EFF: Apple's claim that jailbroken iPhones can crash cell towers a 'hill of beans'
More FUD, says EFF, which calls Apple's argument irrelevant to DMCA ruling
Computerworld - The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) took exception today to Apple's claims that "jailbroken" iPhones could cripple a mobile carrier network, calling the argument nothing but "a hill of beans."
Apple's claims came in a filing to the U.S. Copyright Office (PDF document), which is conducting a regular review of the U.S. Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). Last year, the EFF requested an exemption to the DMCA for cell phone jailbreaking.
The EFF, and other technology companies that support it, including Firefox maker Mozilla, want the Copyright Office to let users install applications not available through Apple's App Store on their iPhones without fear of copyright infringement penalties.
Apple has opposed the exemption. Last February, for example, Apple argued that "jailbreaking," the term for hacking an iPhone to install third-party applications not sold through Apple's own App Store, was illegal.
In a written response to questions from the Copyright Office, which posted the document July 22, Apple upped the ante, claiming that jailbroken iPhones could be used by drug dealers to avoid authorities, by hackers to skirt carrier-enforced limitations or even by attackers to crash the software at cell phone towers.
"In short ... [this] would be much the same equivalent of getting inside the firewall of a corporate computer -- to potentially catastrophic result," said Apple. "The technological protection measures were designed into the iPhone precisely to prevent these kinds of pernicious activities, and if granted, the jailbreaking exemption would open the door to them."
"This is all just a lot of fear, uncertainty and doubt," said Fred von Lohmann, an EFF senior staff attorney and the organization's expert in intellectual property law, calling out the words that make up the FUD acronym. "There were no surprises here. Apple's made the same arguments of the copy infringement question, and the rest of it, including the cell tower claims, is essentially irrelevant. Whatever else attacking cell phone towers is, it's not copyright infringement.
"There's nothing that Apple has conjured up that amounts to a hill of beans," von Lohmann added.
He said Apple's claims that jailbroken iPhones could bring down a carrier's tower software was just a hypothetical game. "None of this has ever happened [with jailbroken iPhones]," von Lohmann said. "You don't see the independent iPhone stores filled with malicious software tools. Instead, they're filled with the software that Apple has refused to offer in its App Store."
Ticking off several such applications, including Cycorder, an iPhone program that lets users take video, von Lohmann added Apple's recent rejection of Google Voice, which is now available for both the BlackBerry and Android platforms. And several applications written to leverage Google Voice have recently disappeared from the App Store.
"If we had to live under this kind of regime for computers, consumers would rebel," said von Lohmann. "This isn't about stopping attacks, it's about Apple and AT&T trying to lock out other programs. I can't imagine anything that's any more blatantly anti-competitive."
Von Lohmann was optimistic that the Copyright Office will ultimately approve the EFF's exemption. "In 2006, the Office gave permission to unlock call phones, and I don't see our jailbreaking exemption very different from that," he said. "The FCC and the Department of Commerce are already beginning to smell a rat when it comes to exclusive ties between hardware and software, and the Google Voice exclusion is really a development that will help us."
The U.S. Department of Justice has also reportedly begun investigating how mobile carriers structure exclusivity deals with handset makers, a move that could bar agreements like the one AT&T has with Apple and the iPhone.
The Copyright Office will make its final ruling in October.
Read more about Mobile/Wireless in Computerworld's Mobile/Wireless Topic Center.
- Best iPhone, iPad Business Apps for 2014
- 14 Tech Conventions You Should Attend in 2014
- 10 Desktop Apps to Power Your Windows PC
- How to Add New Job Skills Without Going Back to School
- Slideshow: 7 security mistakes people make with their mobile device
- iOS vs. Android: Which is more secure?
- 11 sure signs you've been hacked
- OpenStack Hype vs. Reality: CIO Quick Pulse Open-source architecture can enable IT departments to build infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS) clouds running on standard hardware.
- The Critical Role of Support in Your Enterprise Mobility Management Strategy Most business leaders underestimate the importance of tech support when they choose an EMM solution. Here's what to put on your checklist.
- Separating Work and Personal at the Platform Level: How BlackBerry Balance Works BlackBerry® Balance™ separates work from personal on the same mobile device, right at a platform level. Find out how it can work for...
- Protection for Every Enterprise: How BlackBerry Security Works Get an IT-level review of BlackBerry® Security, addressing data leakage protection, certified encryption, containerization and much more.
- Live Webcast On-demand webinar: "Mobility Mayhem: Balancing BYOD with Enterprise Security" Check out this on-demand webinar to hear Sophos senior security expert John Shier deep dive into how BYOD impacts your enterprise security strategy...
- Live Webcast Unmasking the Differences between Consumer and Enterprise File Sync & Share The consumerization of IT combined with the rapid pace of the modern mobile workplace is forcing enterprise IT teams to evaluate file sync...
- Live Webcast Workforce Mobilization for Improved Productivity A mobility research director from Aberdeen discusses reasons for extending legacy applications to mobile devices, and an integration strategist from Attachmate shows how...
- Getting Ready for BlackBerry Enterprise Service 10.2 Find out how BlackBerry® Enterprise Service 10 helps organizations address the full spectrum of EMM challenges, while balancing the needs of both the...
- Containerization Options: How to Choose the Best DLP Solution for Your Organization This webcast outlines a framework for making the right choice when it comes to containerization approaches, along with the pros and cons of... All Mobile/Wireless White Papers | Webcasts
As emerging technologies evolve they often find an initial niche in highly specialized scenarios, or in specific industry verticals, before expanding to wider areas of applicability. Within these initial niches, the early adopters can be anything from digital enthusiasts to fashionistas, or they can be folks simply using the technology because it serves a specific need extremely well. (free registration required) more