Skip the navigation

Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols: The perils of BYOD

I'm not talking about the hassle for IT departments when people bring in their own devices. I mean the perils to the people doing the bringing.

July 10, 2012 08:36 AM ET

Computerworld - Some people love the movement known as bring your own device (BYOD). Some even insist that it's their right to bring their iPhones, Chromebooks or iPads to work. But I've always been wary of BYOD. Recent developments in how businesses see BYOD have moved me from being concerned to being downright worried.

What I have distrusted about BYOD is its potential to become the attractive carrot for the stick of cost-cutting. The BYOD concept was introduced with an emphasis on employee choice, but I never really bought that spin, and the recent developments confirm my fears. The whole point of BYOD, from the point of view of the senior executives who have embraced it, is to save money.

Take, for example, the state of California with its estimated $16 billion shortfall for the fiscal year. Money doesn't grow on trees, even in fruitful California, so Chris Cruz, deputy director and CIO at the state's Department of Health Care Services, decided to cut costs by no longer supplying or paying for smartphones at all but instead requiring employees to use their own smartphones -- at their own expense. The state employee unions aren't happy about this, so it isn't a done deal yet. But it's still a bad sign of what's in store for workers.

Inevitably, requiring employees to use their own devices for work will happen at other businesses -- possibly including yours. One day soon, the CFOs at many businesses are going to sit down with their CIO counterparts and mandate IT budget cuts of 10% (there goes your company-supplied phone), 20% (there goes your company-paid mobile phone and data services) or 30% (there goes your PC).

BYOD is a slippery slope. It started because we loved our tech toys and wanted to use them for work. That was great for executives who could afford to buy the latest and greatest iPad every time Apple released one. But when BYOD becomes a requirement, it's a pain for those in the upper salary brackets and a de facto cut in pay for those who don't make the big bucks.

And we're talking about some major expenses. For instance, in my own case, my Verizon voice and data plan runs me over $1,500 a year. I'm self-employed, so that's part of my cost of doing business. It shouldn't be part of an employee's cost of keeping a job.

Now, take this one step further. Say you don't have a job. Interviews at one potential employer go well and they say they want to hire you -- but your job will require you to have a late-model Android or iPhone smartphone with a minimum data plan of 1GB per month. Don't have them? Well, be prepared to fork over the $500 to get the high-end gear and services, because if you don't, they'll find someone else.

Our Commenting Policies