One company's move to go virtual leads to I/O constraints
Replicating data in a virtual machine means you can be storage system agnostic
Computerworld - Austin Radiological Association is a quarter of the way toward virtualizing its server and desktop infrastructure, but the move has placed a strain on its networked storage and slowed application performance.
ARA, which provides diagnostic imaging services through 15 outpatient centers in central Texas, is trying out a new product from startup Zerto, which launched last year with an unusual approach to data protection. Instead of protecting data by replicating it offsite from storage arrays, it uses software to replicate the data within the virtual machines.
ARA's IT department has about 40 people managing almost 800TB of data. It has about 1,000 desktops for 800 employees along with 300 servers, about 25% of which are currently virtualized using VMware and Citrix XenServer.
ARA, which is part of a larger consortium of radiological imaging firms, had originally imagined itself moving to a private cloud, carving up its data center, selling services to its regional affiliates and becoming the "center of the universe." But that became complicated fast.
"We backed off that cloud marketing hype and decided to learn to crawl before we sprinted," said ARA CIO Todd Thomas. "We didn't see ourselves doing chargeback right away or auto provisioning of servers right away, because our processes weren't mature enough as an IT organization."
So ARA shifted its plan to virtualizing its data center, selecting Cisco's Unified Computing System (UCS) blade center as its server farm, and EMC and NetApp products for storage. But what Thomas didn't want to do is get locked into a particular vendor's data replication software.
"If I want to switch colocation providers, it's easier to migrate a virtual machine and not care about what the underlying storage platform is," Thomas said.
As with most companies, ARA's data replication scheme for business continuity and disaster recovery is based in its networked storage, which features both EMC Symmetrix DMX-4 950 and NetApp 3140 arrays. Replication in those arrays is performed at the block or file level, meaning data is either mirrored or copied to its offsite recovery facility 20 miles south of its primary data center in Austin. ARA uses both EMC's Symmetrix Remote Data Facility/Asynchronous (SRDF/A) and MirrorView software for data replication.
But when it began virtualizing its server and desktop environment, the strain of additional virtual machines overwhelmed its storage arrays' I/O bandwidth.
The ARA project started as a XenApp installation in which applications were going to be streamed down to Wyse Technology thin clients. "In that rollout, we ran into a number of hurdles that shifted our strategy to go more the VDI route than just the applications streaming route," Thomas said.
But an "unforeseen" explosion of virtual desktops created I/O performance problems. "We got about 70% of the way through the project and are now on hold," he said. Instead of 80% streaming applications and 20% VDI, ARA wound up implementing 80% virtual desktops and 20% streaming apps.
"The predominance of virtual desktops created a strain on our storage arrays we weren't anticipating," Thomas said. Not surprisingly, application performance began to suffer.


- Excel 2010 Cheat Sheet
- Register for this Computerworld Insider Cheat Sheet and gain access to hundreds of premium content articles, guides, product reviews and more.
- Virtualizing the Client - The HP Way
- HP VirtualSystem delivers best-in-class virtualization, with integrated software, services, infrastructure, and management - all delivered as one proven solution.
Intel and the Intel logo... - Using HP's Converged Storage to Develop/Enhance Business Resiliency in VMware Environments
- In this report, Enterprise Strategy Group reviews how HP's portfolio of hardware, software, and services can provide the foundational support for VMware environments....
- CIO Guide to Virtual Server Data Protection
- Server virtualization is changing the face of the modern data center. CIOs are looking for ways to virtualize more applications, faster across the...
- IDG Tech Dossier: Converged Storage ~ A Next Gen Virtualized Architecture
- Organizations need a strategy for rearchitecting storage so that it enables, rather than constricts, the delivery of IT services. According to HP, it's...
- Forrester on the Converged Infrastructure
- To understand infrastructure and operations (I&O) perceptions of converged infrastructure (CI), Forrester Consulting surveyed 200 I&O decision-makers from six different countries. Decision-makers were... All Virtualization White Papers
- Live Webcast
Today's NAS: A Solution Beyond Old Limits - Date: Tuesday, July 17, 2012 2:00 PM EDT
Traditional NAS systems don't scale beyond fixed limits. Proliferation of NAS systems leads to management... - Today's NAS: A Solution Beyond Old Limits
- Date: Tuesday, July 17, 2012 2:00 PM EDT
Traditional NAS systems don't scale beyond fixed limits. Proliferation of NAS systems leads to management... - Best Practices to Optimize Your Data Center at Every Layer of the Stack
- Date: May 31, 2012
Time: 1 PM EST
Organizations are reaping the benefits of simplifying IT, lowering costs and dramatically improving transactional throughput by deploying... - North Pole to South Seas: Overcoming the Pitfalls of remote Performance
- In today's always-on world, connectivity is a business requirement. You need the tools that allow you to operate as if you were on...
- Virtualizing Disaster Recovery and Business Continuity
- Disaster recovery is a form of insurance to protect your IT assets when a disaster strikes. Learn how to protect your business in...
- Virtualization Success is a Team Effort
- As greater numbers of datacenter servers transition from the physical to the virtual world, the components of virtualization success come to the fore.... All Virtualization Webcasts