Nook Tablet vs. Kindle Fire: Which will win?
Holiday shoppers must decide between the Nook Tablet's superior features and the Kindle Fire's lower price
Computerworld - As predicted, Barnes & Noble introduced a $249 Nook Tablet that has about double the memory and internal storage of the upcoming $199 Amazon Kindle Fire.
While some of the Nook Tablet's specifications are superior to those of the Kindle Fire, the Nook's price fails to break below the magic $200 figure that will attract more consumers, analysts said Monday. As a result, the Kindle Fire, with its better-recognized brand name and access to widely known Amazon content, should sell better among holiday shoppers in the initial weeks when both go on sale.
Both devices have 7-in. touch screens and will be available next week. The Kindle Fire arrives Nov. 15 and the Nook Tablet comes by the end of next week at Barnes & Noble stores and other retailers, the company said.
The Nook Tablet and the Kindle Fire are "very different products, but the critical break-point is $199, and $249 [for the Nook Tablet] does not have that same cachet with buyers," said Rob Enderle, an analyst at Enderle Group. "Below $200 is a much bigger market than $249, and Barnes & Noble is missing the break-point that's going to be the critical factor in sales, not specs."
Enderle's reasoning is based on consumer technology sales history and how shoppers buy during the holiday season. While a person buying for himself might weigh more carefully the superior memory and storage of the Nook Tablet, that same buyer would want to hold down the cost below $200 when buying one as a gift, he said.
Jack Gold, an analyst at J. Gold Associates, said the $50 difference could weigh against Barnes & Noble because "most buyers aren't crazy techies and won't go through every spec like I would ... For most users, the extra memory won't be that important."
IDC analyst Tom Mainelli said it is hard to predict how important the $50 price difference will be, but added that the customers Barnes & Noble is going after are "likely not that specification-driven."
Barnes & Noble also claimed the Nook has a better screen than the Kindle Fire, "but that's one of those things that you'll need to compare side by side." Both devices have a 1024 x 600 touch screen, but the Nook Tablet benefits from a VividView display, Barnes & Noble officials said.
Barnes & Noble CEO William Lynch drubbed the Kindle Fire on its specs, calling it "deficient" as a media-playing device, partly because it has just 512MB of RAM, compared with the Nook Tablet's 1GB of RAM. Documents leaked on Engadget last week said the Nook's dual-core processor would have a processor speed of 1.2 GHz, but Barnes & Noble said Monday that the Nook's dual-core processor is 1 GHz, the same as the Kindle Fire's.
The Nook Tablet has 16GB of internal storage, expandable with a slot for a 32GB memory card, while the Kindle Fire has 8GB of internal storage that Lynch said would be insufficient for when a user is not connected to the Internet over Wi-Fi.
Tablet war
- The future of the $200 tablet
- Asus, fifth and rising in tablet market
- Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 (7.0) review: A nice price, but where's the 'wow'?
- Toshiba's jumbo tablet, the Excite 13, garners early kudos, scorn
- Why Amazon can't win a tablet price war against Google
- What would Google gain from an online tablet store?
- Two Windows 7 tablets: HP Slate 2 vs. Samsung Series 7 Slate
- Tablet priced under $100 with Android 4.0 surfaces
- Asus Eee Pad Transformer Prime: The Rolls-Royce of Android tablets
- Amazon sees Kindle sales surge on Black Friday


- Excel 2010 Cheat Sheet
- Register for this Computerworld Insider Cheat Sheet and gain access to hundreds of premium content articles, guides, product reviews and more.
- Mobile Middleware Strategies
- Learn why a mobile development platform is critical to be able to support today's complex enterprise mobility strategies. Learn what to look for...
- The Evolution of Enterprise Mobile App Development
- Driven by explosive growth in smartphone and tablet sales, enterprise mobility has become an essential part of business. Organizations across industries are developing...
- Native & HTML5 Mobile Apps: Not an either or, but a where and when
- Learn how developers are using HTML5 and native development methods to build mobile apps. Get practical insights on how these tools are being...
- Enabling Remote Employees with High Quality Video
- In this paper, we analyze the delivery of live and on-demand mobile video content. It focuses on specific ways in which organizations can...
- What to Look For in Solutions For Mobile Device Management
- Managing an increasingly mobile workforce has become one of the most challenging - and important - responsibilities for IT departments. This paper examines... All Mobile and Wireless White Papers
- The Office of Tomorrow with BlackBerry
- Curious about the office of the future and how to prepare with BlackBerry solutions? This session discusses the office needs of tomorrow and...
- The Changing Role of Tablets in the Enterprise
- Do you understand all the capabilities and potential of the BlackBerry PlayBook tablet? BlackBerry® PlayBook™ tablet can help enterprises do business differently.
This webcast... - Security Certifications 101 - BlackBerry and all those acronyms what do they mean and why they matter?
- FIPS, Common Criteria, CAPS, AISEP, NFC, NIST, Fraunhofer SIT, CESG, DSD - these are just some of the government and industry certifications which...
- PlayBook Video about two Grade 6 classrooms that are using PlayBook tablets
- RIM recently worked with Park Manor Public School in Elmira, ON to integrate BlackBerry PlayBook tablets in two Grade 6 classrooms. The project...
- McCain Canada deployed BlackBerry PlayBook tablets with a custom application to their salesforce
- McCain Foods Limited (McCain) has deployed BlackBerry® PlayBook™ tablets in order to enhance mobility within their sales force- along with a customized application... All Mobile and Wireless Webcasts
Prepaid service has started to transform from a source of cheap, bottom-of-the-barrel phones into a viable outlet for compelling smartphones. Read more...
