Skip the navigation
News

Judge berates Apple over Snow Leopard timing in Psystar case

Dismisses Apple motion to stop Mac clone maker's lawsuit

By Gregg Keizer
September 25, 2009 03:50 PM ET

Computerworld - A federal judge castigated Apple yesterday in an order that dismissed a motion the company had made in its ongoing legal battle with Mac clone maker Psystar, according to court documents.

In his order, U.S. District Court Judge William Alsup denied Apple's motion to stop an August lawsuit filed by Psystar that accused Apple of illegally tying its new Snow Leopard operating system to Mac hardware.

Alsup also took a shot at Apple, hinting that the company timed Snow Leopard's release to take place after an important deadline had passed in the 14-month lawsuit Apple opened against the small Florida computer maker in July 2008.

Apple had wanted the new lawsuit stopped, arguing that it was "nearly identical to the issues that have been actively litigated in this case." It was referring to the original copyright infringement and software licensing lawsuit filed over Psystar's installation of Mac OS X 10.5, or Leopard, on generic Intel-based computers.

Psystar, which now sells clones with Mac OS X 10.6, aka Snow Leopard, pre-installed, sued Apple in late August, claiming the company monopolized the market for "premium" computers by prohibiting others from using the operating system on non-Apple hardware.

Apple's motion, filed Sept. 11, also asked that the judge reopen the discovery process of the original case, which is being considered by Alsup's California court, to probe Psystar's use of Snow Leopard.

"Psystar deliberately concealed its intention to run Snow Leopard on its computers despite being relevant to Apple's claims and responsive to Apple's many discovery requests," Apple said in its motion earlier this month. "Then, rather than litigate the legality of its conduct in this Court, where the issues already are pending, Psystar has attempted an end-run around this Court's prior rulings by filing a duplicative and baseless lawsuit 3,000 miles away."

Psystar's Snow Leopard-specific lawsuit was filed in a Miami federal court.

But Alsup wasn't having any of Apple's arguments.

"Apple, not Psystar, commenced this action. Apple has fought hard to keep its unreleased product -- Snow Leopard -- out of this action by, among other things, relentlessly objecting to discovery on Snow Leopard," said Alsup in his Thursday order. "If Snow Leopard was within the scope of its own complaint herein, as it now suggests, then Apple should have welcomed discovery thereon rather than, as it did, object to discovery directed at Snow Leopard and effectively taking Snow Leopard out of the case."

Alsup was also suspicious of the timing of Snow Leopard's release date.

"Only after the discovery period closed did Apple release Snow Leopard, having successfully kept it out of the case," said Alsup. "Apple even chose when to release Snow Leopard and it chose to do so after all opportunity to take discovery on it had ended. The problem is one largely of Apple's own making."

Apple launched Snow Leopard on Aug. 28, exactly one week after discovery closed in the California case overseen by Alsup.

Apple's original lawsuit against Psystar is slated to go to jury trial on Jan. 11, 2010.

Read more about Macintosh in Computerworld's Macintosh Topic Center.



Additional Resources
Forrester Consulting - Optimizing Users and Applications in a Mobile World
WHITE PAPER
Solving application issues over the WAN requires careful consideration. Based on their independent research, Forrester Consulting offers recommendations on how to tackle application performance issues, insufficient bandwidth and the inability to quickly restore users in a disaster.

Read now.

Security KnowledgeVault
WHITE PAPER
Security is not an option. This KnowledgeVault Series offers professional advice how to be proactive in the fight against cybercrimes and multi-layered security threats; how to adopt a holistic approach to protecting and managing data; and how to hire a qualified security assessor. Make security your Number 1 priority.

Read now.

Cut Communications Costs Once and for All
WHITE PAPER
New IP-based communications systems are being deployed by small and midsized businesses at a rapid rate. Learn how these organizations are enabling faster responsiveness, creating better customer experiences, speeding office or mobile interactions, and dramatically reducing existing communications costs.

Read now.

Macintosh White Papers
Overcome Top 7 Admin Challenges of Active Directory
As Active Directory's role in the enterprise has drastically increased, so has the need to secure the data. Gain insight on creating repeatable,...
Insiders Can Ruin Your Company. Take Action.
Did you know that 80 percent of threats to an organization come from the inside? The threat from insiders is often overlooked in...
Top Solutions and Tools to Prevent Devastating Malware
Custom malware frequently goes undetected. According to Forrester Research, the best way to reduce risk of breach is to deploy file integrity monitoring...
Streamline Compliance and Increase ROI
Streamline, simplify, and automate compliance related activities; especially those that impact multiple business units. This white paper from NetIQ, outlines solutions that will...
X-Ray of the PCI Process-4 Proactive Steps
This white paper from Forrester Research Inc., helps break PCI into understandable components. Security and risk professionals will gain knowledge and insight into...
All Macintosh White Papers
Macintosh Webcasts
Optimizing Networks for the Cloud
Join guest speaker, Rohit Mehra, IDC Director of Enterprise Communications Infrastructure, to explore current trends, discuss best practices for optimizing Data Center and...
Apps QuickStart Series Part 2: Designing and Deploying SQL Server on VMware vSphere
Download this webcast to learn about the design considerations for virtualizing SQL workloads, performance and scalability information and high-availability options, as well as...
Apps QuickStart Series Part 1: Designing and Deploying Exchange 2010 on VMware vSphere
Download this webcast to learn the virtual hardware design considerations for Exchange 2010, deployment using the building block approach, options for high-availability and...
Customer Spotlight: How IPC The Hospitalist Company Implemented Oracle on VMware
Have you been looking to hear about customer's experiences with the new VMware vCenter Site Recovery Manager product? View this webcast to learn...
Virtualize Business-Critical Applications with Confidence
Virtualizing business-critical applications has become a key focus for organizations as they move along their virtualization journey. With the launch of VMware vSphere®...
All Macintosh Webcasts
Newsletter Sign-Up

Receive the latest news test, reviews and trends on your favorite technology topics

Choose a newsletter
  1. View all newsletters | Privacy Policy
IT Jobs