Skip the navigation

Google's Chrome OS poses long-term threat to Microsoft

But it will be 'years and years' until it competes with Windows, say analysts

July 8, 2009 12:28 PM ET

Computerworld - Google's entry into the operating system market poses a long-term threat to Microsoft, analysts who cover the maker of Windows said today.

"Will Microsoft be worried? Microsoft will always be worried, whether it should or not," said Michael Silver, Gartner's primary operating system analyst. "Microsoft, after all, is one of the more paranoid companies around."

Late Tuesday night, Google announced that it would launch its long-anticipated operating system, based on the Linux kernel and built around its Chrome browser, sometime in the second half of 2010, more than a year from now. The new operating system will be dubbed "Google Chrome OS."

From Silver's seat, the news will make Microsoft, already locked in competition with Google over search, take notice. But the horizon of a face-to-face OS battle is way out there, he said.

"It will take quite a long time for Google to become a competitor to Microsoft," he said. "In the enterprise, for example, over 70% of the applications used require Windows. And even at home, things like personal finance still require Windows. So, while I think this is a longer-term threat to Microsoft, it's definitely not in the short term."

Michael Cherry, an analyst with Directions on Microsoft, agreed. "It's hard to see this as a threat to Microsoft," Cherry said. "Sure, it could take some sales of netbooks, and previously those netbooks might have had a version of Windows, but it seems like this is not really a platform for applications. The Web is the application."

Both Silver and Cherry, in fact, pointed out that, according to the few pieces of information Google's disclosed so far, applications written for the future Google OS would also run on Windows, or even on Apple's Mac OS X.

The Google executives who announced the company's push into OS waters made that clear. "These apps will run not only on Google Chrome OS, but on any standards-based browser on Windows, Mac and Linux," said Sundar Pichai, vice president of product management, and Linus Upson, engineering director, in their blog post last night.

"Applications written for Google will run on all standard browsers, so you don't even need to use Chrome OS," Cherry pointed out.

That's not to say either analyst was panning Google's move. Both gave the search giant kudos or were confident the company could make a play in the OS arena. "The momentum is on Google's side," said Silver, "because apps are moving away from being OS-specific. But it's taking years. And years."