Flawed McAfee update paralyzes corporate PCs

Computerworld - A flawed McAfee antivirus update sent enterprise administrators scrambling today as the new signatures quarantined a crucial Windows system file, crippling an unknown number of Windows XP computers, according to messages on the security vendor's support forum.

The forum has since gone offline.

McAfee Inc. confirmed it had pushed the faulty update to users earlier today. "McAfee is aware that a number of customers have incurred a false positive error due to incorrect malware alerts on Wednesday, April 21," said company spokesman Joris Evers in an e-mail reply to questions. "The problem occurs with the 5958 virus definition file (DAT) that was released on April 21 at 2:00 P.M. GMT+1 (6:00 A.M. Pacific)."

According to users on McAfee's support forum, today's update flagged Windows' "svchost.exe" file, a generic host process for services that run from other DLLs (dynamic link libraries).

"HOW ... do they put a DAT out that kills a *VITAL* system process?" asked someone identified as Jeff Gerard on one thread. "This is ... ridiculous," added Gerard, who identified himself as a senior security administrator at Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co. in Winnipeg, Manitoba. "Great work McAfee! GRRRRRRRRRRR."

As of 3:30 p.m. Eastern time, McAfee's support forum was offline, with a message reading "The McAfee Community is experiencing unusually large traffic which may cause slow page loads. We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause."

Both users and McAfee said that the flawed update had crippled Windows XP Service Pack 3 (SP3) machines, but not PCs running Vista or Windows 7. "Our initial investigation indicates that the error can result in moderate to significant performance issues on systems running Windows XP Service Pack 3," acknowledged Evers.

Affected PCs have displayed a shutdown error or blue error screen, then gone into an endless cycle of rebooting, users claimed.

McAfee reacted by warning users not to download today's update if they haven't already, and by posting recovery instructions and a signature update to suppress the defective one sent to users earlier. "Apply the EXTRA.DAT to all potentially affected systems as soon as possible," the company recommended. "For systems that have already encountered this issue, start the computer in Safe Mode and apply the EXTRA.DAT. After applying the EXTRA.DAT, restore the affected files from Quarantine." Unfortunately, those instructions and the suppression EXTRA.DAT update file are not currently available, again because McAfee's support site has gone dark.

Instead, users can reach the instructions and EXTRA.DAT file from elsewhere on McAfee's site.

"The faulty update has been removed from McAfee download servers for corporate users, preventing any further impact on those customers," Evers said. "We are not aware of significant impact on consumer customers and believe we have significantly limited such occurrence."

The company has yet to produce an updated signature definition file to replace the one that crippled computers.

McAfee is far from the first vendor to ship a flawed signature update. A month ago, a BitDefender update clobbered 64-bit Windows machines. In 2005, Trend Micro released a flawed signature update that slowed PCs to a crawl. In May 2007, a Symantec definition file crippled thousands of Chinese computers when the software mistook two critical Windows .dll files for malware.

McAfee is working to help customers affected by the rogue update, said Evers. "McAfee apologizes for any inconvenience to our customers," he added.

Gregg Keizer covers Microsoft, security issues, Apple, Web browsers and general technology breaking news for Computerworld. Follow Gregg on Twitter at @gkeizer, or subscribe to Gregg's RSS feed . His e-mail address is gkeizer@ix.netcom.com.

Read more about Security in Computerworld's Security Topic Center.