Mozilla execs want changes to Microsoft's 'ballot screen' proposal
They're concerned about Windows Update, download process, Office links
Computerworld - Mozilla executives today began a concerted campaign to prod European Union (EU) antitrust regulators to demand more from Microsoft than the browser "ballot screen" Windows will offer users later this year.
Both Mitchell Baker, the former CEO of Mozilla and the chairwoman of Mozilla Foundation, and Harvey Anderson, Mozilla's chief counsel, posted lengthy blogs, citing concerns with Microsoft's proposal and spelling out changes they want to see.
John Lilly, Mozilla's current CEO, confirmed that the messages from Mitchell and Anderson were part of a company-wide plan. "It's part of our effort to get across our point of view," he said in an interview. "In principle, [Microsoft's proposal] sounds good, but in practice, the way they implement it will make a big difference."
Mozilla's top executives were reacting to a proposal Microsoft submitted July 24, when it told Brussels-based antitrust officials that it would give Windows users a chance to download rivals' browsers.
A key part of that plan would be a "ballot screen" that EU Windows users would see if IE was set as the default browser. Under Microsoft's proposal, the ballot will offer links to downloads of Mozilla's Firefox, Apple's Safari, Google's Chrome and Opera Software's Opera.
In January 2009, the European Commission filed charges against Microsoft, accusing the company of shielding IE from competition by including it with Windows. Since then, Microsoft has made several moves, including offering a "kill switch" in Windows 7 that lets users disable IE, to fend off fines and even tougher antitrust actions against its software.
The commission's charges stemmed from a December 2007 complaint filed by Norwegian browser maker Opera.
Today, Baker, who has been blogging regularly on the topic since January, argued that if the proposal is accepted, IE will still enjoy most-favored-browser status.
"Even if everything in the currently proposed settlement is implemented in the most positive way, IE will still have a unique and uniquely privileged position on Windows installations," Baker said. She listed several aspects of the proposal that trouble Mozilla, including IE's continued prominence on the desktop, the unfair advantage IE would have even if other browsers can be downloaded, and the possibility that Microsoft might try to convince users to switch back to IE through manipulation of Windows Update, the operating system's default update service.
"The importance of the myriad of details makes it very difficult to predict how effective the proposed remedies will be, or the extent of any side-effects," Baker said.
While Baker used broader strokes to paint the proposal as unclear at best, unfair at worst, Anderson got down to specifics. Among his concerns: Windows Update; IE's ties with other Microsoft software, particularly Office; the download conundrum competitors face; and Microsoft's plan not to eliminate IE if the user chooses an alternative.
Browser wars
- Microsoft's IE loses momentum, drops market share
- Chrome jumps into hardware speed-up game
- Update: Mozilla mulls end of support for PowerPC Macs
- Firefox 4 Beta 4 opens a new Panorama
- Microsoft leaks IE9 look, reveals 'Chromifying'
- Google's Chrome speeds up Flash patching seven-fold
- Microsoft to release IE9 public beta on Sept. 15
- Google debuts Chrome 6 beta, trims UI
- Browsers' private modes leak info, say researchers
- Microsoft sets stage for IE9 beta
Microsoft

- Windows 7 Migration Made Easier with Desktop Virtualization
- Read Now.
- Windows Done Right: From Migration to Implementation
- The recent IDC executive brief, "Doing Windows 7 Right: Efficiency from Migration to Implementation" offers a better understanding on how the migration to...
- Lessons Learned from Windows 7 Early Adopters
- According to Windows 7 early adopters, there are benefits to moving to Windows 7 sooner rather than later. But regardless of when you...
- Bit9 Parity Suite vs. Windows 7 AppLocker
- In Windows 7, Microsoft introduces AppLocker, a feature intended to protect endpoints from malware.
Learn how it stacks up to Bit9's best in... - Match.com: Cross-Platform Client Management Made Easy
- Read Now. All Windows White Papers
- A Common Sense Approach to Windows 7
- Listen to this webcast now!
- The Smart Route to Windows 7
- Join IDC analyst Al Gillen as he presents findings from "Windows 7 Done Right: Efficiency from Migration to Implementation" to demonstrate how planning...
- Supporting Business Critical Workloads
- View this webcast discussion on the findings of an IDC Whitepaper sponsored by Microsoft.
- Guiding Principles for Healthcare in Transformation
- EMC Consulting has developed guiding principles for information technology in healthcare provider institutions. These aren't technical points. They're the kinds of guidelines that...
- Desktop virtualization keys innovation drive
- View now. All Windows Webcasts