Obama's plans for health care IT: Too much money too soon?

More

Obama and tech

• Obama outlines cybersecurity plans, cites grave threat to cyberspace
• Obama's new cybersecurity direction wins praise
• Internet warfare: Are we focusing on the wrong things?
• Obama administration said to consider military cybercommand
• Obama taps Melissa Hathaway for federal cybersecurity review
• IT Blogwatch: Obama's CTO is Aneesh Chopra
• New federal CIO Vivek Kundra wants a Web 2.0 government
• Obama's plans for health care IT: Too much money too soon?

More: Obama tech watch

Computerworld - NEWTON, Mass. -- President Barack Obama's plan to inject $25 billion into the health care industry could create a technological divide between large and small health care organizations, according to doctors and health care professionals. And some worry that his efforts to create a national electronic health records (EHR) system could affect the quality of health care in the U.S.

Those were among the concerns to emerge Thursday at the Massachusetts Health Data Consortium's 2009 Health Information Technology (HIT) Conference here. Several hundred health care professionals attended the day-long conference, which took place as Congress is debating how much money should be included for health care IT in the president's economic stimulus plan.

"This isn't going to be like landing a passenger airplane in the Hudson River with no lives lost; I think there are going to be some casualties," said John Glaser, CIO at Partners HealthCare System Inc., a private collaborative that includes 36 Massachusetts hospitals, specialty and long-term care facilities as well as Harvard Medical School. "There will be some waste. You can't bring that much money into this industry that fast and not have some of that occur."

Glaser, who took part in a panel discussion at the conference, was referring to the fact that health care organizations and individual doctors will start getting incentive money for EHR systems in 2011, giving them less than two years to get ready for the rollout. And that doesn't include figuring out how to coordinate the sharing of sensitive information between caregivers.

The Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act, or HITECH (download PDF), would provide roughly $25 billion for the creation of a national EHR system that would fundamentally change the way medical information is stored and shared among hospitals, private practices and other health care providers. The first $5 billion of the money would go immediately to the Office of the National Coordinator (ONC) for Health Information Technology to lead the way.

Under HITECH, physicians would be eligible for between $40,000 and $65,000 if they show they are using IT to improve the quality of care.

Micky Tripathi, CEO of the Massachusetts eHealth Collaborative, said the money that will go out in 2011 isn't really incentive money for large hospitals that have already rolled out EHRs -- or for those about to roll such systems out. "There's going to be a windfall, because they're basically going to get paid for not changing their behavior all that much," he said.

For smaller health care operations, the gusher of money could lead to a groundswell of technology adoption with little rhyme or reason. "For those who are about to implement [EHR systems] now, one of the issues is, essentially, that this isn't a thousand points of light. This is more like 10,000 bonfires," Tripathi said. "Who helps the solo practitioner, the two-person group, the small hospital?"