Skip the navigation
News Analysis

With 3G ad lawsuits pulled, so too are punches to AT&T's eye

Battle has underscored need to bolster networks to keep up with data-hungry apps

By Matt Hamblen
December 2, 2009 08:04 PM ET

Computerworld - Attorneys for AT&T and Verizon Wireless agreed today to drop two federal lawsuits over Verizon advertising about its 3G network.

As a result, AT&T avoids getting an even bigger black eye from iPhone users, who have hit the company with complaints about inadequate network coverage. AT&T is the exclusive carrier of Apple's popular iPhone.

Analysts said AT&T's failure in November to win a temporary restraining order from a U.S. district court judge in Atlanta was a sign of how thin its central argument was. AT&T was claiming Verizon's "There's a map for that" ads were misleading by showing 3G coverage maps that used white space outside of AT&T's 3G coverage areas, which implied there was no coverage whatsoever outside of the 3G areas.

Verizon did respond to a request by AT&T to clarify that issue, and started using words at the end of its slew of different ads that read, "voice and data services available outside 3G coverage area."

After that language was added, AT&T's main issue at court seemed even thinner, analysts noted.

IDC analyst Scott Ellison today said that AT&T's position was simply "not defensible" especially since regulators and judges are well aware of AT&T's network deficiencies. Ellison had previously said AT&T has "immolated itself with network capacity issues" especially in crowded urban areas.

The thinness of AT&T's case in the Atlanta court indicated that AT&T "didn't have a prayer of winning," added analyst Jack Gold of J. Gold associates.

While the federal case in Atlanta drew all the attention, there was a second lawsuit that was dismissed today by both companies, according to court records. The second was before a federal district court in New York, filed originally in July.

In the New York case, Verizon was arguing that its advertising slogan of having "America's Most Reliable 3G Network" did not violate a federal law for advertising truthfulness. Verizon filed the lawsuit against AT&T on July 27 after AT&T had filed a challenge on July 1 of Verizon's advertising slogan (and related ones) before the national advertising division of the Council for Better Business Bureaus.

Even though it avoided a second black eye or further injury to itself by withdrawing its lawsuit filed in Georgia, AT&T's filing of that lawsuit helped provoke what may be recorded as one of the fiercest, and funniest, spates of TV ads ever.

After Verizon's first ads aired in October, AT&T reacted by airing its own TV ads with actor Luke Wilson defending its network coverage, and Apple even backed AT&T's network capability for the iPhone in separate ads.

More recently, Verizon kept up the pace and attacks on AT&T with several 3G coverage ads on a Christmas theme, most notably one that invokes "Misfit Toys" and a "Dolly for Sue", who say that the iPhone with AT&T 3G will fit in well in their dysfunctional world. Following up the Christmas ad series, Verizon last week released another that features reindeer.



Verizon 3g coverage ads

Additional Resources
The 2009 Handbook of Application Delivery
WHITE PAPER
Ensuring acceptable application delivery will become even more difficult over the next few years. As a result, IT organizations need to ensure that the approach that they take to resolving the current application delivery challenges can scale to support the emerging challenges. This handbook elaborates on the key tasks associated with planning, optimization, management and control and provides decision criteria to help IT organizations choose appropriate solutions.
How to Cut Software Management Costs and Avoid Over-Spending
WEBCAST
Live Webcast Event: June 9, 2010
Time: 1:00 PM EDT / 11:00 AM PDT
Did you know that companies spend an average of 30% more on software licenses and maintenance than they need to? It's not that surprising when you consider the challenges that IT executives face as they struggle to manage software across their organizations. Poor visibility into remote assets, an inability to ensure the security of PCs, and failing to deliver satisfactory service to end users on a consistent and cost-effective basis are a few of the challenges. Attend this webcast to learn more!
How To Boost Your Bottom Line in Today's Business Climate
WHITE PAPER
In conjunction with Google Enterprise Search, the Google Search Appliance (GSA) can dramatically reduce your organization's total cost of ownership (TCO). By providing search solutions that are deployed on-premise all at one price, GSA can simplify matters and keep costs low. Read this white paper.
What People Are Saying
Mobile and Wireless White Papers
The Laptop Dilemma: How to Maximize Productivity and Lower the Burden on IT
Laptops increase productivity, but they challenge IT security, data management and system administration. Click here for a look at Dell and Intel solutions...
Proactive Patch Management
Read Now.
So, You're Responsible for Managing Laptops
Read Now.
The Human Factor in Laptop Encryption
Download this new White Paper today!
Intelligent Client-Side Defense for Stolen Computers by Intel® and Absolute
Download this new White Paper today!
All Mobile and Wireless White Papers
Mobile and Wireless Webcasts
Managing Laptops Outside the Office
Learn how you can reduce costs by tracking mobile computers no matter where they are located.
2010 Roadmap for Remotely Supporting a Mobile Workforce
Download Now!
Accelerating Your Mobile Workers: Controlling the Uncontrollable
Today's workforce is truly mobile. Unlike the managed environment of the office LAN, remote users face many challenges to being productive while out...
4G Ahead Video Program
Uncover the features and benefits of the two leading 4G technologies for enterprises considering future deployment.
5 Architecture Issues that Impact BES performance
Register to attend this LIVE Webinar to learn 5 Architecture Issues that Impact BES performance!
All Mobile and Wireless Webcasts
IT Jobs