Survey finds ERP software project overruns 'distressingly common'
Oracle projects are facing the longest unexpected delays, according to Panorama Consulting
IDG News Service - It is "distressingly common" to see ERP (enterprise-resource-planning) projects involving Oracle, SAP and Microsoft Dynamics software end up taking longer than customers anticipated, according to a new survey.
The survey released this week by Panorama Consulting, a Denver-area company that provides ERP implementation and software selection services, is based on 2,000 responses from 61 countries, which were collected between February 2006 and May of this year.
About 40% were in North America, company President Eric Kimberling said during a webinar on Thursday. Some 61% of respondents said their projects went over schedule, while 28% finished on time and 11% completed the project sooner than expected, according to the report.
The actual ERP software being used is largely not to blame for problem projects, according to the survey data. Just 4% of respondents cited "vendor functionality issues" as a reason for project delays, although "technical issues" drew 14%.
A change in the project's initial scope was the top reason for slowdowns, named by 29% of survey respondents. "Organizational issues" came next with 20%, followed by "data issues" and "resource constraints" with 17% apiece.
A big focus of ERP projects is their promise of a return on a company's investment in the software. But Panorama's survey found that nearly a third of respondents had yet to realize any financial rewards from their projects, and another 30% said it took at least three years to start seeing any "payback."
Dynamics led the pack in terms of overall implementation times, averaging 13 months to SAP's 17 months and Oracle's 18 months, according to the survey.
These results should be viewed with some caution, since Dynamics tends to be implemented by smaller companies with less complex environments, Kimberling said during the webinar.
SAP and Dynamics projects ran on average two months past schedule, while Oracle implementations averaged four-month overruns, according to the survey.
Overall, there's some cause for concern regarding the type of benefits respondents said they've gained from their projects, according to the report. Sixty percent cited "availability of information" as a plus, but only 7% named "decreased labor costs."
In addition, there weren't a meaningful number of responses citing results such as "reduced IT costs" and "improved interaction with customers," according to the report. "The very lack of their selection points to a distressingly small percentage of potential ERP system benefits being realized."
Panorama bills itself as a completely independent consulting firm with no financial ties to any vendor.
Sometimes, ERP projects go so poorly that customers end up suing their vendor, as well as vice versa.
Chris Kanaracus covers enterprise software and general technology breaking news for The IDG News Service. Chris's e-mail address is Chris_Kanaracus@idg.com
- Building a New Era in Enterprise IT As the digital revolution spawned by the explosive growth of disruptive technologies such as mobile, cloud, social, and analytic tools continues to fundamentally...
- Whitepaper: The Continuous Innovation Advantage of SaaS This report defines the next generation system of record, outlining the changes and challenges with current technology and how continuous innovation has become...
- Forrester Report: The ROI of Software as a Service Read Forrester's review of 11 vendors in SaaS enterprise resource planning (ERP), customer relationship management (CRM), and supply chain management (SCM).
- Whitepaper: Redefining Enterprise Software Whitepaper In this whitepaper you will learn what changes are impacting business and human capital management today and how the HR department and its...
- Keep Servers Up and Running and Attackers in the Dark An SSL/TLS handshake requires at least 10 times more processing power on a server than on the client. SSL renegotiation attacks can readily...
- On Demand: Mastering the Art of Mobile Content Management Mobile device usage in the enterprise has skyrocketed, and it continues to escalate. IT must answer to users who demand access to their... All ERP White Papers | Webcasts