Researcher: Chrome's isolated tabs make it memory 'pig'
But he credits Google with efficient use of processor threads
September 3, 2008 12:00 PM ET
- Continuing coverage: Google's Chrome browser
- Review: Google's Chrome -- the first true Web 2.0 browser
- FAQ: Google polishes up its new browser, Chrome
- Researcher: Chrome's isolated tabs make it memory 'pig'
- Chrome grabs 1% of browser market in under 24 hours
- John Brandon: Chrome is Google 2.0
- Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols: Google Chrome: First run around the track
- Seth Weintraub: Google Chrome is a mixed bag for Apple
- First Look: Is Google's Chrome a glimpse of the future?
- Google's Chrome aims to kill Windows, make Web the OS of choice
Computerworld - Google Inc.'s new Chrome browser chews up more memory than even Microsoft Corp.'s recent Internet Explorer 8 Beta 2, a researcher said today.
"Chrome's a pig," said Craig Barth, chief technology officer at Devil Mountain Software Inc., a Florida-based maker of PC performance-testing software. "Like IE8 Beta 2, it's targeted at the next generation of hardware, not older PCs running Windows XP on a half-gig of RAM."
Barth ran Chrome, the new Google browser released Tuesday, through the same 10-site scenario Devil Mountain used earlier in the week to benchmark the memory footprint and processor thread count for IE8 Beta 2, IE7 and Mozilla Corp.'s Firefox.
In the test, each browser opened the 10 sites -- including media-rich domains such as Boston.com, Channel9.com, CNet.com, InfoWorld.com and NYTtimes.com -- in separate tabs, with links on those sites opened in additional tabs.
Chrome's peak memory consumption under Windows XP was 324MB, slightly less than IE8 Beta 2's 332MB, Barth said today, but the Google browser's average footprint of 267MB was 26% larger than IE8's 211MB.
In Monday's test, IE8 Beta 2 consumed far more memory than other browsers -- 52% more than IE7, for example -- and easily led all others in the dubious honor. At the time, Barth called IE8 "epically porcine."
But even though Chrome tipped the scales even more dramatically than IE8, Barth was willing to cut Google some slack. "It's going to be fat by virtue of what they're trying to do," he said, noting that Chrome eats more memory because it essentially opens a separate instance of the browser for each tab, a design Google said it used to segregate tabs, and the sites on them, so that if one crashes the browser as a whole does not.
"It's going to be fat, but you have got to give Google credit for doing [the browser] from scratch," Barth noted. "It's fat by design, and they come out and say that. 'We're willing to isolate each tab,' Google says, so you know that and expect it."
As he did with the other browsers, Barth also tallied the processor threads that Chrome spawned. The numbers, he said, "befuddled" Devil Mountain.
"Given its use of a multiprocess model [similar to IE8's], we would have expected Chrome to introduce a comparable thread workload," he said. "[But] we were surprised that Chrome had spun a much more manageable 48 execution threads at the peak."
In comparison, Firefox and IE7 spawned 25 and 43 threads, respectively, while IE8 Beta 2 spawned a whopping 153.
Barth praised Chrome's each-tab-is-separate design. "It's a completely modular architecture," he said. "Our guess is that the initial 25 threads handle the user interface functions, bookmarking, all the basic stuff, but then beyond that, it uses just two threads for each tab." All told, Chrome spun off 12 discrete instances of itself to handle the 10 test tabs.
Additional Resources



White Papers & Webcasts
Moving Beyond Monolithic White Paper
What's next for enterprise application architecture? Learn Now.
The Workday User Experience Video
Watch Workday's Creative Director, Scott Lietzke, discuss the business-centered design philosophy at Workday.
The ROI of Software-As-A-Service - Forrester Research
Learn if SaaS has a long-term value. Read now.
Virtualize Microsoft Applications on VMware
Register for this live webcast now!
Global at the Core White Paper
Learn the business and technology benefits of Workday's global approach to enterprise applications.
A Unified Approach to Application Performance
Watch this webcast today!
The Workday User Interface White Paper
Read how Workday re-invents the user experience in enterprise applications.
Aligning IT to Business: The Rising Importance of Application Delivery Networks
Application Delivery Networking (ADN) will play a vital role in helping enterprises incorporate strategic technologies to achieve business initiatives.
Measurement Specialties
Download this case study!
Preparing Your Business Services for the Future
Would you trust your network monitoring tools enough to know when something is truly halting a business service?
Computerworld Reports
Disaster Recovery & Cost Savings Zone
Thousands of customers world-wide have turned to virtualization solutions from Riverbed as a way to reduce costs.

