After beating Microsoft, VirnetX hits Apple with patent suit
Settled with Microsoft for $200M last May, now moves against Apple's iPhone
Computerworld - A firm that received a $200 million settlement from MIcrosoft in May filed similar patent infringement charges against Apple Wednesday, claiming that the iPhone and iPad illegally use its technology.
Scotts Valley, Calif.-based VirnetX sued Apple and three other companies -- Cisco, NEC and phone maker Aastra -- in the same East Texas federal court where it was awarded a $106 million judgment in March in its case against Microsoft.
Two months later, Microsoft settled for almost twice that amount to dismiss the original three-year-old lawsuit and a newer follow-up that added Windows 7 to the list of infringing products. Microsoft also licensed the VirnetX patents as part of the settlement.
Wednesday's suit claimed that Apple's iPhone -- all models, including the newest iPhone 4 -- iPod Touch and iPad infringed a pair of VirnetX patents.
One of the two that Apple allegedly infringed -- identified as Patent No. 6,502,135 -- was also one of the pair that VirnetX said Microsoft violated.
The patent cited in both lawsuits, titled "Agile network protocol for secure communications with assured system availability," describes technologies for creating and managing a virtual private networking (VPN) connection.
VirnetX is a holding company that claims a portfolio of four dozen patents, many of them awarded to a team of engineers who once worked at SAIC, or Science Application International Corp., a firm that regularly contracts with the Department of Defense.
"We expect to derive the majority of our revenue from license fees and royalties associated with these patents," VirnetX plainly states on its Web site.
It hasn't done badly. On Monday, the company announced second-quarter revenues of $200 million, up nearly 28,000-fold from the $7,200 it earned in the same quarter in 2009.
The lawsuit also named Canadian company Aastra, U.S.-based Cisco, and the Japanese multinational firm NEC, with the other defendants charged with infringing one, four and two VirnetX patents, respectively.
VirnetX drew the same judge who heard the Microsoft case, U.S. District Court Judge Leonard Davis, for its latest lawsuit.
VirnetX has asked for both unspecified damages and injunctive relief, although the latter is rarely awarded in patent litigation.
But it's not impossible. Last October, Davis did issue an injunction in another patent lawsuit when he barred Microsoft from selling its Word program. The injunction went into effect in January 2010, forcing Microsoft to strip the infringing technology from Word 2007.
VirnetX is again represented by McKool Smith, the Dallas law firm that represented it in the Microsoft patent infringement case.
Gregg Keizer covers Microsoft, security issues, Apple, Web browsers and general technology breaking news for Computerworld. Follow Gregg on Twitter at @gkeizer or subscribe to Gregg's RSS feed . His e-mail address is email@example.com.
- Yosemite's traffic share triples after public beta debuts
- Apple hasn't exhausted its supply of Yosemite betas
- 13 pieces of advice for Yosemite beta testers
- The other Apple economy: $2B in devices on eBay
- Apple sends users scrambling for OS X Yosemite
- Long replacement cycle drags down iPad sales
- Apple unwraps OS X Yosemite public beta Thursday
- Apple grows Mac sales by 18% on the back of the MacBook Air
- Want an Apple watch? Just 3D print one
- What to listen for during Apple's earnings call today
Read more about Legal in Computerworld's Legal Topic Center.
- Improving IT Efficiencies: Four Advantages of Multi-Tenant Data Centers Increasing demands on IT are forcing organizations to rethink their data center options. For many organizations, that means turning to the flexibility afforded...
- Accelerating Cloud Deployment and Operations with Managed Services Companies that do not have sufficient in-house expertise to either deploy or maintain an IaaS cloud should turn to Managed Service Providers .
- Rethinking IT Operations in the Cloud This paper breaks down the challenges that often prevent the cloud from delivering the fast, flexible and affordable infrastructure companies seek - and...
- Gartner Magic Quadrant for Cloud-Enabled Managed Hosting, North America Cloud-enabled managed hosting brings cloudlike consumption and provisioning attributes to the traditional managed hosting market
- NSS Labs & Cisco Present: Evaluating Leading Breach Detection Systems Today's constantly evolving advanced malware and APTs can evade point-in-time defenses to penetrate networks. Security professionals must evolve their strategy in lockstep to...
- Will the Real Endpoint Threat Detection and Response Please Stand Up? This webinar explores new technologies & process for protecting endpoints from advanced attackers as well as the innovations that are pushing the envelope... All Legal White Papers | Webcasts