CompuServe, Prodigy et al.: What Web 2.0 can learn from Online 1.0
By Ken Gagne, Matt Lake
July 15, 2009 06:00 AM ET
Prodigy
Founded: 1984 (as Trintex);1989 (as Prodigy)
Status: Subsumed into AT&T/Yahoo
In the early 1980s, an experiment in shopping and on-demand news delivery using television set-top boxes led three corporations to launch a colorful new online service. It was called Trintex, and unlike older services such as CompuServe and The Source, it wasn't tied to a dull ASCII interface. When it launched in four markets in 1984, this joint venture between IBM, Sears and CBS looked like a consumer product. Within four years, CBS had dropped out of the venture, and the service had a new name -- Prodigy.
Prodigy's colorful splash screens attracted snobby criticism from techies who considered graphical interfaces wimpy and a waste of processing power, but subscribers were drawn to the service because it aggregated the kind of information we now associate with Internet portal pages: news, weather, syndicated columnists, ESPN sports, games, Consumer Reports, and shopping services ranging from groceries to airline reservations. In 2009, this is part of the Internet landscape, but in 1989, it was a hallmark of Prodigy.
Another appealing feature was flat-rate pricing: Instead of charging by the hour, Prodigy offered tiered blocks of services for a flat monthly fee, starting at $9.95.
Despite the fact that subscribers were assigned such alphanumeric salads as PXTB03Z for usernames, Prodigy grew from 100,000 to half a million subscribers in the first year, then doubled to almost a million by 1991. However, Prodigy's subscriber base was fickle, and it suffered major attrition as it increased its monthly rates and began charging for previously free services such as e-mail and chat. The stable subscriber base probably peaked at around 460,000.
The service also lost goodwill when it interfered with the content of postings, deleting posts automatically based on key words without regard to context (zoological forums, for example, had to refer to the beaver by its Latin name).
But Prodigy rallied in 1993 by providing its members access to Internet content, starting with newsgroups and rapidly expanding to include an integrated Web browser. From there, it was a short step for Prodigy to morph into Prodigy Internet, an ISP with specialized content.
It changed ownership a couple of times, ending the millennium as part of SBC Communications. When SBC and Yahoo formed a strategic alliance and portal in 2002, SBC stopped offering new Prodigy accounts but allowed diehard subscribers to retain their @prodigy.net addresses. SBC subsequently purchased AT&T and adopted its brand, so what's left of Prodigy now appears in the att.my.yahoo.com portal and a few e-mail addresses.
NEXT: GEnie
Other early online communities of note
While the online services highlighted in our story set out from the start to be national commercial ventures, most BBSs began as homegrown efforts -- some of which went on to achieve national status anyway. Following are three worth knowing about.
Exec-PC was at one point the largest BBS on the planet, with an estimated million or so subscribers. But it began in 1983 as a 1200-baud Hayes modem hooked up to a 4.77-MHz 8088 IBM PC with a 30MB hard drive. It sat in the den of founder Bob Mahoney's Milwaukee-area home. Exec-PC's main draw was its downloadable files (it had more shareware than anybody else), but it also had hopping social and informational forums. Oddly, it never had live chat -- that feature was available on a parallel service called Exec-PC Chat.
The WELL (Whole Earth 'Lectronic Link), a northern California BBS that grew into a worldwide meeting place, claims to be the birthplace of the online community movement. Its founders were on the bus with author Ken Kesey (One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest), so from its 1985 outset, the WELL drew in subculture denizens from Deadheads to Dada art fans. Arranged into forums called conferences, the community attracted techies and intellectuals of the likes of cyberpunk author Bruce Sterling and Electronic Frontier Foundation co-founders John Perry Barlow and Mitch Kapor. The WELL predictably became an ISP in the early '90s and is now a tiered subscription Web site in the Salon.com network.
Variously called The Jungle and Mofonet, a tiny online bulletin board run by Penn Jillette ("more than half of Penn and Teller") had a certain cachet in the late 1980s. Many people claim to have been regular visitors, but like the hordes of people who claim they saw the Velvet Underground perform in the 1960s, they can't all be telling the truth. You can still find repostings of Mofonet articles on the Web, often on obscure subjects such as whether computing pioneer Vannevar Bush was involved with UFO cover-ups. And really, that's what online communities are all about, right?