Lawsuit shows HP sees Hurd as primal threat
However, the suit against its ex-CEO over confidentiality may not have much of a chance, says one analyst
Computerworld - Hewlett-Packard's reaction to the move by former CEO Mark Hurd to the upper ranks of Oracle is one of sound and fury, but mostly fear.
The fear is that it be "impossible for him [Hurd] to avoid disclosing or utilizing HP's trade secrets or confidential information," HP said in a lawsuit filed in a California Superior Court less than 24 hours after Oracle announced, on Labor Day, that it had hired Hurd as co-president.
Hurd resigned last month following a sexual harassment claim and questions about related expense account reports.
Hurd's new boss, Oracle CEO Larry Ellison, was critical of HP's board for forcing Hurd's ouster.
With Hurd at Oracle, HP faces a loss of customers and technology, as well as "its competitive advantage, its trade secrets and goodwill in amounts that may be impossible to determine, unless Hurd is enjoined and restrained by order of this court," according to legal papers HP filed in California Superior Court in Santa Clara.
Those are strong warnings by HP, but they may matter less in California than in other states, where courts don't recognize noncompete agreements, said legal experts.
It is not uncommon for companies to try to limit the potential risk posed by former employees with agreements, for instance, that bar an ex-employee from taking a job with a competitor for some period of time.
However, under California law, you can't stop someone from going to work for a competitor, "even the most senior executives who may possess a great deal of confidential information," said Michael Rosen, an attorney at Foley Hoag LLP in Boston, who also writes about noncompete law.
In its lawsuit, HP wants an injunction barring Hurd from taking a job at Oracle because of the threat he poses, not what he has done.
"Obtaining such an injunction in the absence of any evidence that he has taken or utilized trade secrets will be very difficult," said Rosen.
The legal argument HP is raising is based on something in California law called the inevitable disclosure doctrine, which argues that there is no way for employees, in some circumstances, to go to a competitor without disclosing confidential information, said business law attorney Peter Berlin.
But Berlin said the problem for HP is that the inevitable disclosure doctrine was overturned. "I'm not sure how far they will get this lawsuit," he said.
Kenneth Chin, an analyst at Gartner, said HP does have a point about the threat posed by Hurd, because he has seen all the product road maps, particularly in the servers and storage areas.
Since Oracle's acquisition of Sun Microsystems earlier this year, Oracle has emerged as a direct hardware competitor to HP.
But the help that Oracle will get from Hurd, at least as far as his knowledge about HP's plans go, also has a time stamp on it of one to two years, as product road maps inevitably change, said Chin.
Chin said he expects that the two firms will reach a settlement quickly to put the dispute to rest.
Patrick Thibodeau covers SaaS and enterprise applications, outsourcing, government IT policies, data centers and IT workforce issues for Computerworld. Follow Patrick on Twitter at @DCgov or subscribe to Patrick's RSS feed . His e-mail address is email@example.com.
- Aloha point-of-sale terminal, sold on eBay, yields security surprises
- HP, Intel, GM and Walmart demand changes to renewable energy industry
- Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols: Does HP have a development pipeline or a pipe dream?
- HP Places Its Data Center Bet on 'The Machine'
- 6 Emerging Programming Languages Career-Minded Developers Should Learn
- Beware the next circle of hell: Unpatchable systems
- Rackspace not a good fit for Cisco, says Chambers
- Solar power to provide HP's HQ with 20% of its electricity
- Review: Dell WYSE delivers Android-on-a-stick
- 6 Top Enterprise Workgroup Printers
Read more about Management in Computerworld's Management Topic Center.
- Who does NSS Labs "Recommend" for NGFW? In 2012, NSS Labs found that most available NGFW solutions "fell short in performance and security effectiveness." In 2013 NSS Labs noted "marked...
- What is this "File Sync" Thing and Why Should I Care About It? All of a sudden, getting a file from your work laptop to your iPad became as simple as clicking "Save." So it's no...
- The Keys to Securing Data in a Collaborative Workplace Losing data is costly. IT professionals have spent years learning how to protect their organizations from hackers, but how do you ward off...
- The Growing Demand for Rich Media This white paper discusses how IBM Customer Experience Suite Rich Media Edition can automate rich media workflows, from collaborating with creative agencies and...
- What should I look for in a Next Generation Firewall? SANS Provides Guidance With so many vendors claiming to have a Next Generation Firewall (NGFW), it can be difficult to tell what makes each one different....
- Why Are Customers Really Deploying an NGFW? It seems every IT Security expert is talking about the NGFW, but what are people really doing? This webcast covers 5 real-world customer... All Management White Papers | Webcasts