does not violate Google patent, U.S. judge says
Ruling by U.S. ITC administrative law judge has to be reviewed by the commission
IDG News Service - An administrative law judge at the U.S. International Trade Commission has ruled against a ban on Microsoft's Xbox as he found it did not violate a patent owned by Motorola Mobility.
In a one-paragraph ruling, Judge David P. Shaw gave an initial determination that the Xbox did not violate section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930.
Section 337 investigations conducted by the ITC most often involve claims regarding intellectual property rights, including allegations of patent infringement and trademark infringement by imported goods, and can lead to the ban on their imports into the U.S.
The commission may, however, review, adopt or change an initial determination.
Judge Shaw ruled Friday that U.S. patent no. 6,069,896, relating to wireless peer-to-peer communications, had not been infringed by Microsoft. This was the last patent in the dispute which was filed in the ITC in November 2010 by Motorola, which accused Microsoft of infringing five of its patents.
Motorola in January asked the ITC to drop two patents relating to the H.264 video encoding standard from the investigation. Microsoft had said in an earlier filing that it expected Motorola to withdraw claims relating to the two patents it said are essential to the H.264 video compression standard, in view of a settlement earlier in the month between Google and the Federal Trade Commission over standard-essential patents and other issues. Google acquired Motorola last year for US$12.5 billion.
Two other patents, relating to the 802.11 standard, were withdrawn by Motorola from the investigation in October last year.
Motorola said in its filings that by its withdrawal of the patents from the investigation, it did not waive any rights, including for past damages, in its currently pending lawsuits against Microsoft in U.S. District Courts for the Western District of Washington and the Western District of Wisconsin.
The case before the ITC attracted considerable attention from government antitrust agencies, U.S. Congressmen and companies over the possible misuse of standard-essential patents to get bans on products.
In a submission in the public interest in the investigation, the FTC, for example, said in June last year that it was concerned that a patent owner can make a FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) commitment as part of the standard setting process, and then seek an exclusion order for infringement of the FRAND-encumbered standard-essential patent as a way of securing royalties that may be inconsistent with the FRAND commitment.
Judge Shaw had earlier recommended a ban on Xbox consoles in the U.S. He also found that Microsoft failed to establish that Motorola's alleged obligation to provide a license on FRAND terms precluded a finding of violation of section 337. The ITC decided to review the recommendation in July.
- Silicon Valley's 19 Coolest Places to Work
- Is Windows 8 Development Worth the Trouble?
- 8 Books Every IT Leader Should Read This Year
- 10 Hot Hadoop Startups to Watch
- Slideshow: 7 security mistakes people make with their mobile device
- iOS vs. Android: Which is more secure?
- 11 sure signs you've been hacked
- Infographic: Converged Infrastructure Benefits This Infographic quantifies the savings organizations are realizing from increased deployment speed, higher availability, and lower annual costs.
- CIOs Deliver Productivity Breakthroughs with Intelligent Digital Signage Retailers have long recognized the influence that digital signage provides over a shopper's point-of-purchase decision making process.
- Going Paperless? Here's What You Need to Think About As makers of some of the world's most popular PDF solutions, we often consult with businesses & governmental agencies that have the goal...
- The Big Data Opportunity for HR and Finance If CEOs, CFOs, CIOs, and CHROs want to drive their businesses forward, they will need to quickly recognize the enormous value of big...
- Top 4 Digital Signage Fails Join RMG Networks for a look at four of the most common reasons digital signage fails in corporate businesses. Learn about strategies to...
- Building Tomorrow's Infrastructure Listen to this podcast to discover how Crider Foods worked with PC Connection to update their IT infrastructure, while maintaining compliance and control. All Legal White Papers | Webcasts