CIO - While the Apple iPhone is known for its great simplicity, some apps drive users absolutely crazy. The problems stem largely from certain app's poorly designed manipulation of the iPhone's touch features, as well as confusing button placement.
"There's a set of guidelines [developers] can get from Apple that say, here's what icons you should use for these type of functions and here's how you should lay them out," says Bill Westerman, principal and CTO of Create with Context, a design and research firm. "This gets you 70 percent of the way there, but then there's this other 30 percent that are de facto standards which have evolved over time." And if developers don't follow them, user frustration ensues.
[Much to the chagrin of iPhone owners, one analyst predicts Apple will extend AT&T's exclusivity contract, CIO.com reports. | Three iPhone 3GS concerns surface. ]
Create with Context, whose customers include Accenture, Adobe and Yahoo, recently brought iPhone users to its Silicon Valley lab to observe how they interacted with iPhone apps. Researchers found that users in the study became confused due to app and button inconsistencies, buttons with graphic designs that didn't reveal their functions, poorly laid out buttons, screen layouts that lacked visual cues, and, of course, ugly icons that blemished the home screen.
Here's a look at the five most annoying app design flaws:
When it comes to button placement on a screen, users balk at inconsistencies between apps. For instance, touch the "+" button in the Calendar app in the upper right corner and you can create a calendar entry. The same button in the World Clock in the upper right corner brings up a clock for a new time zone. But in the Safari app, the "+" button is at the bottom of the screen, not in the upper right corner where iPhone users have to come to expect it.
The problem gets worse when a similar looking button has different functionality between apps. The main screen in the new Facebook iPhone app, for instance, lets you add buttons linking to preferred pages. In the upper right corner of a preferred page, there's a box with an arrow in it. This button design is commonly used in other apps to send information; many users naturally assume they could send the Facebook page to a friend. But in this case, the button is used for deleting the page from the main screen.
The Facebook problem is often repeated in other apps -- that is, in many apps the graphic design of the button is either misleading or ambiguous.
Free Insider GuideCopyright © 1994 - 2013 Computerworld Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Computerworld Inc. is prohibited. Computerworld and Computerworld.com and the respective logos are trademarks of International Data Group Inc.
