RIAA seeks sanctions against defense lawyer in copyright case
Beckerman calls motion 'frivolous,' claims RIAA can't prove its case
Computerworld - In a move likely to further irritate those opposed to the Recording Industry Association of America's controversial anti-piracy campaign, the RIAA last week filed a motion seeking legal sanctions against a lawyer known for vigorously defending alleged copyright violators.
In a motion filed in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, an RIAA lawyer accused New York attorney Ray Beckerman of engaging in "vexatious litigation" in a case involving an alleged copyright violator.
The 31-page motion by the RIAA asked the court to dismiss the case without prejudice and sanction Beckerman and his client for unnecessarily increasing the costs and duration of the lawsuit by filing false statements, making "frivolous motions" and fighting "good faith" attempts by the RIAA to uncover evidence.
The RIAA claimed that it was being forced to seek dismissal of the case because of the loss of a critical computer and because of the "defendant's obstructionist" strategies, both of which had irreparably hurt its ability to prove its claims. The motion noted that the case would not have lasted so long or cost so much to both sides if Beckerman and his client had provided the information sought by the RIAA in a timely and complete fashion.
In seeking sanctions against Beckerman, the RIAA noted that Beckerman's habit of posting details about all his "baseless motions" on his blog site "demeans the integrity of these judicial proceedings and warrants this imposition of sanctions."
The sanctions were needed to "punish Defendant and her counsel for their intentional misconduct and to discourage others from engaging in similar behavior," the RIAA noted in its brief.
Beckerman today dismissed the complaints as frivolous and said the only reason the RIAA is seeking to drop the case is because they are unable to prove the alleged copyright violation.
The case in question is UMG Recordings Inc. et al vs. Marie Lindor and dates back to 2005, though Beckerman only started representing Lindor in 2006. The RIAA accused Lindor, a home health aide from Haiti, of using her home computer to illegally download and distribute copyrighted music.
Initially, it was Beckerman who asked for dismissal of the case on the grounds that the recording companies had failed to provide evidence that Lindor engaged in copyright infringement.
"What's going on here is that they have been chasing an innocent woman for three years for nothing," Beckerman said. "I have repeatedly asked them to drop the case and they refused," he said. He repeatedly informed the RIAA that Lindor was computer illiterate and had not so much as switched on a computer at the time of her alleged infringement, he said.
- Securing Mobility, From Device to Network At one time, the process of managing and securing mobile devices and applications was fairly straightforward. Most organizations worried about one application (email)...
- Data Protection eGuide In this eGuide, CSO and sister publications IDG News Service, Computerworld, and CIO pull together news, trend, and how-to articles about the increasingly...
- Warning: Cloud Data at Risk Experts agree that relying on SaaS vendors to backup and restore your data is dangerous. Yet that's exactly what huge portions of the...
- The Opportunities and Challenges of the Cloud In this report F5 poses questions to IDC analysts, Sally Hudson and Phil Hochmuth, on behalf of F5's customers to better understand the...
- What should I look for in a Next Generation Firewall? SANS Provides Guidance With so many vendors claiming to have a Next Generation Firewall (NGFW), it can be difficult to tell what makes each one different....
- Responding to New SSL Cybersecurity Threat The featured Gartner research examines current strategies to address new SSL cybersecurity threats and vulnerabilities. All Security White Papers | Webcasts
Our new bimonthly Internet of Things newsletter helps you keep pace with the rapidly evolving technologies, trends and developments related to the IoT. Subscribe now and stay up to date!