Court rules Amazon doesn't have to turn over customer names
IDG News Service - North Carolina's Department of Revenue violated the First Amendment in asking Amazon.com for names of customers who bought books, a Washington judge ruled on Monday.
The ruling is a win for free speech advocates, but the ACLU may continue to pursue the issue because the ruling may not prevent similar requests for broad customer data in the future.
The lawsuit has its roots in a dispute over whether Amazon must pay sales tax on goods shipped to North Carolina residents. As part of its investigations into the issue, North Carolina asked Amazon to send it "all information for all sales" to customers in the state.
Amazon complied by sending specific information, including book titles, about products shipped to North Carolina. The trouble started when North Carolina then asked for the names and addresses of customers. Amazon subsequently asked the court to rule that sending customer names to North Carolina violates the customers' First Amendment rights because the state would then be able to match people's names with specific book titles.
The ACLU joined the case on behalf of people who fear the government tracking their online purchases.
North Carolina has said that it doesn't need specific information about products like book titles, despite its broad request for "all information." But it also says that procedural issues prevent it from returning the original discs that Amazon sent to it with the specific data like book titles. Amazon is unwilling to send North Carolina customer names now since the state could match those names with specific book titles.
On Monday, Judge Marsha Pechman of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington ruled in favor of Amazon's argument that North Carolina's request for customer names violates the First Amendment. She denied North Carolina's request to dismiss the suit.
"Issuing the declaratory relief as phrased does not prohibit the [Department of Revenue] from issuing a new request for information as to only the names and addresses of Amazon's customers and general product information, assuming that DOR destroys any detailed information that it currently possesses," the judge wrote in her ruling.
A spokeswoman with North Carolina's attorney general's office said that its attorneys are reviewing the ruling and have not made a decision about whether to appeal.
The judge did not rule on the ACLU and the interveners' arguments because they have not yet requested summary judgment. The ACLU isn't sure yet about its next steps, said Aden Fine, staff attorney at the ACLU. Because the ruling is specific to this situation, North Carolina could continue to issue broad requests for information from online retailers. In fact, North Carolina has said that other retailers have already turned over detailed information following its broad requests, he said.
- Troubleshooting Common Issues in VoIP Learn more about Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP), including common VoIP metrics used, best practices in VoIP management and tips and tricks for...
- IDG Research Survey: Are you Paying Too Much for Your NMS? Feel like you're paying too much for network monitoring? You're not alone. This survey brief summarizes findings from research recently fielded by IDG...
- 2013 Network Management Software (NMS) Buyers Guide This white paper contains an independent comparison study of six different network management solutions and provides guidance on how you can choose the...
- Rightsizing Your Network Performance Management Solution: 4 Case Studies This white paper discusses challenges encountered as organizations search for the most cost-effective network performance management solution.
- Live Webcast 5 Steps to Assuring Quality of Experience In order to align monitoring and management practices with the true demands of the business, IT professionals must expand beyond traditional comfort zones...
- Live Webcast Master the Changing SAP Landscape with Performance Management SAP landscapes are not getting simpler. Gradually, business processes that used to be contained on a single SAP system now involve a range...
- E-Signature RFP Checklist Webcast If your organization is looking to adopt e-signatures, you may be overwhelmed by the number of providers that offer seemingly similar solutions. How...
- Navigating the New Wireless Landscape Thriving in the new wireless landscape View Now>> All Networking White Papers | Webcasts
Our new bimonthly Internet of Things newsletter helps you keep pace with the rapidly evolving technologies, trends and developments related to the IoT. Subscribe now and stay up to date!