Ads by TechWords

See your link here
Subscribe to our e-mail newsletters
For more info on a specific newsletter, click the title. Details will be displayed in a new window.
Networking
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
More E-Mail Newsletters 
 

Update: McCain protests YouTube's removal of his campaign videos

GOP candidate says YouTube acted too quickly to comply with copyright notices that are 'without merit'

October 15, 2008 12:00 PM ET

Active Comments
Anonymous says: He may not personally care about interviews being shown, but he championed the DMCA. If he doesn't like it, he...
Anonymous says: You can't have your cake and eat it to. Republicans have made the copyright laws more stringent, and when that...


Computerworld - Republican presidential candidate John McCain is accusing YouTube LLC of acting too quickly to comply with copyright infringement notices by yanking his campaign videos.

McCain's campaign sent a letter Monday to YouTube parent company Google Inc., protesting YouTube's removal of unnamed videos from the site after receiving take-down notices claiming copyright infringement under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). The McCain camp goes on to suggest that YouTube set up a special process for reviewing the legal merit of take-down requests for YouTube accounts associated with candidates or their campaigns.

The letter asserts that numerous times during the campaign, YouTube removed videos that do not violate the DMCA, but instead are examples of fair use of material because the videos included less than 10 seconds of footage from news broadcasts. The use of material from news broadcasts is protected as fair use under the DMCA, McCain's letter claims, because the videos are noncommercial uses of the material, the material is factual and brief, and the videos don't affect the market for the allegedly infringed material.

"Overreaching copyright claims have resulted in the removal of noninfringing campaign videos from YouTube, thus silencing political speech," according to the letter.

Despite the "complete lack of merit in these copyright claims," YouTube has removed McCain's campaign videos immediately upon receipt of the take-down notices, the letter goes on to note.

"It is unfortunate because it deprives the public of the ability to freely and easily view and discuss the most popular political videos of the day," according to the letter. "Nothing in the DMCA requires a host like YouTube to comply automatically with the take-down notices, while blinding itself from their legal merit."

The McCain campaign went on to propose that YouTube commit to a full legal review of all take-down notices on videos posted from accounts controlled by political campaigns and candidates.

"Surely, the protection of core political speech and the protection of the central role of YouTube has come to play in the country's political discourse is worth the small amount of additional legal work our proposal would require."

In a letter sent yesterday to the McCain campaign, YouTube said that performing a substantial legal review of every DMCA take-down notice that it receives is not a "viable solution."

It is not possible because of the scale of YouTube's operations, the letter said. "Any such review would have to include a determination of whether a particular use is a 'fair use' under the law, which is a complex and fact-specific test that requires the subjective balancing of four factors," the letter said. "No number of lawyers could determine with a reasonable level of certainty whether all the videos for which we receive disputed take-down notices qualify as fair use."

In addition, YouTube does not have the required information about the content in user-uploaded videos, such as the source of the content and ownership rights, to make the determination as to whether a take-down notice includes a valid claim of infringement, YouTube said.



Additional Resources

POLL RESULTS
Accelerate your knowledge of the IT world you inhabit by viewing the results of a series of polls taken by your IT peers. These polls of 100+ IT professionals each are available for full viewing. They cover key topics such as virtualization, processor performance, green IT, cloud computing and many others. Be a part of the buzz.
WEBINAR
Attend this webinar and learn how to:
  • Free up development cycles that can be used to increase the functionality of the application
  • Eliminate the need to develop multiple BIRT web pages that differ only in visual style
  • Create a single BIRT design that shows the same data aggregated and calculated in different ways
  • Attend now!
WHITE PAPER
Utilizing demand intelligence improves the precision of pricing, product assortments, channel/store placement, and promotion, which are all essential for sustainable revenue management performance. Learn more, download this free whitepaper today.

What People Are Saying

White Papers & Webcasts

The 2009 Handbook of Application Delivery
Ensuring acceptable application delivery will become even more difficult over the next few years. As a result, IT organizations need to ensure that...  

Accelerating Your Mobile Workers: Controlling the Uncontrollable
Today's workforce is truly mobile. Unlike the managed environment of the office LAN, remote users face many challenges to being productive while out...

Creating and managing value-driven product portfolios
With such a fine line between success and failure, now is the time to make product portfolio decisions based on fact- not guesswork,...  

Security Configuration Management
In this web video, follow along with Jim Hansen, Senior Product Manager with Big Fix, as he explains why Security Configuration Management is...

iPhone for the Enterprise
One of the biggest concerns of using the iPhone for the enterprise is the security and manageability issues. Read this white paper to...  

How to Reduce Eclipse BIRT Development Effort for Data Visualizations
Web applications can come with a long list of visualization requirements for structured data. By delivering your output through the BIRT Interactive Viewer,...

The Vector Approach to Data Center Power Planning
This white paper describes an approach that considers the major milestones and thresholds in data center power requirements-and how planners should adjust their...  

Disaster Recovery 2008: Reduced Costs and Improved Performance
How long can your Enterprise afford to be without your data? With an accelerated disaster recovery program, you never have to answer this...

Yankee Group Mobile WAN Optimization Report
Mobile work continues to evolve. Learn how to keep up with the demands of your organization's mobile workforce....  

Best Practices for Model-based Systems Engineering
Based on a small set of key principles and practices from the IBM®Rational® Harmony™ library of best practices, the Harmony for Systems Engineering...