Who gets blame for Amazon outage?
Reliability of cloud services makes customers complacent; many don't plan for worst-case scenarios
Computerworld - Amazon.com has promised to provide a "detailed post-mortem" on the root causes of the prolonged outage of its cloud services in recent days. Users of the Amazon services, meanwhile, may also have to explain how they got caught up in the outage.
The ensuing conversations may be uncomfortable for both Amazon and its cloud customers -- perhaps even more so for users of the services.
Cloud services overall have been remarkably reliable, which may be fostering a dangerous complacency among customers who are putting too must trust in them. This is another old and familiar story of technology hubris, one that was famously illustrated by another tech marvel, the unsinkable Titanic.
In this case, it is IT managers who will have to explain to their users -- and to their companies' executives -- why they didn't have a lifeboat.
Amazon's partial outage, which began Thursday and seemed largely resolved today, was an exceptional event.
Based on data compiled by AppNeta, the uptime reliability of 40 of the largest providers of cloud-based services, including Amazon, Google, Azure and Salesforce.com, shows how well cloud providers are delivering uninterrupted services. The performance management and network monitoring firm, known as Apparent Networks until this week, captures minute-by-minute uptime and other data from cloud providers used by its customers.
The overall industry yearly average of uptime for all the cloud services providers monitored by AppNeta is 99.948%, which is equal to 273 minutes of unavailability per year.
The worst providers clock in at 99.92%, or 420 minutes of unavailability each year.
The best providers are at 99.9994%, or three minutes of unavailability each year.
The takeaway for cloud users looking at the AppNeta data is that the risk of an outage is generally very low.
But that's not how the world works.
For example, Ken Brill, founder of the Uptime Institute, which researches data center issues, points to Japan's Fukushima Nuclear Power Plant. For 40 years, there were no problems at the plant. Then an earthquake and tsunami that hit in March disabled the facility with catastrophic consequences.
Brill expects that a post-mortem on the nuclear plant will show at least 10 things that could have been done to help avoid that failure and reduce the magnitude of damage and would have made it easier or faster to recover from.
The Amazon post-mortem will likely show something similar, said Brill.
Despite the redundancies and backups built into the Amazon cloud, "you hit a combination of events for which the backups don't work," he said.
Users see the promise of cloud technology as a way to reduce costs and be greener, but "that [also] means concentrating processing in fewer, bigger places," said Brill. Thus, when something goes wrong, "it has a bigger impact."
- Cloud security concerns are overblown, experts say
- Cloud computing 2014: Moving to a zero-trust security model
- Amazon hiring 'top secret' IT staff as it fights for CIA work
- Empire state ends IT empire building
- No, your data isn't secure in the cloud
- Snowden revelations may cost U.S. cloud providers billions, says study
- DHS shifting to cloud, agile development to boost homeland security
- Cloud computing's big debt to NASA
- Coke bottler picks SaaS over SAP
- Inmate data paroled from mainframe
- 15 Non-Certified IT Skills Growing in Demand
- How 19 Tech Titans Target Healthcare
- Twitter Suffering From Growing Pains (and Facebook Comparisons)
- Agile Comes to Data Integration
- Slideshow: 7 security mistakes people make with their mobile device
- iOS vs. Android: Which is more secure?
- 11 sure signs you've been hacked
- ESG: The IBM FlashSystem 840: Technical Evolution to Deliver Business Value In this whitepaper, you will learn how this high-speed storage technology has tremendous potential to support I/O-intensive and/or latency-sensitive applications.
- Choosing an MDM Platform: Where to Start the Conversation If you're in the early stages of choosing an MDM solution, or you're considering switching vendors, here are seven critical questions to ask...
- Axeda Platform Technical Overview This paper summarizes the major features of an IoT platform and explains how they simplify and speed the process of developing and deploying...
- Stock Shock: The effect of project and portfolio management on share price In this independent report, you'll see the intrinsic connection between long-term capital investment and short term market performance -- and how this can...
- Meg Whitman presents Unlocking IT with Big Data During this Web Event you will hear Meg Whitman, President and CEO, HP discuss HAVEn - the #1 Big Data platform, as well...
- Cloud Knowledge Vault Learn how your organization can benefit from the scalability, flexibility, and performance that the cloud offers through the short videos and other resources... All Cloud Computing White Papers | Webcasts