Microsoft warns users of coming update to Windows Update

Computerworld - Microsoft Corp. has announced that it will upgrade Windows' update mechanism later this month, a warning that comes nearly a year after the company issued a similar upgrade without informing users.

Last September, reports that Microsoft conducted a "stealth" update of its Windows Update (WU) service angered users and put the company on the defensive.

"Beginning at the end of this month and continuing over the next few months, we'll be rolling out an infrastructure update to the Windows Update agent," said Michelle Haven, a product manager in the Windows Update group, in a post to the team's blog late last Thursday.

Haven went on to say that the update would affect both Microsoft's back-end update infrastructure as well as the client-side software necessary to use WU directly or access it through a Windows Server Update Services (WSUS) server. She also said that users would see few, if any, visible changes in the WU software or process, but that scanning performance would improve. "We've invested heavily in reducing the amount of time it takes the Windows Update agent to scan to see if new updates are available," she said. "We've seen some instances of the scan times on some machines decreasing almost 20%."

Microsoft revises the WU infrastructure and client software annually, said Haven.

Haven's prerelease announcement was in stark contrast to what happened last year, when users raised a ruckus after discovering that Microsoft had updated files related to the Windows Update client even when they had disabled the operating system's automatic installation option.

Microsoft's response then was that it had engaged in the practice before and that the client-side software needed to be updated — no matter what the user settings — in order to guarantee receipt of future security patches.

Haven made the same case last week. "To avoid a false sense of security, the Windows Update client automatically checks for and installs any available infrastructure updates anytime a system uses the Windows Update service, independent of the settings for how it handles updates," she said.

The only setting that will not result in the WU client software being updated, Haven added, is the "off" option, which is labeled "Turn off Automatic Updates" in Windows XP and "Never check for updates" in Windows Vista.

Some users weren't happy, even with Microsoft's advance notice. "It [is] unfortunate you didn't take the opportunity of XP SP3/Vista SP1 to fix this obviously incorrect behavior and regain users' trust, especially after the contraversy [sic] this caused back in September," said a user identified only as "Thingy" in a comment to Haven's post. "As it is, you are still ignoring an explicit user instruction to 'don't download or install things on my machine without my permission'."

Last year, after the initial reports of WU's stealth updating, Microsoft acknowledged that it could have done a better job informing users. "The point of this explanation," said Nate Clinton, a WU program manager in September 2007, "is not to suggest that we were as transparent as we could have been; to the contrary, people have told us that we should have been clearer on how Windows Update behaves when it updates itself.

"We are now looking at the best way to clarify WU's behavior to customers so that they can more clearly understand how WU works," he added at the time.

Enterprises that rely on WSUS servers to get patches and hot fixes to users will also be affected by the WU software update, noted another Microsoft manager.

"WSUS-managed end-user[s] who navigate to WU to perform an interactive sync will receive an updated version of WUA [Windows User Agent] as this new agent is rolled out over the next few months," said Marc Shepard, a program manager in the WSUS group, in a separate post on Monday. "Machines whose end users don't explicitly navigate to WUA to perform an interactive scan will continue to use the existing version of WUA. This will result in a mixture of WUA versions in most corporate environments."

Shepard said that the mix shouldn't matter, since the new version of WUA, the WU client software, is backward-compatible and will continue to connect with WSUS servers.

Read more about Windows in Computerworld's Windows Topic Center.