Newsletter Sign-Up

Receive the latest technology news and information.

OS Smackdown: Linux vs. Mac OS X vs. Windows Vista vs. Windows XP

Four experts defend their chosen operating systems in an opinionated free-for-all

By Michael DeAgonia, Preston Gralla, David Ramel and James Turner

April 8, 2008 12:00 PM ET

Dig in

Linux
Light on its feet and ready to strut its stuff
Mac OS X
All you need in one dynamite package
Windows Vista
The best there is (despite the bad rep)
Windows XP
Hands down, the choice of the people
Vote in our reader poll
You tell us: Which desktop OS is the best?

Computerworld - Since the dawn of time -- or, at least, the dawn of personal computers -- the holy wars over desktop operating systems have raged, with each faction proclaiming the unrivaled superiority of its chosen OS and the vile loathsomeness of all others.

No matter how fierce the language or convincing the arguments, however, these battles began to seem somewhat irrelevant to regular working stiffs. While Mac OS, OS/2, Linux and many other desktop operating systems have all had their devotees over the years, the truth is that the majority of home and business users have simply used the current version of Windows as a matter of course.

Windows Vista has changed all that. Never has a Microsoft operating system been greeted with such a lack of enthusiasm from consumers and businesses alike. Whether it's because of Vista's confusing array of versions, its hefty hardware requirements, its driver issues or its invasive security features, users are resisting the upgrade to Vista and considering other options, from Mac OS X to Linux to just sticking with Windows XP, thank you very much.

Suddenly, the OS wars have a new relevance.

That's why we've asked four experts to lay out their best arguments in support of their desktop operating systems of choice:

Each is positive that his operating system is the best and will try his hardest to convince you of that -- and is not above taking a few swipes at the competition. These are not rational, disengaged reviews; these are opinionated essays meant to sway your point of view.

When you've read all the arguments, you make the call by voting in our reader poll -- and of course we welcome your own arguments in the comments area as well.

-- Valerie Potter

Comment Recommend Digg Twitter ShareThis

Email Print Send Feedback Reprints

Jump to comments

Linux

Additional Resources

WHITE PAPER

EFD vs. HDD - What You Need to Know

Enterprise flash drives provide a new Tier 0 storage layer capable of delivering high I/O performance at a very low latency. Proper use of EFDs in an Oracle environment can deliver increased performance compared to fibre channel drives. Read the recommendations for identification of the best DB components for EFDs.

WHITE PAPER

Gartner Research Report: Magic Quadrant for Application Delivery Controllers, 2009

The market for products to improve the delivery of application software over networks remains dynamic and innovative. Vendors focused on solving enterprises' most-pressing application problems have become the top players.

WHITE PAPER

Eight Criteria for Server Load Balancing

Server load balancers are a simple yet highly effective means to scale an application environment while ensuring its availability. Today's solutions should also address application performance and security. Read about the top eight criteria you should consider when choosing a server load balancer and how Citrix NetScaler meets those requirements.

What People Are Saying

348 comments | Add new

See all comments (348) | Add new

White Papers & Webcasts

High Performance for Integrating Massive Data Volumes
Processing very large data sets provides unique constraints, especially when time windows available for this processing are shrinking. This Technical White Paper presents...

Gartner Podcast: Driving SharePoint Adoption in Lotus Notes Shops
Learn how can you drive mainstream user adoption of Microsoft SharePoint when your users are committed to using email.

Improve Operational Efficiencies
Download Now

IDC Webcast: Linux Adoption in a Global Recession
Access this webcast, compliments of Novell and HP, for a limited time only!

Whitepaper: Drive SharePoint Adoption in Lotus Notes Shops
Learn how you can drive your users to Microsoft SharePoint when they rely on IBM Lotus Notes.

Bringing Order and Security to your Mobile Workforce: Corporate Mobility Policy and Device Management
Download this webcast, free, compliments of Nokia.

7 Tricks and Tips for Windows 7 - Part 1
Download Now

Data in Action: Making the Planet Smarter
Register Now

7 Tricks and Tips for Windows 7 - Part 2
Download Now

Hosted Security Services: Why it make budget and security sense in today's economy
Watch Now

All White Papers | All Webcasts