Judge revives Apple, Motorola patent suit
The judge had earlier said he had made a tentative decision to dismiss the case
IDG News Service - A federal judge has scheduled an injunction hearing in a patent dispute between Apple and Motorola Mobility, after raising the possibility last week that the case might be dismissed as neither side had established a right to relief.
Judge Richard A. Posner said in an order Wednesday that the hearing would be June 20, and each party may argue for injunctive relief against alleged patent infringement by the other. "The parties should be prepared to address the possibility of substitution for an injunction of an equitable decree for a reasonable royalty going forward," the judge said.
Posner is presiding over Apple's patent lawsuit against Motorola and Motorola Mobility in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, a trial court.
While stating last week that he had tentatively decided that the case should be dismissed with prejudice, Posner said in his order that he would delay entry of judgment until he had prepared a full opinion in about a week.
The judge limited himself to briefly sketching the grounds for his tentative view, in which he stated that he could not find basis for injunctive relief, as it would impose costs disproportionate to the harm inflicted on the patent holders or benefit to alleged infringer, and would be contrary to the public interest. He also canceled a trial scheduled to begin Monday.
Motorola should be prepared to address the bearing of FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) on the injunction analysis, if it means to argue for injunctive relief, Judge Posner said in his one-page order this week. FRAND is used to describe the relatively easier licensing terms on which companies commit to license standards-essential patents.
Import bans and other exclusions on the basis of alleged infringements of standards-essential patents have come into focus after the U.S. Federal Trade Commission last week expressed concern to the U.S. International Trade Commission on this issue.
In a submission to the ITC, the FTC said it was concerned that a patent owner can make a FRAND commitment as part of the standard setting process and then seek an exclusion order for infringement of the FRAND-encumbered standards-essential patent as a way of securing royalties that may be inconsistent with the FRAND commitment.
FTC made the submission in the context of the ITC investigation into Motorola Mobility's charges of patent infringement against both Apple and Microsoft. Some U.S. congressmen and companies including Nokia and Verizon Wireless have adopted similar positions before the ITC.
- The New Business Case for Video Conferencing: 7 Real-World Benefits Beyond Cost-Savings This whitepaper provides insight into the value of video conferencing in today's business environment, and how organizations are using visual collaboration to find...
- Gartner Magic Quadrant for Client Management Tools The client management tool market is maturing and evolving to adapt to consumerization, desktop virtualization, and an ongoing need to improve efficiency.
- Audit Ready and Asset Optimized: The Solid Promise of an Intelligent Software Asset Management Solution In this paper Frost & Sullivan examines the benefits of enterprise-grade Software Asset Management solutions, and how these solutions serve as the convergence...
- Pragmatic Endpoint Management: Empowering an SMB Workforce in the Age of Mobility Lacking the time for proper training and education, SMB administrators often resort to taking shortcuts to keep their environment running.This paper discusses the...
- LIVE EVENT: 5/7, The End of Data Protection As We Know It. Introducing a Next Generation Data Protection Architecture. Traditional backup is going away, but where does this leave end-users?
- On-demand webinar: "Mobility Mayhem: Balancing BYOD with Enterprise Security" Check out this on-demand webinar to hear Sophos senior security expert John Shier deep dive into how BYOD impacts your enterprise security strategy... All Legal White Papers | Webcasts