Judge overturns 2007 Unix copyright decision
Network World - A federal appeals court Monday overturned a 2007 decision that Novell owns the Unix code, and the ruling now clears the way for SCO to pursue a $1 billion copyright infringement case against IBM.
In a 54-page decision, the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals said it was reversing the 2007 summary judgment decision by Judge Dale Kimball of the U.S. District Court for the District of Utah, which found that Novell was the owner of Unix and UnixWare copyrights.
How famous OS logos got started
SCO CEO Darl McBride told the Salt Lake City Tribute that the decision was a “huge validation for SCO” and that it would enable the company to continue its lawsuit against IBM and a related suit against Novell.
SCO sells Unix-based software technology and mobile services, including UnixWare for enterprise applications and SCO OpenServer for small and midsize businesses. Just last week, the company released a virtualized version of its OpenServer 5.0.7 Unix operating system.
Monday, the Circuit Court also ruled on other issues in the case and remanded those for trial, including issues around Novell's alleged duty to transfer ownership rights to the computer code in question.
The ruling likely will re-open the company’s litigation of IBM, based on a relationship SCO has with private equity firm Stephen Norris Capital Partners.
In February of last year, Stephen Norris Capital Partners pumped up to $100 million into SCO believing the rulings against the company could be reversed on appeal to a higher court. The firm’s commitment requires SCO to “aggressively continue” its ongoing litigation against Novell and IBM, as well as another case against AutoZone Inc.
The case traces its root to 1993 when Novell paid more than $300 million to purchase UNIX System Laboratories, which owned the UNIX copyrights and licenses.
Two years later, Novell decided to sell the UNIX business to SCO.
The two have differing stories on whether that sale included ownership of the copyright to the code.
In 2004, Novell claimed it owned the rights to Unix after SCO had decided on litigation a year earlier to enforce Unix copyright.
In 2003, SCO claimed that Linux was an illegal derivative of the Unix code, which SCO said it had purchased from Novell. SCO then went head-hunting, picking IBM as its first target in a $1 billion copyright infringement suit claiming Big Blue had violated SCO’s rights by contributing Unix code to Linux.
Microsoft joined the fray shortly thereafter, agreeing to license Unix code from SCO and then using the association to fuel confusion over open source licenses and the liability they could carry for corporate users.
SCO eventually sent letters to some 1,500 large companies, warning them that their use of Linux could infringe on SCO’s intellectual property. SCO then turned on Novell when it claimed Unix ownership.
But that did not go well for SCO.
A summary judgment in the SCO vs. Novell case was issued on Aug. 10, 2007, when Kimball ruled that Novell owned the Unix and UnixWare copyrights. Eventually, the court awarded a $2.5 million judgment to Novell.
Shortly thereafter, SCO filed for Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code.



- Excel 2010 Cheat Sheet
- Register for this Computerworld Insider Cheat Sheet and gain access to hundreds of premium content articles, guides, product reviews and more.
- Optimize Data Backup to Ensure Data Protection
- Protecting data, a top IT priority, is made even more difficult as rapid data growth pushes traditional backup processes beyond their capabilities. Integrating...
- Enabling Storage Flexibility to Better Manage Data Growth
- Virtualizing file storage gives organizations the flexibility and data mobility required to reduce backup windows and costs, improve storage efficiency, and seamlessly integrate...
- Case Study: Publisher Cuts Backup Times by 98 Percent
- Learn how John Wiley & Sons, Inc., a leading publisher for scientific, technical, and medical communities, successfully reduced backup times from 36 hours...
- Case Study: Firm Optimizes Storage, Shrinks Backup Window
- By optimizing its existing storage environment, multi-skilled architectural firm RHWL reduced backup times from 14 hours to 1.5 hours, slashed tape and offsite...
- Indiana University Virtualizes Mission-Critical Oracle Databases
- The Kelley School of Business at Indiana University deployed VMware Infrastructure which decreases costs, streamlines server deployment, and reduces energy consumption. All Data Center White Papers
- Live Webcast
North Pole to South Seas: Overcoming the Pitfalls of remote Performance - In today's always-on world, connectivity is a business requirement. You need the tools that allow you to operate as if you were on...
- Live Webcast
Playing Defense: Staying on Top of Your Disaster Recovery Game - When it comes to disaster recovery, rapidly growing data volumes, distributed computing models, and new technologies all combine to present an ever-changing playing...
- Customer Spotlight: How IPC The Hospitalist Company Implemented Oracle on VMware
- Have you been looking to hear about customer's experiences with the new VMware vCenter Site Recovery Manager product? View this webcast to learn...
- Introduction to VMware View 5
- VMware View™ 5 simplifies IT management while increasing end user freedom by delivering desktop services from your cloud. Building upon VMware's leadership in...
- Reliable Disaster Protection with VMware vCenter Site Recovery Manager
- A simple, cost-effective disaster-recovery solution for virtual environments is high on the agenda for IT organizations as they virtualize more business-critical applications with...
- Introduction to VMware vCenter Site Recovery Manager 5
- Traditional disaster recovery solutions are often too expensive, complex and unreliable to meet business requirements. As a result, IT departments are hesitant to...
- Introduction to Virtualization
- This video webcast is designed to help those with little to no virtualization experience understand why virtualization and VMware are so important to... All Data Center Webcasts