Bart Perkins: Change management is not optional
Computerworld - High-impact projects -- those aiming for streamlined, redesigned and transformed business processes -- require more than incremental change. But few people embrace change enthusiastically. Staff can be stiffly resistant to new processes, interfaces or job responsibilities. It's a challenge that calls for effective change management.
Unfortunately, even multinational enterprises often ignore change management until problems arise. Many good project teams naively assume that if they just design a better approach, people will automatically embrace the new system. (I'm still waiting to see this happen in the real world.)
Other reasons that projects often neglect change management include the following:
Incomplete analysis. Lacking a full understanding of job content and interactions, project teams might not see the need for change management. Analysts at one large manufacturing company decided that field repair technicians should be able to complete more than their current 3.2 service calls per day. To that end, the analysts decided that techs no longer needed to start their day at the supply depot. Instead, supplies would be shipped directly to the techs, transforming each truck into a mini warehouse. Result: Calls completed per day decreased sharply. The analysts had failed to understand the flow of critical information. Techs routinely shared their diagnostic and repair experiences with one another during their time at the depot. Without this forum for sharing information, the techs were less effective and required formal training.
Resource constraints. Change management requires time and money and might be deemed wasteful. This was true at one Fortune 500 company, where the extremely powerful accounting department regularly put project plans through four or five rounds of cost cutting. Project teams that saw value in change management had to create small additional projects (which received less scrutiny) for training, documentation and change management. Unfortunately, this approach resulted in out-of-sync schedules and poor integration among other project activities, severely hampering change management efforts.
Politics. Teams might be reluctant to challenge entrenched interests. A state governor announced a program to implement common systems across all state agencies. The project team recognized that the resulting new business processes and job content would be so different that the only hope of success lay in a massive change management effort to get buy-in from the people who would use the new system. They were confident that, given enough time for communication and training, workers and middle managers would embrace the changes. Unfortunately, prior governors had allowed each agency to build its own IT capability, and none of the agencies wanted to relinquish IT staff and funding. Since the governor was unwilling to confront the entrenched bureaucracy, the team backed off and eventually reproduced each agency's legacy package in the new system. The governor declared success, and the bureaucrats retained power.
Even when change management is employed, other factors can dilute its effectiveness. In one case I'm aware of, store managers at a regional grocery chain were essentially crew schedulers whose performance metrics demanded optimal staff scheduling. When the position was upgraded to include P&L responsibility, corresponding metrics and compensation plans remained the same, and the project team had to drop a major component of its change management effort. Predictably, schedules remained optimal, while profits dipped.
Successful projects require organizational acceptance to achieve their full potential. Even otherwise well-designed projects often fail when change management is neglected. Be proactive! Require high-impact projects to include a change management analysis and plan. Otherwise, you risk impacting your project's acceptance, business benefits and ultimate success.
Bart Perkins is managing partner at Louisville, Ky.-based Leverage Partners, which helps organizations invest well in IT. Contact him at BartPerkins@LeveragePartners.com.
More by Bart Perkins
- Bart Perkins: Pester no more: How to handle the FCC's new rules on robocalls
- Bart Perkins: 3D printing is IT's next big challenge
- Bart Perkins: Benchmarking is great, when it's not a waste
- Bart Perkins: Global standards, meet local constraints
- Bart Perkins: Congratulations on your new supplier. Got a good prenup?
- Bart Perkins: Can't buy you love
- Bart Perkins: Jousting for jobs
- Bart Perkins: Unresponsive suppliers might just not be that into you
- Bart Perkins: Avoiding IT audit nightmares
- Bart Perkins: Beware of self-destructing messaging in the enterprise
Read more about Management in Computerworld's Management Topic Center.
- 15 Non-Certified IT Skills Growing in Demand
- How 19 Tech Titans Target Healthcare
- Twitter Suffering From Growing Pains (and Facebook Comparisons)
- Agile Comes to Data Integration
- Slideshow: 7 security mistakes people make with their mobile device
- iOS vs. Android: Which is more secure?
- 11 sure signs you've been hacked
- Future Focus: What's Coming in Enterprise Mobility Management (EMM) Find out why Enterprise Mobility Management (EMM) solutions that are truly future-ready must be designed to enable Machine-to-Machine (M2M) capabilities and much more.
- The CIO's Guide to Enterprise Mobility Management (EMM) This guide will help those making an EMM platform decision make the best choice for their organization.
- Yankee Group: BlackBerry Results Refute Rumors of its Demise Yankee Group: BlackBerry® is stronger than the press makes it out to be.
- Your New EMM Platform: How to Streamline the Migration Smartphone migration can be resource-intensive and challenging. Find out how outsourcing the process can save significant time and money.
- Live Webcast Increasing the Value of Your Reports and Dashboards Learn how incorporating other analytical capabilities such as predictive modeling and visualization can increase the value of your reports and dashboards by providing...
- Testimonial: Cystic Fibrosis Trust Peter Hawkins, the Head of IT for Cystic Fibrosis Trust, discusses the role CommVault's Simpana software platform plays in improving the company's information...
- Increasing the Value of Your Reports and Dashboards Learn how incorporating other analytical capabilities such as predictive modeling and visualization can increase the value of your reports and dashboards by providing... All Management White Papers | Webcasts