Domain-name wars: Rise of the cybersquatters
Paul Levins, vice president of corporate affairs at ICANN, calls Deutsche's assertion "mischief making." Use of the newest GTLDs, such as .tel and .mobi, is growing, he says. Plus, two ICANN-commissioned economic impact reports, published in March 2009, show that increased competition would benefit consumers, adds Levins, noting that intellectual property concerns "can be addressed through existing legal mechanisms and appropriately designed ICANN procedures for protecting intellectual property."
Related blog: Why Wolfgang Puck wants his .food network.
But without additional protections, businesses worry that it will be impossible to protect their brand names online in an expanded GTLD universe. Goodendorf, for instance, frets that IHG will be forced to buy the same set of defensive domain names for each new top-level domain. "That will run up our costs even more, [and] it's going to become more confusing for people to find what they're trying to find."
Intellectual property owners complained loudly to ICANN through the IPC, one of several advisory groups to the ICANN board. In response to those concerns, ICANN asked the IPC to come up with recommendations.
It formed the Implementation Recommendation Team, which on May 29 issued a report to ICANN listing suggestions for dealing with the new top-level domains. These include the establishment of a list of trademarked names that can't be sold in the new GTLDs, a provision for rapid takedowns of sites that blatantly violate trademarks, disablement of offending domains instead of transferring ownership and requiring the complainant to pay for their registration, and a complaint mechanism to deal with registrars that don't cooperate with UDRP decisions (see sidebar).
A decision on the report's recommendations is expected, possibly as early as September, following a period of public comment and discussions this summer. It's unclear how many of the report's recommendations will be adopted, but IPC President Steve Metalitz says ICANN has done a good job so far in responding to the concerns of intellectual property holders.
"The board recognized that there is a problem. They won't roll out the new GTLDs until that problem is resolved," he says.
Unfortunately, the proposal applies only to new GTLDs when it's the existing ones that cause the biggest problems, Metalitz says. Even if every recommendation is adopted for the new GTLDs, getting the same rules applied to existing domains like .com will be tough, he adds. "The problem is, you have entrenched interests that are resistant to change," he says.
However, ICANN may be able to apply the new rules as existing registrar contracts expire, Levins says. "We may be able to retrofit the features that are in the new GTLD agreements to address abuse."
Meanwhile, the cybersquatting pandemic shows no signs of abating. While ICANN has made strides in improving oversight through its audits of registrars, the potential financial gains from cybersquatting remain too high and penalties too small to stop the growth in domain-name brand abuse, let alone deter the practice. That's why the IRT recommendations, even if applied to existing top-level domains, aren't likely to completely solve the underlying problem.
But the GTLD issue has intensified the focus on trademark abuse in domain names, and the matter now has ICANN's full attention. So the GTLD proposals could be a catalyst for change -- eventually. For Metalitz and the intellectual property owners he represents at the IPC, those recommendations represent one small step in the right direction.
Correction: This article originally quoted a source naming Sedo.com LLC as a domain registrar that engages in domain parking; however, while the company does buy and sell domain names and offers domain parking services, it is not a registrar.
Read more about Networking in Computerworld's Networking Topic Center.
- Why Dell PowerEdge VRTX for ROBO and Small Offices Remote and branch offices, as well as small business, often have the dilemma of balancing office productivity with the complexity of providing IT...
- Achieve Deeper Network Security and Application Control Next-generation firewalls (NGFWs) have emerged to revolutionize network security as we once knew it. Yet to safeguard an organization from today's ever-evolving threats,...
- It's Who You Know: CDW + CISCO Unified Communications and Collaboration When it comes to unified communications and collaboration, it's not just what you know. It's who you know. That's why we partner with...
- How to Modernize Your IT Infrastructure & Streamline Operations Increasing line of business demands? Shrinking IT budget? See how Red Hat can help you meet growing.
- Live Webcast 5 Steps to Assuring Quality of Experience In order to align monitoring and management practices with the true demands of the business, IT professionals must expand beyond traditional comfort zones...
- Live Webcast Master the Changing SAP Landscape with Performance Management SAP landscapes are not getting simpler. Gradually, business processes that used to be contained on a single SAP system now involve a range...
- Navigating the New Wireless Landscape Thriving in the new wireless landscape View Now>>
- Deep Dive into Advanced Networking and Security with Hybrid Cloud Security and networking are among the top concerns when moving workloads to the cloud. VMware vCloud® Hybrid Service™ enables you to extend your... All Networking White Papers | Webcasts
Our new bimonthly Internet of Things newsletter helps you keep pace with the rapidly evolving technologies, trends and developments related to the IoT. Subscribe now and stay up to date!