Apple wins restraining order against N.Y. stores for trademark infringement
'Apple Story' exposed by blogger who uncovered elaborate Apple retail copycat in China
Computerworld - A federal judge yesterday granted Apple's request for a preliminary injunction and issued a temporary restraining against several retailers for infringing Apple's trademark, according to court documents.
On July 25, Apple filed a complaint that named three companies, two individuals and 50 "John Does," in the lawsuit.
Two of the firms -- Apple Story Inc. and Fun Zone Inc. -- match the name of stores in Flushing, N.Y. located about three blocks apart on the city's Main Street. The two are represented by Samuel Chuang, also from Flushing.
Fun Zone and Chuang did not reply to requests for comment, and Apple Story was unavailable for comment.
Apple Story may have come to the attention of Apple because of the efforts of a blogger known as "BirdAbroad," who last month revealed a copycat store in Kunming, China that went to great lengths to duplicate Apple retail stores' look and feel.
After soliciting more photos from her readers, on July 23 BirdAbroad posted images of several other Apple look-alikes, including one with the sign that read "Apple Story" located in Flushing.
Within days, Chinese authorities announced that they had closed two unauthorized stores in the country for operating without a business license, but allowed several others to remain open.
Kunming, the capital of Yunnan Province in southwest China -- the province borders both Laos and Vietnam -- does not have a legitimate Apple retail store. Currently, Apple has only four company-owned stores in the country, two in Beijing and two in Shanghai.
The AppleInsider blog first reported on the lawsuit Apple filed in a Brooklyn, N.Y. federal court
Details on the lawsuit are scanty because all case documents remain sealed, available only to the court and the parties' counsels.
Yesterday, however, U.S. District Court Judge Kiyo Matsumoto granted a preliminary injunction against the defendants, including Apple Story and Fun Zone, and simultaneously issued a temporary restraining order.
Typically, a preliminary injunction and the resulting retraining order bar the recipient from continuing questionable conduct until the underlying case has been decided. In a trademark dispute, the results of such an injunction and order would likely prevent the defendant from using the trademark, forcing him to change signage or even modify his business.
From the photo posted by BirdAbroad, Apple Story appears to be a smartphone accessories outlet. On Facebook, Fun Zone bills itself as a mobile phone repair shop.
Matsumoto has scheduled a show-cause hearing Aug. 12 to listen to arguments from Apple and the defendants' attorney about whether the temporary restraining order should be extended.
Gregg Keizer covers Microsoft, security issues, Apple, Web browsers and general technology breaking news for Computerworld. Follow Gregg on Twitter at @gkeizer, on Google+ or subscribe to Gregg's RSS feed . His e-mail address is email@example.com.
- Trade-in volume signals 'tremendous' sales for iPhone 6
- Carmakers put Apple's CarPlay in the slow lane
- Apple updates OS X Yosemite public beta
- Even rivals are waiting for Apple to get into wearables
- Apple preps final non-security Mavericks update
- New Yosemite dev preview may herald public beta update later this week
- iPhone 5C's China bust raises questions about Apple's pricing for '14 models
- Mac sales so far in '14 may signal share push
- China scrubs Apple's iPad and MacBooks from government buying list
- Circle the date: Apple's iPhone 6 event slated for Sept. 9
Read more about Legal in Computerworld's Legal Topic Center.
- An Insightful Approach to Optimizing Mainframe MLC Spend This paper discusses how you can penetrate the complexity of IBM mainframe MLC products and the MLC price model to gain insight into...
- Meeting the Exploding Demand for New IT Services In this eBook, explore the top trends driving the New IT for IT Service Management, and how leading organizations are evolving to focus...
- Hybrid IT-A Low-Risk Path from On-Premise to ITaaS This white paper provides a strategy to move part or all of your ITSM suite to the cloud as a stepping stone to...
- Paving the Windows XP Migration Path to Success Support for Windows XP has ended, leaving organizations with three choices: Windows 8, Windows 7 or a combination. With the right planning and...
- Increase Your Data Center IQ Discover how to improve network efficiency, lower IT costs and more proactively manage your physical, virtual and cloud environments.
- Optimize Data Center Resources and Plan for the Future Eliminate over-provisioning and capacity shortfalls with pro-active capacity optimization. Join us in the evolution from capacity monitoring to capacity optimization in your data... All Hardware White Papers | Webcasts