Skip the navigation
News

Network engineers question need for Net neutrality rules

By Grant Gross
October 29, 2009 01:32 PM ET

IDG News Service - New Net neutrality regulations, as proposed by the U.S. Federal Communications Commission, don't make sense because some Internet traffic is already prioritized and needs to continue to be, two networking engineers said Thursday.

Even if the FCC makes rules prohibiting broadband providers from selectively blocking or slowing some Internet traffic, other parts of the Internet will continue to give some traffic priority over other traffic, said David Farber, an engineering and public policy professor at Carnegie Mellon University.

Net neutrality rules, if they were applied across the Internet, could "slow things down incredibly," Farber said during a forum on network management and Internet content at George Washington University in Washington, D.C. In addition, U.S. Internet traffic can route through other countries, and it'd be impossible for the FCC to enforce Net neutrality rules there, he said.

Internet users are moving away from using mainly browsers and e-mail clients, and services such as video conferencing will require dedicated bandwidth, added Richard Bennett, a network engineer and research fellow at the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, a tech-focused think tank. Internet standards allow Web traffic to be prioritized, and it makes no sense to regulate that functionality out of the Internet, he said.

"Applications don't all have the same requirements," Bennett added. "Applications don't all have the same [bandwidth] cost."

Thursday's forum came a week after the FCC voted to begin a proceeding that would create new Net neutrality rules. New rules are needed to protect consumers and preserve innovation from Web application providers, FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski said last week.

Other speakers at Thursday's forum said the concerns expressed by Farber and Bennett were unfounded. The proposed FCC rules don't attempt to impose Net neutrality across all parts of the Internet, instead prohibiting broadband providers from selectively blocking traffic they don't want to carry, said Harold Feld, legal director of Public Knowledge, a digital rights group.

Feld disputed concerns expressed by some panelists that Net neutrality rules would discourage investment in broadband networks. Mobile-phone carriers ran into network congestion problems in the late '90s, but had FCC rules in place saying they had to carry all traffic, he said. Instead of blocking traffic, they built out their networks and acquired more spectrum as a way to deal with the congestion, he said.

Major communications networks in the U.S. have always been open and nondiscriminatory, added Robb Topolski, chief technologist for the Open Technology Initiative of the New America Foundation. Broadband providers should be able to manage their networks but do it without discriminating against some Web applications or content, he said.

The FCC isn't telling broadband providers that they can't provide managed services for high-priority traffic, Topolski said. But the FCC rules would say that broadband providers can't block or slow certain types of traffic on the common Internet, he said.

But Farber questioned the need for new rules, with only two examples of a broadband provider blocking or slowing traffic in recent years. If the FCC continues to challenge bad behavior, as it has done in the past, broadband providers can continue to experiment with network management methods.

Broadband "companies have been reasonable," he said."There are a lot of techies who'd be happy to scream bloody hell if they do something bad."

Reprinted with permission from IDG.net. Story copyright 2012 International Data Group. All rights reserved.
What is Tech Briefcase?
TechBriefcase is a new, free service where IT Professionals can Search, Store and Share IT white papers and content like this. Learn more
Bookmark content
Speed up your research efforts with content across the web.
Search and Store
Find the white papers you need. Create folders for any topic.
View Anywhere
Open your briefcase on your iPhone, tablet or desktop. Share with colleagues.
Don't have an account yet?
Additional Resources
Security KnowledgeVault
WHITE PAPER
Security is not an option. This KnowledgeVault Series offers professional advice how to be proactive in the fight against cybercrimes and multi-layered security threats; how to adopt a holistic approach to protecting and managing data; and how to hire a qualified security assessor. Make security your Number 1 priority.

Read now.

Cut Communications Costs Once and for All
WHITE PAPER
New IP-based communications systems are being deployed by small and midsized businesses at a rapid rate. Learn how these organizations are enabling faster responsiveness, creating better customer experiences, speeding office or mobile interactions, and dramatically reducing existing communications costs.

Read now.

Blog Spotlight
Paul Haugan

Last month I blogged about the partnerships you should build inside your organization. In keeping with that tone it's time we discussed expanding that partnership mentality to include some of the best technical resources you can ever get hold of, those are the ones that work in your neighboring cities, municipalities, counties, regions, townships etc. Come on folks, these people are already doing exactly the same things as you!

Aaron Davis
Dan Lohrmann
Government IT White Papers
Plugging Information Leaks
Unlike traditional data leak prevention solutions, which work at the network or desktop level, Attachmate Luminet software monitors end-user activity at the application...
Shine a Light on Insider Abuse
This solution brief describes the four technical challenges you face and tells you how Luminet can help you overcome them.
Threats from Within Your Government Agency
This solution brief tells how Attachmate Luminet fraud management software can help government agencies and departments get ahead of the fraud curve-by providing...
Finding the right cloud solutions for your organization
HP is driving the evolution of what we call the Instant-On Enterprise. It is an enterprise that embeds technology into everything it does...
Converged Infrastructure for Dummies
As you know, everything is mobile, connected, interactive, and immediate. This is exactly why organizations need a highly agile IT infrastructure in order...
All Government IT White Papers
Government IT Webcasts
Redefine Expectations in the Data Center
Need to do more with less? Watch this video to learn how HP ProLiant Gen8 servers can help your business deploy servers three...
BMC Control-M - Single Point of Control Demo
With BMC Control-M, you schedule and manage everything - down to the very last platform and application - from one simple interface. It's...
Operational Analytics - Changing the Competitive Dynamics of the Business
Date/Time: June 5, 2012, 11:00 a.m., EDT, 4:00 p.m. BST / 3:00 p.m. UTC

Please join us for this webcast, as Dr. Barry...
A Geek's Guide to Presenting to Business People
Live Webcast: Wednesday, June 20th at 1:00 PM EDT

Join this live webinar with Paul Glen, author of Leading Geeks, to learn how to...
Today's NAS: A Solution Beyond Old Limits
Date: Tuesday, July 17, 2012 2:00 PM EDT

Traditional NAS systems don't scale beyond fixed limits. Proliferation of NAS systems leads to management...
All Government IT Webcasts
Newsletter Sign-Up

Receive the latest news test, reviews and trends on your favorite technology topics

Choose a newsletter
  1. View all newsletters | Privacy Policy
IT Jobs