Privacy expert: It's good PR to say no to the government
IDG News Service - A leading privacy researcher is urging companies to say no to government requests for data, arguing that it's good for business.
"Or rather, saying yes can be really bad for business," said Chris Soghoian, an Indiana University PhD candidate and security and privacy researcher.
Speaking on Monday at a Law Seminars International event in Seattle, Soghoian offered companies tips for handling law enforcement requests for data.
Consumers do care about their privacy and their reaction to news about companies that too willingly help the government access their data -- or resist such requests -- proves it, he said.
For instance, in 2005 it was revealed that a few years earlier the National Security Agency had illegally asked telecom providers to install wiretap equipment in their facilities. Qwest said no. "When the news came out, there was widespread praise for that company and the strong position they took, whereas AT&T and the others were criticized," he said.
In 2004 airline JetBlue voluntarily provided customer data to the Department of Defense. The action led to a lawsuit that was ultimately thrown out, "but in the meantime their name was dragged through the mud," he said.
In addition to bad publicity, such incidents aren't cheap. "Not only do government requests lead to loss of reputation but when you get sued by civil liberties groups and your customers, the government won't pick up the tab," he noted.
In another instance, the Department of Justice asked search engines to reveal information about search terms. Most of the big search engines complied but Google declined, not on privacy grounds but citing proprietary information, he said. "If you ever have the fortune to discuss privacy with a Google privacy person barely two minutes will go by before they tell you about the time they said no to the DOJ. They receive thousands of requests a year that they say yes to, but this one instance they've been able to trumpet," he said.
A lawyer who spoke at the conference on Monday agrees that resisting data requests can be good for business. There is increasing scrutiny from consumer groups about privacy issues and companies may be able to maintain competitive differentiation if they are careful about law enforcement requests and if they are open about their policies, said Daniel H. Royalty, a lawyer at K&L Gates in Seattle. "It may be that increasing transparency in this space can lead to differentiation."
With a bit of forethought, companies can avoid getting into situations that could lead to bad publicity. "Providers have a lot of flexibility in what they do and the way they design their networks and respond to government requests. If you think about this ahead of time, you can spare yourself a bit of heartache," Soghoian said.
- Troubleshooting Common Issues in VoIP Learn more about Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP), including common VoIP metrics used, best practices in VoIP management and tips and tricks for...
- 2013 Network Management Software (NMS) Buyers Guide This white paper contains an independent comparison study of six different network management solutions and provides guidance on how you can choose the...
- Rightsizing Your Network Performance Management Solution: 4 Case Studies This white paper discusses challenges encountered as organizations search for the most cost-effective network performance management solution.
- Global Growing Pains: Tapping into B2B Integration Services to Overcome Global Expansion Challenges A recent survey by IDG Research explored both the challenges and pain points companies face when growing globally, as well as the capabilities...
- E-Signature RFP Checklist Webcast If your organization is looking to adopt e-signatures, you may be overwhelmed by the number of providers that offer seemingly similar solutions. How...
- Cloud and Collaboration: Driving Your Business Value Mission Critical Cloud from Peer 1 Hosting is enterprise-grade. All Security White Papers | Webcasts
Our new bimonthly Internet of Things newsletter helps you keep pace with the rapidly evolving technologies, trends and developments related to the IoT. Subscribe now and stay up to date!