Samsung Galaxy S III review: A rock-star phone, but does it deliver?
Samsung also put power controls into the phone's notification area -- a feature that's handy, even if it could be achieved just as easily via third-party add-ons -- along with an option to display your exact remaining battery percentage at the top of the screen. Samsung's nature theme provides some pleasant visual flourishes, too, such as a rippling water effect that happens when you unlock the phone.
Some other noteworthy feature additions:
- Samsung created a cool "Pop Up Player" that lets you watch a video while simultaneously conducting other tasks. The video plays in a floating picture-in-picture-style box that can be moved around the screen. The feature is wildly impressive and a great demonstration of the phone's power, though I question how often one would actually use it (particularly considering that videos have to be on the phone's local storage to work -- YouTube isn't supported).
- The Galaxy S III has a host of new motion-based commands. Some of them are more novel than practical -- being able to tilt the phone to move an icon around on your home screen, for example -- while others are legitimately useful, like the ability to have the system automatically call someone when you move the phone to your ear while texting.
- Samsung has provided a handful of gesture-based commands, like the ability to swipe left on someone's name in the Phone app to text her or swipe right to dial her number. It also, however, removed Google's ICS-level People app, which offers a centralized place to view your contacts and all their connected social network information.
Finally, there's S Voice, Samsung's voice-powered personal assistant that's clearly an answer to Apple's Siri. Like Siri, unfortunately, S Voice feels more like a gimmick than anything. In general, I found its accuracy and responsiveness to be inconsistent and unreliable.
The few areas where S Voice shines are those in which it expands upon Google's own Voice Actions technology, which is integrated into Android by default. S Voice has a few useful additions to Google's simple command-driven tools, such as voice-activated options to set timers or toggle the phone's Wi-Fi mode. But it lacks some of the basic commands that make Voice Actions useful, such as the ability to compose and send an email.
The more natural-language-based functions are a waste of time. S Voice rarely understood me correctly, and even when it did, it almost always responded by apologizing for not having the answer and then prompting me to search the Web. (This happened even with easy queries like: "How tall is Michael Jordan?") Most tasks could be accomplished more effectively and with less aggravation by using Google's Voice Actions or just searching the Web directly.
Other elements of S Voice are integrated throughout the Galaxy S III, such as the ability to use voice commands to unlock the phone or to capture a picture while in the Camera app. Some of these functions are novel, but I found their reliability to be around 50% at best, which basically renders them useless.
(An observation: You can't talk about Samsung software without talking about upgrades. From the early days of Android through now, Samsung has been notoriously bad about providing timely OS upgrades to its users. The past doesn't necessarily predict the future, of course, but if fast and frequent upgrades are a priority to you, buying a Samsung Galaxy S phone sure seems like a risky bet to make.)
The Galaxy S III has a lot of great things going for it. The phone has a sexy, sleek design; a big, beautiful screen; and perhaps the best performance of any smartphone on the market today. The new Galaxy has an excellent camera, too, and some nice perks like NFC-based sharing and external storage support.
At a Glance
Price: Varies according to carrier (see chart).
Pros: Sleek design; big, beautiful screen; top-of-the-line performance; excellent camera; removable battery; supports external storage; has innovative features like "SmartStay" and "Pop Up Player"
Cons: Dated button setup; awkward combination of physical and capacitive buttons; capacitive buttons can't be seen much of the time; has a tendency to run hot; busy and inconsistent UI compared to Google's base Android 4.0; lots of bloatware
For all its strengths, though, the Galaxy S III has some drawbacks that can't be ignored. Samsung's button approach is riddled with problems, ranging from an awkward combination of physical and capacitive buttons -- the latter of which frequently can't be seen at all -- to a dated choice of button commands. The phone's software has some commendable bonus features, but the overall user interface feels bloated, busy, and inconsistent compared to Google's base Android 4.0 OS.
Whether or not these things are deal-breakers is dependent on your perspective; if you're more of a casual smartphone user, you may not even think twice about them. For many people, the large number of positive qualities will outweigh the negatives. But if you're an Android enthusiast or someone who values a cutting-edge, optimal user experience, Samsung's choices may let you down.
All considered, the Galaxy S III is a standout smartphone that easily earns a place among the Android elite. It isn't without its flaws -- no technology is -- but it's a mighty fine device with an awful lot to offer.
- Sprint's cut in data prices won't help its network woes
- The 5 most anticipated smartphone launches coming in September
- Sprint to resell Google Apps for Business cloud service
- Samsung's S5 mini: Slimmer and slower than S5, but still scans fingerprints
- Privacy-focused Blackphone starts shipping to early adopters
- Why you shouldn't buy the Amazon Fire phone
- A closer look at the new technologies in Amazon's Fire smartphone
- Amazon's Fire phone is 'Prime' example of customer first
- Amazon's expected smartphone already faces skeptics
- Update: Tizen OS declared 'dead in the water'
Read more about Smartphones in Computerworld's Smartphones Topic Center.
- Tips for Driving User Adoption in New Technology Deployment Read this checklist on tips for driving user adoption to see where you stand.
- Capabilities You Need in an IP Address Management Solution A mismanaged IP space can cripple an otherwise healthy network. Take a moment to understand what you need in an enterprise-ready IPAM solution.
- IPv6 Fundamentals IPv6 is needed to sustain the growth of the Internet. The transition from IPv4 will require planning and likely some degree of support...
- Optimize IT Performance & Availability: Four Steps to Establish Effective IT Management Baselines More than ever before, your company's ability to grow hinges on IT performance and availability. Download this how-to report on establishing IT baselines,...
- Maximizing Availability for the Modern Data Center Check out this information-packed resource center for help in maximizing the availability of your data center - from overcoming challenges to choosing the...
- Business-driven data protection Setting up data protection infrastructures with your organizations' core mission or business in mind is key. In this webinar, the ARCserve team will... All Smartphones White Papers | Webcasts