Google antitrust probe to shed light on search, experts say
But Google supporters question whether there's evidence that the company has been anticompetitive
IDG News Service - The U.S. Federal Trade Commission's antitrust investigation into Google's search engine could shine some light on the secret inner workings of the company's search ranking decisions and the relationship between advertising and free search results, some Google critics said Friday.
With other Google services being integrated with its search engine and Google offering both paid search and free search results, there's an "enormous possibility for abuse," said Eric Clemons, an operations and information management professor at the University of Pennsylvania.
Google's paid search service gives the company an incentive to keep its free search results from getting too good, Clemons said at a Technology Policy Institute (TPI) forum on Google and antitrust in Washington, D.C. "I've always wanted to say this in Washington: Follow the money," he said.
The FTC's antitrust probe of Google, reported in June, will give investigators a chance to see how Google ranks search results, giving the public a "first line of defense" against anticompetitive practices, said Oren Bracha, a law professor focused on technology and intellectual property at the University of Texas.
"The whole search process is shrouded in secrecy," Bracha said. "It's a big black box, and nobody except Google really knows what's going on in there. Somebody gets to open the black box."
While Clemons and Bracha argued in favor of an investigation, other speakers on Friday questioned whether an antitrust probe of Google was appropriate. Though some competitors have complained about Google's search dominance and its search rankings, antitrust cases must show harm to consumers, said Geoffrey Manne, founder of the International Center for Law and Economics, an organization that has received support from Google.
There don't seem to be any major complaints against Google alleging consumer harm, Manne said.
Also, although Google has become a huge company, that's not a good reason to bring an antitrust lawsuit against the company, said Manne and Michael Katz, a business professor at the University of California, Berkeley. U.S. law allows companies to become monopolies, as long as they act fairly, said Katz, who has worked with Google.
"In the United States, there's nothing wrong with making lots of money," Katz said.
Google should have the ability to add services and integrate search functionality with other products as a way to better serve customers, Katz said. Microsoft's Bing search engine integrates an airfare pricing service, and there are few complaints, he said.
People complaining about Google adding services to search have the attitude of, "Innovation? We don't need no stinkin' innovation," Katz said.
Thomas Lenard, TPI's president, questioned how FTC investigators could tell if Google's search results were biased. "If you were at the FTC, what would you be looking at?" he said.
Determining search bias will not be easy, Bracha said. "One cannot imagine equal, neutral treatment for everybody in this context," he said. "Search, in order to be useful at all, is inherently hierarchical. Somebody has to be at the bottom."
But the American Homeowners Grassroots Alliance, an advocacy group that doesn't disclose its supporters, has heard "countless complaints" from small-business marketers of niche products who see their Google search rankings drop for no apparent reason, said Bruce Hahn, the group's president.
"I don't know what other explanation there could be, other than there's some bias in Google search, and for what reasons, other than financial gain?" Hahn said.
Friday's Google antitrust forum may be a preview of a U.S. Senate hearing next Wednesday. The Senate Judiciary Committee's antitrust subcommittee will host a hearing entitled, "The Power of Google: Serving Consumers or Threatening Competition?" at 2 p.m. that day. Eric Schmidt, Google's executive chairman, is scheduled to be a witness.
Grant Gross covers technology and telecom policy in the U.S. government for The IDG News Service. Follow Grant on Twitter at GrantGross. Grant's e-mail address is firstname.lastname@example.org.
- Chrome users attack Google for zapping unsanctioned Windows add-ons
- Google postpones add-on 'kill switch' for Chrome on Windows
- Google yanks option to restore Chrome's old-style new tab page, riles users all over again
- Google's 3D tech could be boon to Glass, robots and virtual reality
- Google bots are coming!
- Antitrust deal leaves Google unscathed
- Google agrees to give equal prominence to rivals' services to settle EU antitrust case
- Lenovo-Moto deal's impact on Apple? Zip
- With Motorola sold, Google can focus on robots, Glass and smart homes
- Google is developing a smart contact lens
- 15 Non-Certified IT Skills Growing in Demand
- How 19 Tech Titans Target Healthcare
- Twitter Suffering From Growing Pains (and Facebook Comparisons)
- Agile Comes to Data Integration
- Slideshow: 7 security mistakes people make with their mobile device
- iOS vs. Android: Which is more secure?
- 11 sure signs you've been hacked
- Pay-as-you-Grow Data Protection: IBM Tivoli's Full-featured Data Protection Suite for Small to Medium Businesses IBM Tivoli Storage Manager Suite for Unified Recovery gives small and medium businesses the opportunity to start out with only the individual solutions...
- Streamline Data Protection with IBM Tivoli Storage Manager Operations Center IBM Tivoli Storage Manager (TSM) has been an industry-standard data protection solution for two decades. But, where most competitors focus exclusively on Backup...
- Simplify and Consolidate Data Protection for Better Business Results Learn about IBM® Tivoli® Storage Manager Operations Center, which provides advanced visualization, built-in analytics and integrated workflow automation features that leapfrog traditional backup...
- HP HAVEn: See the big picture in Big Data HP HAVEn is the industry's first comprehensive, scalable, open, and secure platform for Big Data. Enterprises are drowning in a sea of data...
- Meg Whitman presents Unlocking IT with Big Data During this Web Event you will hear Meg Whitman, President and CEO, HP discuss HAVEn - the #1 Big Data platform, as well...
- The New Way to Work Knowledge Vault This Knowledge Vault focuses on how, in today's increasingly virtual world, it's more important than ever to engage deeply with employees, suppliers, partners,... All Internet Search White Papers | Webcasts