Google loss in Nortel patent bids undermines Android, analyst says
Cash-rich Google should have beat out consortium that includes Apple, Microsoft
Computerworld - Google's failure to win a bid on 6,000 Nortel patents raises doubts about Google's commitment to Android and its large community of developers and device manufacturers, one prominent analyst said Friday.
Florian Mueller, an intellectual property analyst and blogger, said by email that it was surprising Google, which is rich with cash, didn't outbid a consortium of six companies that yesterday offered $4.5 billion for the Nortel patent portfolio. The portfolio spans wireless technology and related area.
"Google lost an unprecedented opportunity to acquire a major bargaining chip that would strengthen it at the mobile industry's intellectual property negotiating table," Mueller contended. "I'm afraid it won't get a similar opportunity in quantitative and qualitative terms anytime soon."
According to Mueller, there are already 45 patent infringement lawsuits surrounding Android and makers of Android devices. "In light of Android's patent problems, it's surprising that Google didn't outbid everybody else," he said. "It could have afforded more than $4.5 billion, but it doesn't appear to be truly committed to Android."
Mueller has contended in his blog and in articles he has written for the UK-based Guardian newspaper that Google has generally been too weak in terms of patents it owns to protect Android and a huge evolving ecosystem around it. That ecosystem now includes more than 300 smartphones and tablets made by several prominent manufacturers and supported by thousands of developers large and small.
Google's senior vice president and general counsel Kent Walker issued a statement that the outcome of the Nortel bidding was "disappointing for anyone who believes that open innovation benefits users and promotes creativity and competition." He vowed that Google would "keep working" to reduce the "flood" of patent litigation.
Walker had blogged in April that Google was bidding for the Nortel patents in hopes of creating a disincentive for groups planning to sue Google, its partners and the open source community.
Even if Google has its heart in the right place, Mueller said it will now be left with the option of buying up smaller quantities of patents "from failed startups and similar kinds of sellers" offering patents with little bearing on Android or evolving technologies such as Long Term Evolution wireless, expected to be critical to the growth of Android.
The winning consortium for the Nortel patents, made up of Apple, EMC, Ericsson, Microsoft, Research in Motion and Sony, appears to have purchased the portfolio as a "defensive" move to "clear the market and prevent the patents from being used in the wrong ways."
With Google left out, its patent position is shaky, Mueller contended. "No major industry player is as needed in terms of patents as Google," he said.
Matt Hamblen covers mobile and wireless, smartphones and other handhelds, and wireless networking for Computerworld. Follow Matt on Twitter at
@matthamblen or subscribe to
Matt's RSS feed. His e-mail address is mhamblen@computerworld.com.
Patent wars
- Apple files another U.S. patent suit against Samsung
- Motorola Mobility fails to make patent case against Apple in German court
- Samsung wins against Apple, Galaxy Tab 10.1N still on sale
- Samsung loses again in German patent suit against Apple
- Apple files new lawsuit against Samsung in Germany
- Apple loses first round in ITC case against Motorola
- Patent win will boost Apple fight against Android
- Samsung files four more patent claims against Apple
- Apple names Kindle Fire in revised 'App Store' lawsuit against Amazon
- Oracle, Google again fail to settle Android lawsuit
Read more about DRM and Legal Issues in Computerworld's DRM and Legal Issues Topic Center.



- Excel 2010 Cheat Sheet
- Register for this Computerworld Insider Cheat Sheet and gain access to hundreds of premium content articles, guides, product reviews and more.
- ESG: Defining Tier One Storage in the Modern Data Center
- This report defines "tier-1" storage in the modern IT world and in the data centers and services that support it. What was a...
- ESG: Using HP's Converged Storage to Develop/Enhance Business Resiliency in VMware Environments
- In this report, Enterprise Strategy Group reviews how HP's portfolio of hardware, software, and services can provide the foundational support for VMware environments....
- HP 3PAR Storage Systems Designed for Mission Critical High Availability
- In this technical whitepaper, learn how HP 3PAR Storage Systems have been designed to deliver 99.999% and greater availability, bringing new possibilities to...
- Utility Storage - The Ideal Platform for Virtual and Cloud Computing
- Server virtualization has transformed corporate IT -- companies have enjoyed major cost savings and have gained flexibility and efficiency. But this has also...
- ESG Lab Review: Focus on Federated Workload Balancing, Asset Management, and Thin Provisioning
- This ESG Lab review documents hands-on testing of HP 3PAR Peer Motion Software's distributed volume management with a focus on federated workload balancing,... All DRM and Legal Issues White Papers
- The Higher-Bandwidth, Lower-Cost Connection of Choice: 10GBASE-T LAN on Motherboard
- Learn how Expedient, a cloud provider, is using 10 Gigabit Ethernet to boost its services and rein in costs.
- Banish Poor Application Performance
- End User Experience, 30-Min Webinar
Wed. March 21st ~ 11 AM ET
Are you ready to gain the proactive ability to rapidly respond... - Virtualization KnowledgeVault
- Virtualization initiatives are underway at most small and midsize businesses, but some unexpected challenges have prevented many organizations from achieving original goals. This...
- Mobility KnowledgeVault
- How "mobile ready" is your infrastructure? This Mobility Knowledge Vault provides a wide variety of expert advice on how to strike a balance...
- Integrated IT Operations Management in the Cloud
- Join award-winning technology editor Stan Gibson and Andrew White, CMO at BMC, to learn how asset management and service management are converging and... All DRM and Legal Issues Webcasts
