Skip the navigation

Kaminsky: DNS bug tattler not the first to guess flaw details

Two weeks of silence helped, says researcher who found critical flaw

July 23, 2008 12:00 PM ET

Computerworld - The researcher whose speculation led to an early disclosure of information about a critical flaw in the Domain Name System (DNS), the Internet's traffic cop, wasn't the first to come close to the truth, said the security expert who found the bug and organized a massive patching effort.

"'Halvar [Flake]' was not the first, not even the tenth," said Dan Kaminsky, director of penetration testing at Seattle-based IOActive Inc. and the researcher who uncovered the DNS flaw early this year. He also helped coordinate a multivendor patching process that kicked off two weeks ago. "A lot of other people figured this out first," Kaminsky said.

On Monday, Flake, the hacker moniker of Thomas Dullien, CEO of the German security company Zynamics GmbH, took a stab at the flaw and posted his best guesses about its details and how it might be exploited. Later on Monday, Flake's speculations were confirmed by Matasano Security, a consultancy that included at least one researcher who had been briefed on the bug by Kaminsky several days later.

"I asked [others who had guessed the details] to hold off until Black Hat," said Kaminsky late Tuesday. "I really have to express my appreciation to them. The security community did not speak with one voice. Many [researchers] realized the importance of this."

When Kaminsky first announced the bug, he said he would provide technical details on Aug. 7 at the Black Hat security conference in Las Vegas. At the time, he said he wanted to give administrators a month to patch before he got specific about the bug.

Kaminsky seemed to bear no ill will toward Flake for posting details of the DNS flaw. "I'm not going to say it was irresponsible," said Kaminsky of Flake. "It's his blog, and he can say what he wants on it. I can only ask [that others hold information]; I can't demand. My only regret is that I didn't have more of an opportunity to talk to him before he posted."

Kaminsky said he and Flake had traded e-mails before Flake went public.

Immediately after Flake's post and Matasano's confirmation, Kaminsky urged administrators responsible for DNS servers to patch immediately, a recommendation he repeated Tuesday. "There's definitely [more of] an increased risk than there was two days ago," he said. "I would advocate doing what you can [to patch now]. I tried to give you as much time as I could. I knew that 30 days was not going to be enough, but we didn't get them. But 13 was better than zero."

He was referring to the nearly two weeks between Flake's posting and availability of patches from Cisco Systems Inc., Internet Systems Consortium Inc. and Microsoft Corp.



Our Commenting Policies