'PatentGate,' one year later: Microsoft against the open-source world
Has Microsoft advanced its legal claims to those 235 patents?
Computerworld - It was just over a year ago that Microsoft Corp. dropped a bombshell of a claim: users of Linux and open-source software were unwittingly violating as many as 235 Microsoft software patents.
"This is not a case of some accidental, unknowing infringement," Horacio Gutierrez, Microsoft's vice president of intellectual property and licensing, told Fortune magazine at the time. "There is an overwhelming number of patents being infringed."
Releasing a count of the allegedly infringed patents added a bit of specificity to Microsoft's longstanding contentions that Linux uses its intellectual property. Since then, critics say, the software vendor has played the "good cop, bad cop" routine with the open-source camp.
For example, promising not to sue customers of eight vendors that had signed cross-licensing deals with Microsoft for potential open-source-related violations? Good cop. But continuing to refuse to publicly reveal what those alleged patent violations are? Bad cop.
Here's another: Announcing in March that open-source developers will now be able to use hundreds of Microsoft software protocols without a license for noncommercial use? Good cop. CEO Steve Ballmer telling customers of licensing holdout Red Hat Inc. last October that they "have an obligation to compensate" Microsoft for IP violations? Bad, bad cop.
Gutierrez, interviewed late last week, said that Microsoft's hot-and-cold engagement with the open-source community is neither "intentional" nor "inherently contradictory."
"We spend $7 billion a year on research, development and cranking out innovations," he said. "We need to protect our innovations against people who infringe upon them."
But legal eagles in the open-source camp argue that Microsoft's moves, even its ostensibly positive ones, have done little to bolster its patent claim.
"Claiming you have IP that folks are infringing isn't the same thing as proving it," wrote Pamela Jones, author of the open-source legal blog Groklaw.net, in an e-mail. "I think they [Microsoft] are in a weaker position because they did the [cross-licensing] deals. It makes them look needy, like they can't make it any more without Linux."
"The [legal] threat [to open source] is no greater" today than a year ago, wrote Mark Radcliffe, a lawyer with DLA Piper's Silicon Valley office and the general counsel of the Open Source Initiative, in an e-mail.
Take Microsoft's attempts to persuade vendors to sign cross-licensing deals that include protection from potential open-source patent lawsuits by Microsoft.
Besides Novell Inc. and Fuji Xerox Co., which both had signed deals before "PatentGate," other cross-licensees include Asian consumer electronics makers Samsung Electronics, Kyocera Mita and LG Electronics, and a trio of smaller Linux makers, including Turbolinux, Linspire Inc., and Xandros Inc. and its Scalix subsidiary.
- Building a New Era in Enterprise IT As the digital revolution spawned by the explosive growth of disruptive technologies such as mobile, cloud, social, and analytic tools continues to fundamentally...
- Mobile First: Securing Information Sprawl Learn how the partnership between Box and MobileIron can help you execute a "mobile first" strategy that manages and secures both mobile apps...
- AIIM Trendscape: The New Mobile Reality This AIIM Trendscape report shares data, expert opinions, and a unique perspective on the impact of cloud and mobility in the enterprise, surfacing...
- Empowering Your Mobile Workers A modern mobile IT strategy is no longer an option, it is an absolute necessity. Here's how some of the nation's most progressive...
- NSS Labs & Cisco Present: Evaluating Leading Breach Detection Systems Today's constantly evolving advanced malware and APTs can evade point-in-time defenses to penetrate networks. Security professionals must evolve their strategy in lockstep to...
- Will the Real Endpoint Threat Detection and Response Please Stand Up? This webinar explores new technologies & process for protecting endpoints from advanced attackers as well as the innovations that are pushing the envelope... All Legal White Papers | Webcasts